THE issue of the corporate mafia, a moniker created by a Malay-language blog more than three years ago, has now reached a point where lawmakers have no choice but to set up a Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) to get to the bottom of it.
Over the past few months, numerous public statements and comments have emerged, along with attempts to uncover the truth, including the formation of a special task force to investigate allegations related to the issue.
The Attorney General himself leads the task force, which has three months to complete its investigation.
According to the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Law and Institution Reform), the report will be made public to ensure transparency and maintain public confidence in the integrity of the country’s enforcement institutions.
The special task force, set up about a month ago, includes the Royal Malaysian Police, Securities Commission (SC), Bank Negara Malaysia, Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC), and Inland Revenue Board.
Who are the mafias?
The corporate mafia saga gained public attention after Bloomberg reported allegations that certain individuals had used the MACC to take over listed companies.
The alleged scheme is simple. Enforcement agencies are enlisted to create the impression of wrongdoing, leading to the questioning of key directors or personnel. In other cases, bank accounts are frozen on suspicion of money laundering activities.
The ensuing uncertainty erodes investor confidence in the targeted companies, causing share prices to fall drastically. As these companies’ share prices weaken, some see changes in their shareholdings.
Interestingly, the probes usually end thereafter, or, in the case of frozen bank accounts, the restrictions are lifted.
However, the damage has been done. The biggest losers are these companies’ shareholders, especially minority shareholders, who bear the brunt of the losses.
The companies’ reputations are also damaged, to the point that doing business with or for them would never be the same again. It is no longer business as usual.
But the million-ringgit question on everyone’s mind remains: who are these corporate mafias, and who is behind them?
SC’s response
The corporate mafia story has had many twists and turns before the government finally stepped in.
While politicians have called for thorough investigations, the government was previously seen as reluctant to act and had dismissed the allegations.
Even the SC’s hands were tied, as the regulatory body can investigate matters only when the country’s securities laws are breached.
Hence, the SC chairman’s comments were appropriate, as the reported corporate mafia allegations relate to criminal offences like intimidation and extortion, which do not fall within the SC’s remit. These matters fall under other law enforcement agencies.
Police actions
According to the Home Minister in his parliamentary reply on Oct 28, police have frozen or seized assets worth more than RM409mil in connection with an ongoing investigation into an alleged corporate mafia.
The breakdown showed that the seized assets included 70 share trading accounts worth RM323.6mil and 404 bank accounts holding RM85.6mil.
Police also seized eight properties, 11 vehicles and 417 Central Depository System accounts, but did not disclose their value.
The Minister also said several individuals have been detained as part of the investigation, which is still ongoing.
Damage done
The corporate mafia modus operandi is real, as police have now revealed the extent of the assets seized and the individuals under investigation.
The police investigations have already revealed the extent of the “works” carried out. The question now is whether any criminal action will be taken against those involved so that the public and the corporate sector can regain trust in our system.
Nevertheless, the RCI into allegations related to the corporate mafia must proceed despite the police findings as mentioned above.
The key is to ensure the RCI’s scope is broad enough to give all stakeholders a complete picture of the corporate mafia’s activities and establish safeguards to prevent them from recurring.
After all, the issue has already impacted the reputation of Corporate Malaysia and Bursa Malaysia, with billions of ringgit in market capitalisation wiped off the share prices of the listed companies involved.
Enforcement agencies
The activities of these corporate mafias cannot undermine the role of enforcement agencies, and the latter, in turn, must always act above board, relying on sound evidence and without prejudice.
In recent months, we have also seen enforcement agencies, including the police and MACC, act hastily by freezing bank accounts or calling key executives for questioning, only to find no concrete evidence of wrongdoing to substantiate the suspicions.
Early this year, the alleged money laundering case involving IJM Corp Bhd
’s non-executive chairman was a case in point, as the MACC cleared him after months of investigation.
In the meantime, the damage to the company’s share price and its reputation was clear.
The authorities then even investigated Sunway Bhd
’s voluntary takeover offer for IJM but cleared both companies just after the offer failed to achieve the required level of acceptance.
When it comes to enforcement actions, listed companies must disclose material developments involving their businesses or key personnel with immediate effect.
When this occurs, investors typically react negatively to such public disclosures, sending the share price of the companies involved sharply lower.
The impact is even worse when the matter turns out to be short-lived and regulators or enforcement agencies clear the individuals or companies within days. By then, the damage cannot be undone, and a shadow now hangs over the company and its operations.
While corporations are no angels, and neither are their key personnel, enforcement agencies must get it right from the start.
They must ensure that their actions are supported by the evidence gathered before taking enforcement action, to avoid unnecessary negative market reactions.
As for the corporate mafia issue, only a RCI can thoroughly investigate the entire modus operandi and make strong recommendations to tighten enforcement agencies’ oversight and reach.
Hence, while a task force has been set up to investigate the corporate mafia, only a proper RCI can clear the air once and for all.
