Landmark genocide ruling only the beginning


A group of Rohingya refugees fleeing to Cox's Bazar after crossing the border into Bangladesh in 2017. — AP

THE International Court of Justice’s (ICJ) ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya minority is a major milestone, but it is not the end of the accountability process, says the Independent Investigative Mechanism for Myanmar (IIMM).

Nicholas Koumjian, head of the IIMM, says while the court has addressed Myanmar’s responsibility as a state under international law, establishing the criminal responsibility of individual perpetrators will require separate criminal investigations and judicial proceedings.

“The pursuit of accountability must also extend to crimes against humanity and war crimes,” he says.

“The IIMM will continue to impartially investigate serious international crimes committed across Myanmar, against victims from all communities and by perpetrators of any affiliation, and support efforts to bring the individuals most responsible to justice.” 

The IIMM was created by the United Nations Human Rights Council in 2018 to collect and analyse evidence of the most serious international crimes and other violations of international law committed in Myanmar since 2011.

It aims to facilitate justice and accountability by preserving and organising this evidence and preparing analysis that can be used by authorities to prosecute individuals in national, regional and international courts.

Koumjian adds, although the IIMM will need time to examine the judgement and its implications closely, its significance for the Rohingya community is clear.

It not only recognises the discrimination, persecution and crimes the Rohingya people have suffered for many years, but also brings renewed hope that their plight has not been forgotten.

“This judgement by the world’s highest court acknowledges the immense suffering endured by the Rohingya and represents a landmark step towards accountability and redress for one of the gravest crimes under international law,” he says.

The significance of the judgement also extends beyond the Rohingya community, he notes.

“Many of the actors and state institutions examined by the court are also relevant to other serious international crimes that are being committed across Myanmar.”

Now that the court has delivered its judgement what matters next is action, Koumjian stresses.

Although the judgement addresses crimes committed in the past, it is still relevant today as many Rohingya continue to face the consequences of those crimes right now.

“Myanmar must fulfil its obligations as ordered by the court.

“The international community, especially states, must build on the court’s findings, demand compliance with the orders and continue to support efforts to achieve accountability and justice,” he says.

On Nov 19, the ICJ also ordered the state to make reparations to the community.

Other than ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, the court also found that Myanmar failed to prevent and punish genocide in breach of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.

This was based on evidence of brutal violence against the Rohingya in the northern Rakhine state during the 2017 clearance operations.

As such, Myanmar has been ordered to investigate and prosecute those responsible, facilitate the safe and voluntary return of the Rohingya to their place of origin, return all property and provide adequate compensation for the damage caused.

Myanmar must submit a report to the court on the measure of restitution it has adopted and the amounts and modalities of compensation within two years.

In September this year, the IIMM had said that the situation remains extremely volatile and dangerous for all communities in Rakhine state, with civilians frequently becoming victims of aerial bombings, artillery shelling, drone attacks, arbitrary detention, sexual and gender-based crimes, tortures and killings.

This was in response to the intentions of governments in the region on the possible return of people, including the Rohingya, who had previously fled the violence in Myanmar.

At the time, the IIMM said conditions in Rakhine state were not yet conducive to the safe and sustainable return of people.

“Before such returns can take place, the crimes and violence causing immense suffering to communities across Myanmar must end,” says Koumjian.

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!
Rohingya , ICJ , genocide

Next In Focus

Nepal: A climate justice test for the world
Myanmar: Guilty of genocide; for the Rohingya, misery continues for now
Editorial: Returning to era of domination by major powers is unacceptable
Myanmar genocide ruling sets up court fight over Israel and Gaza
Shenzen 2026 is not Yalta 1945
More than 50 years on, P. Ramlee still brings us together
Scrap nukes now
Fine and dandy in this city?
Fine cities: ‘I don’t want live in a fine city anymore’
Pain after pain for many Lebanese

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read