Amber Heard didn’t want Johnny Depp to pay US$100mil. She wanted to send a message


By AGENCY

Jurors are being asked to decide if physical abuse took place as well as whether Amber Heard’s Washington Post story legally defamed Johnny Depp. Photos: Reuters

Amber Heard isn’t really asking for the US$100mil she sued Johnny Depp for. Her lawyer said Friday (May 27) that they simply asked for that amount to send a message to the Pirates Of The Caribbean star after he asked for half that amount when he sued her for defamation.

That information came Friday in a Virginia courtroom as legal teams for the former spouses registered their closing arguments in their duelling defamation cases.

“Johnny Depp sued for US$50mil, and we sent a message back saying, ‘Fine, then we’re gonna sue for US$100mil because look what you did to her.’ We’re not asking you to give US$100mil,” attorney Elaine Bredehoft told the jury, speaking about compensatory damages.

“We’re asking you to just look at the damages in this case and just be fair and reasonable in whatever you determine.”

The case, which kicked off April 11 in Fairfax, Virginia, went to the jury Friday afternoon.

While Depp’s side has painted the case as being about getting his life and reputation back, Heard’s side has argued that it’s a First Amendment case about the right to tell one’s own story.

Amber Heard’s legal team has argued that it’s a First Amendment case about the right to tell one’s own story. Photo: AFPAmber Heard’s legal team has argued that it’s a First Amendment case about the right to tell one’s own story. Photo: AFP

Heard attorney Benjamin Rottenborn led off the defendant’s closing arguments by warning the jurors about the message they would be sending to victims of domestic abuse if they found in Depp’s favour.

“If you didn’t take pictures, it didn’t happen. If you did take pictures, they’re fake. If you didn’t tell your friends, you’re lying. If you did tell your friends, they’re part of the hoax. If you didn’t seek medical treatment, you weren’t injured.

"If you did seek medical treatment, you’re crazy,” Rottenborn said.

“If you do everything that you can to help your spouse, the person that you love, rid himself of the crushing drug and alcohol abuse that spins him into an abusive, rage-filled monster, you’re a nag.

"And if you finally decide enough is enough, you’ve had enough of the fear, enough of the pain and you have to leave to save yourself, you’re a gold digger.”

Rottenborn called the case “victim-blaming at its most disgusting.”

Johnny Depp’s side has painted the case as being about getting his life and reputation back. Photo: ReutersJohnny Depp’s side has painted the case as being about getting his life and reputation back. Photo: Reuters

He also replayed the notorious video of Depp wandering around a kitchen, slamming cabinet doors, pouring himself a large glass of wine and getting angry when he realised Heard was recording his actions.

“Who does that? Who does that?” Rottenborn asked the jurors. “Imagine watching your husband, the person you love, behaving violently that way. Like a wild animal. That is abuse. That’s abuse.”

Those statements came after Depp’s attorneys argued that he was the actual victim in the relationship.

“There is an abuser in this courtroom, but it is not Mr. Depp,” attorney Camille Vasquez said. “And there is a victim of domestic abuse in this courtroom, but it is not Ms. Heard.”

Later, Vasquez painted the team’s allegations against Heard more plainly. “Ms. Heard lied,” she said. “And she lied again. And she kept lying.”

Heard allegedly lied, Vasquez said, when she asked for the temporary restraining order in 2016, when she said she donated her entire US$7mil divorce settlement to charity and when she wrote the 2018 Washington Post op-ed around which Depp’s case revolves. (The case is being argued in Virginia because the state is home to the news outlet’s servers.)

Dan Kim, 26, holds a sign in support of Amber Heard amidst throngs of Johnny Depp fans, outside the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse on the final day of the defamation trial of Johnny Depp versus Amber Heard. Photo: ReutersDan Kim, 26, holds a sign in support of Amber Heard amidst throngs of Johnny Depp fans, outside the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse on the final day of the defamation trial of Johnny Depp versus Amber Heard. Photo: Reuters

“She’s come too far. She can’t back down. She’s lied too many times to too many people,” Vasquez said.

“So when Mr Depp finally decided to fight, to clear his name by filing this lawsuit, Ms. Heard responded by making up more and more stories of more and more extreme abuse.

"She came up with a new accusation that Mr. Depp had raped her with a bottle in Australia, and she keeps making new claims up even now.”

After listing the 16 witnesses who had stood up in court for Depp either in person or via live video, including ex-girlfriend Kate Moss, the Depp team later said that except for Heard’s sister, Whitney Henriquez, “no one showed up for Ms. Heard in this courtroom” other than witnesses who were paid to testify.

Heard’s team presented its case in large part via prerecorded video depositions.

Actor Johnny Depp greets courtroom staff after closing arguments during his defamation case against ex-wife Amber Heard. Photo: ReutersActor Johnny Depp greets courtroom staff after closing arguments during his defamation case against ex-wife Amber Heard. Photo: Reuters

Depp attorney Ben Chew, during his turn in front of the jury, categorised the case as “the unique and singular #MeToo case where there’s not a single ‘me too,’” as in no other women who came forward to similarly accuse Depp of abuse.

Chew also noted that after the #MeToo movement hit in 2017, producers knew better than to hire anyone who had been accused of abuse, implying that Heard’s 2018 op-ed had placed Depp into a category where he didn’t belong – one that allegedly cost him tens of millions of dollars in acting work.

Rottenborn returned in his rebuttal to remind the jury about how Heard’s career had allegedly suffered after comments were made by former Depp attorney Adam Waldman.

“Studios like her. Co-stars like her. She tests well. But she can’t get opportunities because of the negativity associated with Mr. Depp and Mr. Waldman,” he said.

Amber Heard’s team presented its case in large part via prerecorded video depositions. Photo: AFPAmber Heard’s team presented its case in large part via prerecorded video depositions. Photo: AFP

Judge Penney Azcarate – who kicked off Friday by reading the jury its instructions about how to decide the case – had strongly hinted the day before that the jury shouldn’t argue past dinnertime each day and instructed them to decide what time they would return to deliberations after the Monday holiday.

In Virginia, a seven-person civil jury must reach a verdict unanimously. The jury in this case will decide the defamation claims for both actors simultaneously.

It’s not clear when the verdict will be decided, though presumably it could happen next week. – Los Angeles Times/Tribune News Service

Fans of Johnny Depp and their pets wait to get a glimpse of the actor at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse. Photo: ReutersFans of Johnny Depp and their pets wait to get a glimpse of the actor at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse. Photo: Reuters

Article type: free
User access status:
Join our Telegram channel to get our Evening Alerts and breaking news highlights

Johnny Depp , Amber Heard , trial

   

Next In Entertainment

Actress Jerry Hall files for divorce from billionaire Rupert Murdoch
'Thor: Love And Thunder' release date postponed to July 21 in Malaysia, two weeks after movie premieres worldwide
Single's Inferno's Song Ji-ah uploads her first YouTube video 5 months after fake luxury good scandal
Cameron Diaz is 'Back In Action,' comes out of retirement to star in new film with Jamie Foxx
'Lost' actress Kim Yun-jin says she 'suffered and struggled a lot' working in other countries
Sharon Stone opens up about losing 9 children through miscarriages
Malaysian wonder boy 'Ejen Ali' inspires not only viewers but creators themselves
'Loki' star Tom Hiddleston and fiancee expecting their first child
Dakota Johnson says she signed up for a 'very different' 'Fifty Shades Of Grey' movie
Amber Heard is supposedly the 3rd most beautiful woman in the world, behind Bella Hadid and Beyonce

Others Also Read