Broadway is down right now, struggling to reopen after being shuttered during the pandemic. But it has been down before and gotten back up. That’s the message of On Broadway, a new documentary celebrating the history of the Great White Way.
“Broadway is resilient,” said the film’s director, Oren Jacoby. “The story of that resilience is really the message. And we hope that inspires people and will make them want to support the arts and want to go back to Broadway.”
The 85-minute film traces how the fortunes of New York’s theatre district have gone up and down over the decades, crashing in the late 1960s after enjoying a Golden Age in the 1940s and 1950s. Though hard-hit by the pandemic, the film offers hope that a rebound is possible.
“The film is a celebration about this ability of Broadway to reinvent itself,” said Jacoby. “Broadway kept finding new ways to attract audiences and respond to the times and be in a meaningful way a part of people’s lives.
Jacoby interviewed an A-list of Broadway stars, including Hugh Jackman, Helen Mirren, Christine Baranski, James Corden, Alec Baldwin, August Wilson, John Lithgow, Viola Davis and Ian McKellen. Some others tapped to share their views are Michael Eisner, David Henry Hwang, Jack O’Brien, Harold Prince, Michael Riedel, Jeffrey Seller and George C. Wolfe.
Broadway was on top in the 1940s and 1950s when big, lush musicals – West Side Story, Kiss Me, Kate, and Oklahoma, among them – were what played on the radio and drove Hollywood films, while Arthur Miller and Tennessee Williams made playwrighting a high art.
All that crashed as New York City flirted with bankruptcy in the early 1970s and pop music shifted away from musicals. From 1968-1972, attendance on Broadway went from 10 million to less that five million, a precipitous decline. The documentary makes the point that Broadway had suddenly become uncool, what your grandparents liked.
A large part of the problem was with Times Square itself, which had become seedy, filled with junkies and hustlers. Lithgow calls it “a rat hole” and Tommy Tune tells of his visiting mom crying when she first saw his apartment in adjacent Hell’s Kitchen.
On Broadway explains how live theatre clawed its way back, with city leaders cleaning up Times Square and with such creative geniuses as Stephen Sondheim, Michael Bennett and Bob Fosse making theatre an edgy, sexy draw again.
Interspliced with the past is behind-the-scenes footage of the modern-day play The Nap as it navigates Broadway, with a disappointing first read-through and nerves throughout. The British import about a snooker player lasted less than two months on Broadway in 2018 and shows how tenuous the business of live theatre can be.
Jacoby included The Nap for another reason: It co-starred Alexandra Billings, a transgender actor playing a transgender character. That gave him a way to show how Broadway’s stages have become more diverse over the years in terms of race, ethnicity, sexual orientation and now gender identity.
“Theatre has to touch the hearts and souls of the widest possible audience and that’s why it’s gotten better and come to reflect more and more what people in our world really look like,” said Jacoby, whose other works include Sister Rose’s Passion and The Topdog Diaries, a portrait of playwright Suzan-Lori Parks.
By the late 1970s, Broadway had rebounded, but its recovery was still tenuous until Cats captured popular attention, pointing the way in the 1980s for mega-successes and merchandising. The British theatre invasion kept Broadway afloat during the AIDS crisis and rock returned with Rent.
Disney, Wicked and Hamilton have been modern game-changers.
“Broadway’s like some old 42nd Street hooker: She just keeps plugging, just keeps plugging. Sometimes she has new shoes on and sometimes they’re old, broken down shoes,” Tune says in the film.
Jacoby thinks Broadway can rebound again after encountering the grave threat of Covid-19. He looks to the industry’s innovators who can make what’s playing in the district’s 41 theatres a must-see draw again.
In the past, groundbreaking artists backed by producers and theatre owners willing to go out on a limb gave audiences such unconventional sounding shows as A Chorus Line, Cats, Rent and Hamilton. Those are lessons for the future, Jacoby believes.
“They’ve got to try something quirky. They’ve got to try something that responds to the craziness of our time, and get a great team of artists working on it who can develop it into one of these shows that becomes something that people just think they have to come see,” he said. — AP