FINDING somewhere to shelter when financial markets turn volatile is becoming an increasingly difficult exercise, as assets traditionally regarded as safe havens are proving less reliable when investors need protection most.
From government bonds and gold to major currencies, the usual defensive bets are facing challenges as inflation, geopolitical tensions and concerns over public debt reshape market behaviour.
As Reuters highlights, recent market sell-offs have exposed the limitations of conventional portfolio protection, with assets that once moved in the opposite direction to equities increasingly falling alongside them.
For decades, investors have turned to US treasuries and the Japanese yen when stock markets came under pressure. However, these traditional refuges have not always delivered the expected protection, the newswire notes.
The problem became particularly apparent during the April 2025 market turmoil, when fears over US tariffs triggered an equity sell-off but treasuries failed to provide their usual cushion.
Long-dated bonds declined alongside stocks, sending 10-year yields sharply higher as investors worried about inflation, fiscal risks and strained market liquidity.
A similar pattern emerged following the outbreak of the United States-Israel war with Iran on Feb 28, when oil prices surged and bond yields climbed on concerns that higher energy costs would fuel inflation.
Gold, another longstanding defensive asset, has also become less predictable. It fell alongside equities during a market downturn in late October, breaking through technical support levels and touching a one-year low.
“You’re running out of safe-haven fingers to count on,” Steve Englander, global head of Group of 10 foreign-exchange research and head of North America macro strategy at Standard Chartered Bank, says.
Safe-haven assets are traditionally expected to preserve their value or appreciate when markets fall, helping investors offset losses elsewhere. But their performance depends not only on underlying economic conditions but also on market positioning.
Englander points out that following a sudden shock, the strongest-performing haven could simply be an asset that investors had previously bet against and were subsequently forced to buy back.
Lost appeal
US treasuries remain the world’s largest and most liquid government bond market, making them a natural destination for investors seeking shelter during periods of uncertainty.
However, their defensive qualities become less convincing when inflation is the main concern and investors anticipate tighter monetary policy. Under such circumstances, rising yields can push bond prices lower even as equities come under pressure.
Will Compernolle, a macro strategist at FHN Financial, says volatility surrounding US tariff announcements have made it difficult to determine whether treasuries have genuinely lost their appeal.
Talk of a “Sell USA” trade, he notes, has not translated into meaningful changes in international transaction flows. Other episodes of market stress, including concerns over France’s fiscal position, have demonstrated that Treasuries continue to retain their safe-haven status.
“If there’s a risk-off mood, Treasuries are attractive,” he says. “But if there’s inflation or geopolitical risk, very few things are safe.”
Campbell Harvey, a finance professor at Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business, describes US Treasuries as “the bellwether safe asset in the world”.
Nevertheless, he observes that stocks and bonds have increasingly been moving in the same direction, weakening the diversification benefits of the traditional 60% equities and 40% bonds portfolio.
“Historically it’s been reliable. However, the diversification benefit has decreased,” Harvey tells Reuters.
He also highlights the growing burden of US government borrowing, with national debt reaching US$40 trillion, annual fiscal deficits of about US$2 trillion and interest payments of US$1.1 trillion.
These figures introduce another layer of risk for bond investors, particularly as concerns about the sustainability of government finances become more prominent.
Short-term refuge
Gold’s reputation as a store of value is built largely on its performance over extended periods rather than its ability to protect portfolios during every market correction.
Harvey tells Reuters the precious metal was highly reliable “over the extreme long term, which means centuries”, but warns that shorter investment horizons could produce very different results.
Its annualised volatility, at more than 15%, is comparable to that of the S&P 500.
Although gold’s correlation with equities is close to zero over three-year to five-year periods, this is an average that can change considerably over shorter intervals.
Gold can also struggle when inflation surprises investors on the upside, an environment that tends to weigh on financial markets.
Suki Cooper, Standard Chartered’s global head of commodities research, says gold’s role “has really evolved”.
Investors increasingly regard it as a high-quality liquid asset that can be sold to raise cash during periods of extreme market stress. When sharp equity declines trigger margin calls, gold often becomes an attractive source of liquidity, particularly after a prolonged rally.
Nevertheless, Cooper says the longer-term investment case remained supported by structural factors, including record central bank purchases since 2022, concerns about rising global debt, de-dollarisation and the erosion of currency purchasing power.
No perfect escape
The foreign exchange market presents its own challenges, with each potential safe-haven currency carrying particular vulnerabilities.
Englander says the Swiss franc is expensive, while the euro faces political and economic difficulties.
Sterling has performed well, although he points to the Labour government’s position further to the left than any British government in many years as a potential concern.
The Japanese yen can still offer protection during periods of market volatility, provided the turbulence is not driven by oil prices. Japan’s dependence on imported energy makes its currency particularly sensitive to movements in energy costs.
The US dollar, meanwhile, retains an advantage through its combination of relative safety and attractive yields.
Investors can park their money in Treasuries, “clip a 4.5% coupon” and decide where to allocate their capital once market conditions stabilise.
“By default”, Englander opines, that is “probably the safest of the safe havens”.
With no single asset offering dependable protection across different market environments, investors may need to rethink what a defensive portfolio should look like.
Harvey tells Reuters gold and Treasuries remain important components, but suggests broadening exposure to commodities, other real assets and inflation-protected government bonds.
Active investment strategies could also help.
Quality strategies, which involve buying shares in financially stronger companies while shorting weaker ones, may limit losses during significant market declines. Trend-following strategies, meanwhile, can potentially benefit from sustained market movements during selloffs.
However, Harvey cautions that none of these approaches is consistently effective on its own.
Combined, though, “you increase the chance that your defensive portfolio will actually work”, he says.
