Ask the Plant Doctor! To pot or not to pot


To plant in a pot or in the ground ? Consider your available space and your plant's needs. Photo: 123rf.com
Do you have a question about plants or how to maintain your garden? Send your questions to the Plant Doctor! Email your questions to lifestyle@thestar.com.my with "Plant Doctor" in the subject field. Questions may be edited for brevity and clarity.

Which is the better option — planting in pots or in the ground? - Yinyi Foong

Deciding whether to plant in pots or directly in the ground revolves around several considerations, including the specific needs of the plant, the characteristics of your environment, the amount of space you have, and your gardening goals.

Choosing to plant in pots offers certain conveniences.

It offers the flexibility to move your plants, helping you optimise conditions, such as light and temperature, or simply to rearrange the plants for aesthetic reasons. This can be beneficial if your gardening area is confined, such as at a balcony, terrace or indoors.

Pots can also be filled with a specialised potting mix, offering a reliable alternative if your garden soil is problematic, such as being too rocky, shallow, or prone to waterlogging after rainfall.

Additionally, managing and treating any pests or diseases is generally easier with potted plants.

However, it is important to remember pots can bring their own set of challenges. Plants in pots often dry out more quickly, requiring more regular watering, and the pot’s size may restrict the growth of the plant, necessitating periodic repotting.

Conversely, planting directly in the ground gives your plants abundant space for root expansion, often leading to healthier, more vigorous growth.

Typically, ground-planted plants require less watering and overall care than potted plants. They also have the advantage of interacting naturally with the soil’s microbiome and other organisms.

But this method has its drawbacks too. Controlling soil conditions can be more challenging, and plants can be more vulnerable to environmental changes, such as unpredictable weather.

Ground-planted plants also have to contend with weeds, and they may be more susceptible to soil-borne diseases, especially without proper crop rotation practices.

In summary, if you have a problematic garden soil, limited space, or if you value the ability to move your plants around, then pot planting could be a good fit for you.

However, if you have ample space and prefer a gardening approach that requires less regular maintenance, allowing your plants to grow to their potential, then opt for planting in the ground.

Planting passion fruit requires patience. Photo: Filepic
Planting passion fruit requires patience. Photo: Filepic

I have grown four pots of passion fruit. The diameter of the pots is 40cm with a depth of 35cm. They are about 10 months old but there are still no signs of flower. Foliage is abundant. I have used fertiliser like blood and bone meal, fruits fertiliser and flower fertiliser. All of them have higher potassium and phosphorus but have not yielded flowers or fruits. - Vinnie Goh

Growing passion fruit vines requires patience. It can take between 12 and 24 months for them to flower, especially if grown from seeds.

However, my primary concern is the risk of over-fertilisation. It is not uncommon for gardeners to “experiment” with various fertilisers in quick succession, hoping to hit upon the perfect “fertiliser combo”. This approach often does more harm than good.

Excessive amounts of one nutrient can hinder the plant’s uptake of others. For example, an abundance of nitrogen (N) promotes leaf growth at the expense of flowering. The fertilisers you have used previously are likely mixed, supplying various nutrients in different ratios.

Young passion fruit plants need more N and phosphorus (P) for leaf and root development. However, as they mature and prepare to flower, they require more potassium (K). At this stage, K should be twice as abundant as N and four times as much as P. Given that you may have over-fertilised, it would be wise to refrain from any further fertiliser application for at least six months.

Other aspects to consider are:

1. Light: Passion fruit vines need at least six hours of full sun daily for flowering. Assess the lighting condition your plants are in and adjust accordingly.

2. Pruning: These vines bloom and bear fruit on new growth. If yours are overgrown with old, unproductive vines, consider pruning to stimulate new growth.

3. Pot size: Ensure the roots are not constrained. Passion fruit vines have extensive root systems and if they become pot-bound, flowering may not occur. Pots should ideally be at least 50cm to 60cm in width and depth.

Dr Christopher Teh heads the Dept of Land Management, Faculty of Agriculture, Universiti Putra Malaysia and coordinates the Healthy Garden series.

Get 20% OFF The Star Digital Access

Monthly Plan

RM 13.90/month

RM 11.12/month

Billed as RM 11.12 for the 1st month, RM 13.90 thereafter.

Best Value

Annual Plan

RM 12.33/month

RM 9.87/month

Billed as RM 118.40 for the 1st year, RM 148 thereafter.

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!
gardening , Dr Plant , pot , plants

Next In Living

This mental trick may help you get more exercise
China's bull wrestlers fight to keep the centuries-old tradition alive
How to spot hidden price increases or 'shrinkflation'
Feeling drowsy at your desk? A 5 minute stroll will perk you up
What’s in your dog’s food? How to make sure your pet is getting quality meals
Winemakers on the Greek island of Santorini try to adapt to heat and drought
'Dutch sashimi': Getting the young to swallow herring
Common home cleaning practices that lead to hidden wear and damage
Security education should start early, especially for girls, say experts
Sunny Side Up: None of us can be blank slates

Others Also Read