There are no ‘natural disasters’, just man-made vulnerabilities


Residents search for their belongings amid the debis of their collapsed huts after the cyclone Sitrang hit Chittagong in October. – AFP

A TROPICAL cyclone formed in the Bay of Bengal recently and hit Bangladesh and some parts of India. As in the past, the storm – named Cyclone Sitrang – brought flooding, destroyed crops, collapsed buildings and loss of life.

For a disaster to happen, hazard and vulnerability must come together. Human-caused climate change is affecting hazards now, such as decreasing the frequency of tropical cyclones while increasing their intensity. A tropical cyclone, though, does not need to harm health if people and infrastructure are ready for it and can cope with it.

The vulnerability – or how society deals or cannot deal with hazards – is what creates the disaster. Vulner-ability is a societal process setting up people and places to be harmed by potential hazards. Examples are poorly-constructed buildings, breaking planning regulations, not having insurance, not receiving or understanding warning messages due to language differences, being unable to evacuate due to illness or immobility, fearing assault in an emergency shelter, and many others.

The disaster is not that Hurricane Ian swept over Cuba and Florida in September. The problem is that Cuba’s electricity grid failed in a storm less powerful than previous ones and that Florida has had rampant coastal development without accounting for flooding.

So the phrase “natural disaster” is a misnomer. Disasters come from vulnerability, not from hazards originating in nature. By definition, human-caused climate change affects the weather, but also by definition, weather does not cause disasters. Therefore, by definition, climate change does not cause disasters.

There are lethal exceptions, one impacting us terribly now: human-caused climate change is pushing heat-humidity into realms that are beyond human survival. In British Columbia, Canada, in 2021 and England and Wales in 2022, deaths from heat waves were directly attributable to human-caused climate change.

Many workers cannot escape the devastating heat-humidity. Agricul-tural labour is especially affected, impacting the world’s food supplies. Wildfire smoke exacerbated by climate change is worsening respiratory ailments. And, in an example of vulnerability, many cannot afford artificial indoor cooling which, in any case, can lead to blackouts through overuse.

Other physical health impacts from climate change could emerge in the future. Coastal food systems could be undermined by acidifying oceans in coming years. Over centuries, sea-level rise could require megacities and low-lying island communities to relocate. Without advance planning and support, health impacts could be severe.

Meanwhile, science is only just beginning to understand the effects of climate change on mental health. So far, no unambiguous correlation of self-harm with human-caused climate change has been identified. Yet data quality is poor, since self-harm, including suicide, is stigmatised and not always recorded comprehensively. As well, prevention and treatment can avert self-harm, irrespective of environmental changes.

Heat-humidity nonetheless influences interactions between mental and physical health. Heat-humidity physically stresses our bodies which can compound into mental stress. Schizophrenia, depression, dementia and others seem to be directly affected by heat-humidity. Some medications for mental health and wellbeing conditions impede the body’s ability to adjust to heat-humidity while the effectiveness of others changes with temperature.

Doom-laden narratives of climate change now have a demonstrable and detrimental effect on mental health and wellbeing. “Ecoanxiety” and climate grief through “climate crisis” stories manufacture “doom- erism” and reduce nuances, such as incorrectly attributing many disasters to climate change. Reporting and action should balance ecogrief and ecoinspiration.

Hope emerges from activities to avoid the worst of human-caused climate change, such as reducing excess consumption, while adjusting to observed and ongoing impacts.

Cyclone deaths have declined in Bangladesh while the most lethal US hurricane to make landfall so far was long ago, in 1900. Mental health conditions can be destigmatised to support affected people. All these required decades to achieve and evidence, so further actions must start now.

Health systems worldwide are currently not resourced or robust enough to meet current and future health needs. They are in crisis, burning out healthcare professionals and failing to serve people’s health needs, with austerity killing patients irrespective of climate change. We cannot develop and implement effective health policy and practice by suddenly blaming long-standing, deep-seated, fundamental problems on a single topic, such as human-caused climate change.

Yet heat-humidity is significantly adding to these problems now, as detailed in Lancet Countdown’s annual report for 2022, even as some trends in the report offer hopeful direction. Public and political engagement in health and climate change appears to be increasing, with climate change action increasingly focusing on health.

Most notably, the Covid-19 response shows that countries are willing to invest public money in tackling an immediate health danger. This dedication must be transferred to climate change, especially for strengthening health systems. Prioritising our health contributes to redressing all global difficulties, including climate change. – 360info

Ilan Kelman (who has an Open Researcher and Contributor ID) is Professor of Disasters and Health at University College London and Professor II at the Kristiansand campus, University of Agder, Norway. His overall research interest is linking disasters and health, including the integration of climate change into disaster research and health research. Kelman has co-authored Lancet Countdown since its first report in 2015.

Get 20% OFF The Star Digital Access

Monthly Plan

RM 13.90/month

RM 11.12/month

Billed as RM 11.12 for the 1st month, RM 13.90 thereafter.

Best Value

Annual Plan

RM 12.33/month

RM 9.87/month

Billed as RM 118.40 for the 1st year, RM 148 thereafter.

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In Focus

From sugar rush to sugar crunch
Violence in the olive groves
Two worlds, different origins
‘What can I say to the river?’
Shadow wars behind the open war
Stranded by red tape
Gen Z reuses non-violent method
Turquoise waters, turbulent politics
Edging towards the abyss
‘Now the elephants come to see us’

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read