At her central kitchen in Kuala Lumpur, Lisa Yeoh, 31, and her team are busy pressing cute little bread-shaped mould characters into a long, thin stretch of dough.
Yeoh is the founder of a homegrown cookie brand, simply called Kaya Toast Cookie. A lawyer by profession, she has been in practice for nearly a decade but took a sabbatical for family reasons.
Yeoh has always had an avid interest in baking and has been baking since she was 14. Like most Malaysians, she also has a lifelong love of kaya toast, something she has eaten at kopitiams since she was a child.
So she decided to fuse those two passions together and create a kaya toast cookie.

“I used to travel to Japan and Korea a lot. And at the airports – there were all these nicely packaged snacks for tourists and I felt like that was kind of missing in Malaysia. I mean, we do have snacks, but I don’t think the snacks were very reflective of our local dishes.
“So that is why I thought I needed to do something that transported well, had a long shelf life and represented our food culture. And when I thought of doing a cookie, there was no doubt this was the flavour it was going to be,” says Yeoh.
Which, as it turned out, was easier said than done. Yeoh started experimenting last August and quickly ran into all sorts of roadblocks. First, she realised that because kaya has a high water percentage, the water migrated to the cookie after a few days and turned the entire product into mush.
So the first 50 versions of her cookie simply involved checking the water percentage and sending it for food testing to ensure it was actually safe to consume. As of now, she is on the 214th iteration of her kaya toast cookie!
“I thought it would be a baking project, but I think because it’s a product with a longer shelf life, it turned out to be more of a science project. I had to learn more about how to extend the shelf life of the product and the type of additives to use and stuff like that,” explains Yeoh.

Yeoh also had to learn the ropes of running a business and dealing with customers. Initially, she was working alone and so she was slammed when orders came in. Now she has a small team and operates out of a central kitchen in Kuala Lumpur.
Yeoh’s kaya toast cookie is insanely, addictively good – a firm yet crumbly, lightly buttery cookie moulded around a rich, thick kaya filling. It’s a simple idea but one that has been executed really well.
Yeoh initially made the kaya herself but eventually figured out it was too time-consuming to do regularly, so she now purchases the kaya but adds other ingredients to it to give it her own unique spin. Each batch takes a few days to make as she also ages the dough to enhance the flavour.
Part of the appeal of her brand is that she has crafted an entire series of characters called Tosti around the cookie. On her social media page, Tosti is animated and has a life (and many adventures). This has very quickly built her a good following, even though she only started selling the cookies in August this year.

“So, these Tosties are like Smurfs. They’re little characters, and there are a lot of them living in the whole community. And I wanted it to be this character to remind us of the little joys in life,” she says.
Yeoh sells the cookies on her website for RM50 for a box of eight and typically sells between 200 and 400 boxes every week. Within the third month of launching the brand, she was approached by KLIA2 to open a pushcart at the airport, where the cookies are now sold as well.
Yeoh says 70% of her customers are people looking for gifting options to either give to friends from overseas or take on trips abroad. She hopes to expand her range of snacks to include other quintessentially Malaysian flavours and eventually branch out and reach more Malaysians.

“When I first started, I was like, ‘This can only get viral if Malaysians eat it and like it’. Because if I can’t even target the local market when it’s mirrored after a local dish, then I failed in that sense.
“But my takeaway from all this is I want the cookie to be brought around the world, because when I travel, I always bring Malaysian snacks with me, because I just want a taste of home. So for Malaysians abroad, I want them to have a snack that reminds them of Malaysia all the time,” says Yeoh.
