Dangerous minds – the bullying we never really outgrow


THE film Dangerous Minds, released in 1995, introduced audiences to a classroom of young people navigating poverty, difficult relationships, troubled neighbourhoods and violence.

It left an impression on me not merely because of the unconventional teacher, played by Michelle Pfeiffer, but because it reflected how readily society associates troubled adolescents with the circumstances in which they grow up.

More than three decades later, I find myself returning to this film whenever conversations about bullying and youth aggression resurface. Much has changed since 1995, yet we remain remarkably quick to associate cruelty with certain kinds of children, families or neighbourhoods.

Perhaps we have become so accustomed to looking for the troubled child that we sometimes overlook the behaviour we tolerate in everyone else.

I grew up in a Malaysian town whose reputation sometimes arrived before its postcode did. Mention where you came from and somebody would have a joke ready, usually about how tough you must be to have survived childhood there.

We laughed about it. We still do. But growing up somewhere other people considered rough taught me something else: geography is a poor predictor of kindness.

Cruelty does not require a deprived neighbourhood, and privilege provides no immunity from it. Socioeconomic disadvantage can contribute to vulnerability in certain circumstances, but bullying crosses social boundaries. It can happen in an ordinary classroom, an expensive private school, a university or an office overlooking the city skyline.

Bullying has never needed the right postcode. Perhaps the more useful question is about power: who has it, how we learn to use it, and what happens when using it against somebody else brings laughter, status, obedience or simply no consequences.

Many adults have experienced bullying at school. Some may remember bullying somebody else. Others occupied the large territory in between – watching, laughing nervously, walking away or deciding that intervening might make them the next target.

We did not always call it bullying. Sometimes, it was teasing, initiation or rough play. Sometimes we were told not to be so sensitive.

Occasionally, an adult reminded us that hardship built character because they had endured something worse themselves. We often hear the familiar phrase, "We went through it, too."

Yes, many of us did, but survival is not evidence that something was harmless.

There is another assumption buried inside conversations about bullying: that the child being harmed should somehow know how to stop it. Speak up, walk away, tell a teacher, stand your ground or report it. These are reasonable things to teach children, but they also place a remarkable amount of responsibility on the person who may have the least power in the situation.

Children can be oppressed, too. Yet, how many children are genuinely equipped to defend themselves against sustained aggression? A frightened child may not have the words to explain what is happening. Another may fear retaliation. Some may already have tried telling somebody and discovered they were not believed.

Children should learn resilience and how to seek help, but safeguarding cannot depend on a child becoming powerful enough to overcome the person harming them. Sometimes, responsibility belongs to those who already possess the power to intervene.

We expect bullying to be left behind with childhood. But the behaviour remains remarkably familiar in adult life. Perhaps the easiest way to recognise this is to walk into a workplace. There may be no playground, but adults have more sophisticated tools.

Someone can be repeatedly humiliated during meetings, excluded from information necessary to perform a job, undermined in front of colleagues or quietly pushed towards the margins of a team.

Power no longer needs to come from physical size or playground popularity. It may come from seniority, professional status or control over somebody else's livelihood.

Not every disagreement at work is bullying, and neither criticism nor an unpopular management decision should automatically be labelled as such. Nevertheless, workplace bullying is a recognised psychosocial concern.

Malaysia's Department of Occupational Safety and Health has issued guidelines on assessing and managing psychosocial risks at work, acknowledging the importance of organisational and social conditions in employee well-being.

And what do we often tell an adult experiencing mistreatment? Speak up, document everything, use the proper channel or lodge a complaint. Necessary advice, certainly, but notice how familiar it sounds.

Again, we begin by asking the person with less power to activate a system against the person with more. A reporting channel is not the same thing as protection.

A school can have an anti-bullying policy, a university a complaints procedure, a workplace a grievance mechanism and a social media platform a report button. Their existence matters, but so does whether people trust them enough to use them, whether retaliation is feared, whether somebody acts after a report and whether anything actually changes.

This should make adults uncomfortable when we tell children simply to stop bullying. They are watching us. They observe how adults exercise authority, how we speak about people who cannot easily answer back and what happens when somebody is humiliated.

Children receive lessons about power long before anyone gives them a school programme explaining that bullying is wrong.

Technology has complicated those lessons further. Those of us who grew up before smartphones sometimes make an unfair comparison when we say, "We were bullied, too."

Yes, but many of us could also go home. The school gate did not erase what happened during the day, but for many children it created some physical distance.

Today's adolescent may carry the schoolyard home in a pocket. A humiliating moment can be photographed, a cruel joke becomes a screenshot, and a rumour moves from a classroom to a group chat. Something said at lunchtime may still be circulating at midnight.

Technology did not invent bullying; it changed its reach, persistence, audience and escape routes. It also changed the bystander. Once, standing nearby and laughing could reinforce another child's humiliation. Today, participation may require only a like, a laughing emoji, a screenshot or a share. Someone who never initiated the cruelty can help give it an audience far beyond the original encounter.

Adults cannot comfortably blame teenagers for this either. We know what an online pile-on looks like. We have watched adults ridicule strangers, swarm comment sections and turn somebody else's worst moment into entertainment.

Sometimes, we participate without considering ourselves as participants at all. The technology developed, and the behaviour came with us.

None of this means that a bullied child inevitably becomes an adult bully. Human lives are nowhere near that predictable. Some people emerge from painful experiences extraordinarily empathetic. Some become fiercely protective of others. Some carry wounds quietly. Others may come to regard what happened to them as normal.

What can persist are lessons about power. Humiliation that earns laughter, intimidation that produces compliance, complaints that lead nowhere and witnesses who remain silent can all communicate something about what society is prepared to tolerate.

That is why "we survived it" deserves a second thought. Perhaps we did. The more useful issue is what we learned from surviving it. Did the experience teach us to recognise somebody else's suffering sooner, or did it simply raise the threshold of suffering we expect another person to tolerate before we consider it serious? There is an enormous difference between the two.

Perhaps we should spend less time trying to identify the kind of child who becomes a bully and more time examining the conditions under which harmful uses of power become rewarding, tolerated or invisible.

We look for the difficult child, the troubled home, the rough neighbourhood or the violent school. Yet, we are not always as willing to examine the environments surrounding them. Who models power? Who rewards cruelty? Who laughs? Who stays silent? Who notices and who intervenes?

When somebody says they are being harmed, who decides whether that harm is serious enough to matter?

These questions do not stop being relevant when somebody turns 18. They follow us into universities, relationships, workplaces and digital communities. The vocabulary changes, the hierarchy becomes more complicated and the methods become more sophisticated.

The underlying question remains familiar: What happens when one human being discovers that diminishing another gives them power, and the people around them allow it to go on?

Perhaps bullying is something humanity will never completely outgrow. Bullying culture, however, is different. Culture determines whether humiliation receives laughter or resistance, whether a bystander forwards a message or refuses to amplify it, whether a teacher dismisses a complaint or investigates it, or whether a manager's cruelty is excused as a demanding leadership style.

Bullying culture is learned, reinforced and normalised. That also means it can be interrupted.

We may never completely outgrow bullying. But we can outgrow the culture that teaches people they can get away with it.

MARZIAH ZAHAR (PhD)

Senior lecturer

School of Business Management

Universiti Utara Malaysia 

 

Get 20% OFF The Star Digital Access

Monthly Plan

RM 13.90/month

RM 11.12/month

Billed as RM 11.12 for the 1st month, RM 13.90 thereafter.

Best Value

Annual Plan

RM 12.33/month

RM 9.87/month

Billed as RM 118.40 for the 1st year, RM 148 thereafter.

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!
Violence , schools , bullying culture

Next In Letters

The missing piece in university reform
Losing talent through retirement
Holding company directors and officers to account
Better way to strengthen entrepreneurship support
As floods keep happening, are the right problems being fixed?
Flood mitigation systems in KL need an overhaul
Saving high culture in an ageing Malaysia
Look at long-term value of the ECRL
Why policy certainty is important in a world of hyper-flux
Preparing now for longer lives

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read