THERE is something quirky about Malaysians when it comes to fines.
Some try their best to avoid them, lest they burn a hole in their pockets. Others heed the law as a matter of principle. And, of course, there are those who simply don’t give a rodent’s bottom about lighting up a cigarette in a restaurant.
Which group is the most interesting to examine? Honestly, all of them. Each reflects a mindset that says something about one’s upbringing and, perhaps, the state of civic-mindedness in our society – or the lack thereof.
But what is the purpose of a fine? The popular answer would be “deterrence”. Fines are intended to discourage offences and, ideally, prevent people from repeating the same mistakes.
This is achieved, at least in part, by instilling a fear of monetary loss. If caught smoking in a prohibited area, for instance, you could face a fine of up to RM5,000. Now, that is just crazy. The saying “burning a hole in one’s pocket” should perhaps be amended to “tearing one’s pockets to shreds”.
And yet, scores of people continue smoking in prohibited public spaces, speeding along highways and zigzagging through morning traffic while imagining a smiling Dominic Toretto looking over at them.
Whether they will be caught does not appear to cross their minds. Not a tinge of concern. Not a hoot of uncertainty. Just the unshakeable confidence of someone who believes the rules are for everyone else.
Therein lies the question: Are fines enough to serve as a deterrent?
“Fines should not be viewed solely as a financial penalty. Their broader purpose is to encourage responsible beha-viour, protect the public interest and reinforce the principle that rules exist for the benefit and safety of everyone,” says a random person this writer met while queuing to pay a traffic summons in Shah Alam not too long ago.
He probably read that from a brochure written by a copy-writer who enjoys the luxury of a sedentary lifestyle.
Nevertheless, our random gentleman was not entirely wrong, although his words deserve to be examined with a fine (oh yes, that is intentional) toothcomb.
Look beyond the machinery used to discipline the public into becoming a more civic-minded society, and you may find something missing. Specifically, the interrogative “why”.
Why is smoking banned in restaurants? Why is it wrong to speed along the road as though there were no tomorrow? And why is it wrong to release a piranha into the country’s rivers and ponds?
Some may know the answers. Others may be less acquainted with the reasoning behind these rules, especially when their original purpose has been overshadowed by the prospect of paying a hefty compound.
Fines can work, of course. Nobody enjoys paying for a mistake, particularly when the amount could cover a decent meal or two. But there is a difference between obeying the law because one fears getting caught and doing so because one understands the consequences of breaking it.
For the affluent offender, a fine may be little more than an inconvenient transaction, for habitual speed-demons, another operating expense. And for the smoker, hardly enough to outweigh the immediate gratification of a cigarette.
In such cases, the punishment may have been imposed, but has the lesson been learnt?
A fine can make someone think twice about breaking the law, but it cannot guarantee that the person understands why the law matters. Fear may secure compliance while an enforcement officer is watching; conscience is what keeps a person in check when nobody is.
Consider the prohibition against releasing piranhas into local waterways. It is not some arbitrary attempt by the authorities to spoil someone’s aquatic hobby. Invasive species can threaten native ecosystems and cause lasting environmental damage. The consequences extend far beyond the individual and whatever pleasure comes from keeping an exotic fish.
The same principle applies to speeding and smoking bans. These rules are not merely obstacles to personal convenience; they exist to protect other people and the wider community. Understanding this is what turns reluctant compliance into genuine civic responsibility.
Of course, the prospect of a lighter wallet has its uses. But if the only lesson learnt is to avoid getting caught, we have achieved little beyond teaching offenders to be more careful next time.
Ultimately, the real measure of an effective fine is not how much money it collects, but whether it encourages people to think twice before breaking the law – even when no enforce-ment officer is watching.
Because if the only thing stopping someone from doing the wrong thing is the fear of having to pay for it, perhaps the fine has done its job only halfway.
And if we need to put a price tag on basic civic responsibility before people are willing to practise it, we may have a much bigger problem than unpaid summonses.
