THE Japanese yen has become an increasingly difficult currency for investors to trade, as traditional market signals lose their reliability and competing economic forces make its direction harder to predict.
While higher domestic interest rates and government intervention offer reasons to expect a stronger yen, persistent capital outflows, attractive overseas returns and a widening gap between Japanese and other major economies’ interest rates persist to pressure the currency.
According to a Bloomberg report, the yen’s unpredictable behaviour reflects a fundamental shift in Japan’s economic landscape, leaving investors divided over its longer-term prospects and prompting some to reduce their exposure or stay out of the market altogether.
The challenge is that several forces are pulling the currency in opposite directions.
The Bank of Japan (BoJ) has been raising interest rates at its fastest pace since 1990, with domestic bond yields reaching multi-decade highs.
This should theoretically make yen-denominated assets more attractive and reduce the incentive for investors to borrow cheaply in yen to finance investments elsewhere.
However, Japanese interest rates remain considerably lower than those in the United States and other major economies.
This continues to make the yen an attractive funding currency for carry trades, where investors borrow in a low-interest-rate currency and invest in assets offering higher returns.
The persistence of these competing forces has made it difficult to establish a reliable trading strategy.
“The challenge is that these competing forces have made the timing and magnitude of yen moves much harder to anticipate,” Rajeev De Mello, global macro portfolio manager at Gama Asset Management SA, which manages about 600 million Swiss francs in assets, told Bloomberg.
“I have therefore reduced my yen positions to reflect the greater uncertainty,” he said.
The uncertainty is reflected in the sharply divided views among investors.
While Marlborough Investment Management’s James Athey expects significant yen appreciation, Fidelity International’s Lei Zhu sees further depreciation as the bigger risk.
Others have opted to avoid the currency altogether.
T Rowe Price Group Inc’s David Clewell has stayed out of the yen for an extended period, while Brandywine Global Investment Management’s Carol Lye has favoured trading the currency against the euro rather than the US dollar.
Intervention has limits
Government intervention has added another layer of uncertainty to yen trading.
Japanese authorities have repeatedly stepped into the foreign exchange market to support the currency, as a persistently weak yen raises import costs, squeezes household purchasing power and complicates efforts to revive domestic economic growth.
According to Bloomberg, Japan has spent a record 27.1 trillion yen (US$169.7bil) buying the local currency, an amount equivalent to almost three times the country’s combined trade deficit and direct-investment outflows.
The intervention helped lift the currency from a 40-year low near 164 against the US dollar, although much of those gains subsequently faded.
The involvement of US officials has also complicated the picture, with Washington showing a willingness to support efforts to stabilise the yen.
However, investors cannot rely on intervention alone to establish a sustained appreciation trend.
State Street Investment Management chief fixed income strategist Masahiko Loo told Bloomberg that markets should not underestimate authorities’ ability to counter sharp currency movements, but warned that intervention has inherent limitations.
“Intervention can slow a move, but it rarely changes the underlying direction on its own,” he said.
This leaves investors having to distinguish between temporary currency support and a genuine improvement in the yen’s underlying fundamentals.
Overseas investments
Another major complication is Japan’s transformation from an export-driven economy into a mature creditor nation with substantial investments overseas.
Historically, Japanese manufacturers generated significant foreign-exchange earnings through exports of cars, electronics and other industrial products.
However, decades of near-zero interest rates encouraged domestic investors to move their savings abroad in search of better returns.
This created a deep-rooted investment pattern that may not easily reverse, even as the BoJ gradually raises borrowing costs.
Japan now holds about 811 trillion yen in overseas portfolio assets, reflecting the scale of capital accumulated abroad during years of cheap money.
Fidelity’s Zhu told Bloomberg that pension funds, insurers and households continue to invest heavily overseas, creating a structural headwind for the yen.
Although higher Japanese government bond yields could encourage some investors to bring money home, the resulting inflows may not be sufficient to offset persistent overseas investment unless domestic returns become significantly more attractive.
The currency’s weakness despite substantial foreign interest in Japanese financial markets illustrates the problem.
Overseas investors bought a combined 34.5 trillion yen of Japanese bonds and equities between January and October, the highest amount on record for the period. Yet the yen remained under pressure.
One possible explanation, according to Citigroup strategists cited by Bloomberg, is that foreign investors are hedging part of their Japanese equity exposure by selling yen, limiting the positive currency impact of their investments.
Allocation
reconsiderations
There are some indications that domestic investors are beginning to reconsider their overseas allocations.
Higher domestic bond yields, stronger Japanese equity market returns and improving corporate governance have also made local investments more appealing.
However, this does not necessarily mean investors are ready to commit more capital to domestic assets.
“The issue is not valuation, but uncertainty,” Mizuho Bank senior strategist Masayuki Nakajima told Bloomberg. “Many institutions remain worried that yields could rise further if inflation, BoJ tightening expectations, or fiscal concerns intensify.”
According to Bloomberg, the Government Pension Investment Fund, one of the world’s largest pension funds, is being closely watched for signs of a shift towards domestic assets, although its allocations have remained largely unchanged.
Implications for
global markets
The difficulty in predicting the yen matters well beyond Japan. The currency is among the world’s most heavily traded, with about US$1.6 trillion in transactions changing hands daily.
Its direction influences international investment flows, global carry trades and the attractiveness of overseas assets for Japanese investors.
For Japan, prolonged weakness risks adding to imported inflation and complicating the BoJ’s efforts to normalise monetary policy.
It could also intensify volatility in the country’s bond market as investors reassess the relationship between inflation, interest rates and government finances.
BNP Paribas Asset Management head of global aggregate and absolute return James McAlevey told Bloomberg that a stronger yen would help ease inflationary pressures and stabilise longer-dated Japanese government bond yields.
Washington also has a stake in the currency’s direction.
Japan is the largest foreign holder of US government debt, meaning further unilateral intervention to support the yen could require Tokyo to sell some of its US Treasury holdings.
Such sales could potentially put upward pressure on US bond yields, adding another consideration for policymakers on both sides.
For investors, the combination of uncertain monetary policy, structural capital outflows and unpredictable government intervention makes it increasingly difficult to establish a clear view on the yen.
Arkevium Capital chief investment officer Maxence Visseau told Bloomberg that the currency had become “almost impossible to call” following joint intervention by Japan and the United States.
“I’m happy to stay on the sidelines for now. And I suspect I’m not alone,” he said.
