Have you ever stubbed your toe or tripped over something, only for someone to offer the advice, “Be careful” once it’s too late? Or maybe you’ve been leaning against a wall you didn’t know was freshly painted, and a friend helpfully warns you, “Watch out, that’s still wet!”
Such reactions are reflexive, meant to protect from further damage, but I’m sure you’ll agree it’s irritating to receive redundant advice.
A particular pet peeve of mine is when I’m worried or stressed about something and I’m told not to worry or – worse! – to “just relax” when I’m feeling anything but.
Of course, I’m guilty of this myself at times, and it’s something I try hard to avoid, mainly because I know it can feel like nails being scraped down a board. Being a licensed counsellor, I also have less of an excuse to be unaware of how clumsy reassurance can – and does – make people feel worse.
Some time ago, a friend of mine was feeling anxious about having to undergo minor surgery. He said, “People keep telling me to stop worrying and that it’s just a routine operation, but I can’t help it”.
In reply, I said: “Of course you can’t help it – I’d be anxious, too. It’s easy for them to say not to worry, they’re not the ones going for the surgery.”
It sounds counterintuitive to say, but my friend seemed reassured precisely because I hadn’t reassured him. Instead, I showed that I understood his feelings without needing to correct them. In therapy, this is known as “reflection”. Reflection involves listening carefully to someone’s experience and communicating your understanding of what they’re feeling without immediately trying to offer advice or fix their problem.
Reflection helps people feel understood and accepted, making it easier for them to speak openly about their experiences. In therapy and everyday relationships, this can help build trust, particularly when someone feels their emotions are being taken seriously, without any pressure to change or justify what they’re feeling.
When we jump in to correct a person’s experience, we send them the message that what they’re feeling or how they’re reacting is wrong. Would you receive that message well?
In 2021, I had the pleasure of interviewing American clinical psychologist Dr William Miller for a podcast. He’s the creator of a therapy style called motivational interviewing, and we spoke about what he calls “the righting reflex” – the urge to offer unsolicited advice, or steer someone onto what we believe is a better path.
Miller described how this reflex leads to people becoming more resistant to what we have to say, mainly because it makes them feel invalidated or dismissed. Motivational interviewing was developed initially as an approach to working with addiction, and it emphasises reflective listening as an important skill to develop empathy, trust, and connection.
For example, imagine someone tells you that they’ve been drinking heavily because they’ve been feeling down about themselves and alcohol is the only thing that makes them feel good for a while. They know it’s causing problems in their relationships and it affects their performance at work, but they’re in such a slump they feel that drinking is the only thing that helps.
Can you imagine how they’d react if we said, “I get that you’re going through a hard time, but drinking’s not going to help your situation. Think of your family – what happens if you lose your job?”
On the surface, this appears to be a well-intentioned intervention. We’re acknowledging their problem and trying to help them see the seriousness of their situation – as if they don’t already know. They’re obviously not likely to respond well.
But what if we took another approach and left the quick fix to one side? We might say, “It sounds like things have been really difficult for you lately, and drinking gives you some relief from how you’ve been feeling about yourself. You’re aware of the problems it’s causing, but right now, it’s hard to imagine how you’d cope without it”.
Here, we’re more likely to make a connection with the person. They might think, “Finally, someone who gets the problem and isn’t immediately making me feel worse than I already do”.
Think about the last time you were worried about something and someone told you to “just relax” or “don’t worry”. Chances are, you already knew that worrying wasn’t helping and being reminded of that probably did nothing to make you feel better.
Now imagine someone responding by acknowledging how difficult things must feel for you, perhaps asking what’s been troubling you, or simply taking the time to listen.
How might that change the conversation? Would you feel more comfortable opening up, knowing that you wouldn’t have to explain or justify your feelings?
We can’t always make someone’s difficulties go away, but it can make a huge difference if we listen to others the same way we’d want ourselves to be heard.
