PETALING JAYA: The artificial intelligence (AI) investment boom is facing growing scrutiny as investors question whether the billions of dollars being poured into the technology, including in data centres and semiconductor infrastructures, will generate sufficient returns.
The concerns have triggered a sell-off in technology stocks, with the Nasdaq Composite, which rode the AI boom to a record high of 27,722.75 points on Oct 6, retreating to 25,466.19 points, down 8.1% from its peak, after falling as much as 12.5% at one point.
The pullback has raised questions about whether the AI-driven rally is losing steam and, more importantly, what a potential correction could mean for markets and economies.
For Malaysia, the issue is particularly relevant given the country’s growing exposure to the global AI supply chain, with the technology boom providing a boost to electrical and electronics (E&E) exports, semiconductor demand and data centre investments.
In the first nine months of 2025, E&E exports rose 49.5% year-on-year to RM766.38bil, accounting for about half of total exports, or more precisely 48.8%.
The sector recorded a trade surplus of RM171.87bil, contributing about 74% of the country’s overall trade surplus of RM232.4bil.
The sustainability of the AI boom, therefore, has implications beyond global technology stocks, particularly for economies such as Malaysia that are increasingly tied to the AI supply chain.
SPI Asset Management managing partner Stephen Innes does not think the AI bubble has burst, but said “cracks” are beginning to emerge in the investment narrative.
“The problem isn’t AI technology itself. It’s the extraordinary amount of capital being thrown at it and whether investors will ever see an acceptable return,” he noted in a reply to StarBiz.
He said investors had been willing to support massive AI infrastructure spending by hyperscalers over the past two years, but were now placing greater emphasis on cash flow and returns on investment.
“Patience is wearing thin as financing costs remain elevated and investors increasingly focus on cash flow rather than simply applauding bigger spending announcements,” he said.
“We’re moving from the AI spending-at-any-cost phase to the show-me-the-money phase, and that’s a much tougher environment for richly valued technology stocks.”
For Malaysia, Innes said a pullback in AI spending could eventually affect export orders, manufacturing activity and corporate earnings, given the country’s exposure to the semiconductor and E&E supply chains.
Still, he said foreign portfolio outflows and weaker technology sentiment would likely affect Malaysian equities before any deterioration in export figures.
“Technology stocks would likely take the first hit, particularly where valuations depend heavily on continued AI investment,” he noted.
The Bursa Malaysia Technology Index has gained 25% year-to-date to 69.50 points, although it remains about 13.5% below its recent high of 80.39 points on Oct 12.
Beyond the equity market, he says a sustained slowdown in AI investments could also affect foreign direct investment, particularly in data centres and related infrastructure projects.
Any delay or scaling back of such projects could have knock-on effects on the construction, industrial property and utilities sectors, he added.
Innes said the ringgit could also come under pressure if an AI sell-off developed into a broader global risk-off event.
“The key distinction is between an AI valuation correction and an AI capital expenditure recession,” he said.
“Malaysia can weather the former reasonably well. The latter would be considerably more painful, particularly if it coincides with weaker US and Chinese demand.”
For Innes, the bigger concern is whether companies investing heavily in AI infrastructure will continue committing capital at their current pace.
“That’s where the real economic risk lies, and Malaysia is close enough to the centre of that spending cycle to feel it if the taps start turning off,” he added.
Ultimately, Innes said a 10% correction in the Nasdaq did not necessarily signal the end of the AI investment boom.
“The real danger comes if falling valuations, tighter financing conditions and political uncertainty force hyperscalers to start cutting spending rather than merely slowing its growth,” he said.
Adding to the uncertainty, Innes said, is the political landscape in the United States, where the Democratic sweep in the midterm elections could bring greater scrutiny of AI regulation and data centre expansion.
He said these developments could make it harder for companies to justify their enormous capital expenditure commitments.
Innes said Washington’s broader technology rivalry with China was also unlikely to ease, with export restrictions, trade uncertainty and potentially tougher AI oversight creating additional challenges for Malaysia’s E&E supply chains.
His base case remains that AI will be a “powerful structural growth story, although its investment cycle is vulnerable to a painful shakeout”.
“We saw something similar during the Internet boom. The technology changed the world, but plenty of investors financing the infrastructure lost their shirts,” he said.
Similarly, Tradeview Capital Sdn Bhd chief executive officer and founder Ng Zhu Hann believes the AI boom could eventually produce a shakeout.
He said concerns over whether AI investments would generate sufficient returns were valid, as investors would increasingly scrutinise whether companies could earn enough from those investments to meet their financing obligations.
Ng added that exuberance was common whenever new trends or emerging technologies gained traction, but companies would eventually have to prove that their investments could generate sustainable earnings.
“There’s always exuberance in the market when it comes to new trends or emerging technologies, whether it was the Internet or now AI. This exuberance will continue until reality kicks in,” he said.
Ng said the “AI bubble” had always existed, although its eventual size was difficult to predict. “In the event of a bubble burst, there will still be survivors. And who are the survivors? There will only be a handful,” he said.
He believes these survivors could go on to become dominant players in the years ahead, much like the Magnificent Seven technology stocks today.
From an investment perspective, he said his firm had remained cautious on US technology stocks even before the recent correction, given the sharp run-up in valuations over the past two years.
He said the correction was a healthy development as markets went through their natural ups and downs, adding that his firm’s cautious stance had so far been justified.
However, Ng said it was still too early to return to US technology stocks as market conditions remained unsettled.
“We think that the situation is still not stabilised. There is no need to rush,” he said.
For the Malaysian market, however, he expects technology companies along the semiconductor and data centre supply chains to continue delivering strong earnings, supported by investments and capacity expansion undertaken over the past two years.
He said these companies were beginning to reap the benefits of those earlier investments, with demand remaining strong, capacity largely full and forward orders extending into 2027 and 2028.
However, he cautioned that strong earnings growth would not necessarily translate into further share price gains, given the rally in technology stocks.
“The problem is that if the share price has already reflected, how much higher can it get? Whether the good news is already baked into the share price is another question altogether,” he said.
In his view, much of the positive news had already been reflected in valuations, making it risky for investors to chase technology stocks at current levels.
For instance, Vitrox Corp Bhd
has surged 157% year-to-date to RM10.20 at the time of writing, after reaching an all-time high of RM11.24 on Oct 12.
Inari Amertron Bhd
has gained 34% year-to-date to RM2.21, after reaching a 23-month high of RM2.88 on Oct 12, while Frontken Corp Bhd
has risen 19% to RM4.95, after hitting an all-time high of RM5.38 on Oct 8.
