Claiming to have the answer to mood swings, picky eating and even autism, some mum influencers are accused of preying on desperate parents and reaping financial rewards. — AFP
AN ARMY of American mothers claiming to be “detox” specialists is pushing unproven treatments for childhood behavioural disorders – while hiding that their misinformation is actually a marketing campaign aimed at making money.
Influencers with a large following, these mothers typically cite personal testimonies to passionately endorse detox sprays or bath treatments, claiming without evidence that they help rid children of toxins such as heavy metals and parasites.
Their videos, which often garner millions of views on platforms including TikTok, illustrate how unqualified nutrition influencers deftly skirt content moderation rules to peddle potentially harmful health misinformation that experts say is difficult to police.
Claiming to have the answer to mood swings, picky eating and even autism, the influencers are accused of preying on desperate parents and reaping financial rewards through what researchers call predatory multi-level marketing (MLM) schemes, whose companies are banned on TikTok.
Danica Walker, a self-styled “detoxification specialist” holds up a spray in one video and claims it helped cure her toddler’s “mood issues” within weeks.
Like dozens of similar endorsements on her account, this video is not marked as an advertisement.
But a website linked in her TikTok bio directs users to a company that bears the hallmarks of MLM, a form of direct sales using independent contractors. It sells detox products, including the spray in Walker’s video, and recruits new sales representatives through an “affiliate programme.”
Neither Walker nor the MLM company responded to AFP’s request for comment.
Comments under her video such as “Did you get paid for this?” and “It didn’t work for me and it was so expensive” did not elicit a public response from Walker.
Fake treatment
The AFP examined around a dozen of what appeared to be a flood of TikTok accounts of influencer mums promoting scientifically unproven detox products.
The accounts appear to violate TikTok’s community guidelines. Without commenting on the detox influencers, a TikTok spokeswoman told AFP: “Our community guidelines make clear that we don’t allow MLM.”
Two accounts, including Walker’s, were deactivated immediately after AFP flagged them to the spokeswoman.
Many influencers appear to sidestep the possibility of legal challenges with a standard disclaimer: the endorsements are “not medical advice.”
“It has become part of their sales tactic – ‘I’m giving you this information mother-to-mother, not as your doctor,’ so it presumably protects them legally but also connects them with potential consumers,” TikTok misinformation researcher Abbie Richards told AFP.
“The claims these accounts are making could be entirely fabricated in the name of selling merchandise and they aren’t even marked as advertisements.”
People working for MLMs can earn money through commissions from direct sales of products or by recruiting new distributors, according to the US Federal Trade Commission.
The real-life impact of the “pseudoscientific misinformation” is huge, said Jonathan Stea, a clinical psychologist and adjunct assistant professor at the University of Calgary. “Detox is a scam,” Stea told AFP.
“There’s no compelling scientific evidence to support detox treatments for eliminating ‘toxins’ from the body. Ultimately, a detox bath is fake treatment for a fake condition.”
A healthy and good as they sound, there's no evidence to support detox practices. — 123rf.com
‘Preying on mums’
Parents of autistic children in particular have lashed out at influencers for peddling falsehoods for personal gain, including that detox treatments cure symptoms such as speech delays and enable non-verbal children to start singing.
“A lot of you (influencers) are reaching out saying: ‘Hey girl, I know your child has autism. I have the perfect thing for you,’” a mother named Anna Maria said in a TikTok video.
“Cut it out. Stop preying on moms in the special-needs community.”
But seeming to validate the adage that lies spread faster online than the truth, such videos attract far lower engagement and traction than the slick and sentimental detox endorsements.
TikTok appears flooded with unqualified influencers who spread misinformation, from vaccine- and abortion-related falsehoods to health myths, which experts say can have a serious impact on medical decisions.
Last year, the watchdog Media Matters exposed another “predatory” MLM scheme on TikTok to covertly sell weight loss products not approved by US health regulators.
“TikTok’s inability to detect such a large-scale MLM sets a bleak precedent for meaningful moderation of these exploitative schemes,” Media Matters wrote in its report.
“The platform benefited from a significant amount of positive media attention after announcing its MLM ban (in December 2020), but its actual enforcement seems to be failing.” – AFP Relaxnews
