Expert unsure if signatures were Najib’s


PUTRAJAYA: There were dissimilarities between the signatures of Datuk Seri Najib Razak and those that appeared in photocopied government documents relating to 1Malaysia Development Bhd (1MDB), the High Court was told.

Forensic document examiner Tay Eue Kam, 59, testified that she had observed both the similarities and the differences of the specimens but her findings were inconclusive as she did not have the original documents.

“My opinion is inconclusive due to the existence of both similarities and differences.

“A conclusive determination would necessitate further assessments of the original document,” she said.

Tay, who was under examination-in-chief by lead counsel Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah, is the 25th defence witness testifying in the former prime minister’s RM2.28bil graft trial involving 1MDB here yesterday.

The expert had analysed 31 specimen documents – including numerous bank cheques and government letters and memos – to identify whether Najib had indeed penned the signatures and notes in seven impugned documents in relation to the 1MDB trial.

All the documents, however, were reproductions, not the originals.

“It has been established that examination can be conducted on good quality reproductions but poor quality reproductions present challenges in identifying some critical handwriting figures.

“While specific details such as connection, line quality, and variations in pen pressure within the signatures in the reproductions were not explicitly deciphered, their structural formation, key features, and orientation were subject to examination and analysis,” said Tay on her findings.

Muhammad Shafee: Because it’s a reproduction, from your experience, can the signature (in the impugned documents) be lifted and pasted?

Tay: When we deal with reproductions, we cannot exclude that probability.

Muhammad Shafee: How do you prove if they are lifted or not?

Tay: It’s not an easy answer. It’s the way they do it. If they photocopy it... there will be lines erased. I have to compare it with the original.

According to the witness, it was not easy to identify fabrication without original documents to compare it against.

On Oct 30 last year, Najib was ordered by the High Court to enter his defence on four counts of using his position to obtain RM2.28bil gratification from 1MDB’s funds and 21 counts of money laundering involving the same amount.

The hearing continues before Justice Collin Lawrence Sequerah today.

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In Nation

Anwar extends 68th birthday wishes to Sultan Ibrahim
Two women killed after being thrown from car on Federal Highway
Police track down driver of yellow car in Hulu Langat hit-and-run
Search underway for woman swept away at Ipoh waterfall
MCA will not be complacent after winning 12 seats in three recent state polls, says Dr Wee
Ampang Hospital ER hit by 25% surge in patients, causing delays in ward admissions
Floods: Number of evacuees in Perak, S'gor drops, Negri fully recovers
Elopura rep calls for security audit after military aircraft alleged used in attempt to smuggle drugs into Sabah
Govt must ensure cultural heritage of all communities gets equal protection, says MCA Youth chief
MyEVOC urges stricter enforcement of EV charger regulations, transparency in fire investigations

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read