Grab’s Uber deal still has some obstacles to navigate

  • TECH
  • Friday, 06 Apr 2018

Used Grab and Uber helmets are seen at used-helmet shop in Jakarta, Indonesia, April 2, 2018. REUTERS/Beawiharta/File

SINGAPORE: Regulatory scrutiny could complicate ride-hailing company Grab's takeover of Uber Technologies' South-East Asian business, but there is little the authorities can do to stop Uber from simply exiting the region, lawyers and analysts said.

Days after the deal was announced last week, antitrust agencies in Singapore and Philippines began to review it, with Malaysia saying it would follow suit.

Antitrust lawyers say Singapore-based Grab could try to mollify regulators by offering concessions such as price restrictions and subjecting itself to greater regulations. It could also argue that consumers still have many ride-hailing options to choose from.

"Rather than throwing out the deal, and especially with potential new entrants coming in, I believe that with the right safeguards, with the right commitments, the deal can still go through," said Gerald Singham, deputy managing partner at law firm Dentons Rodyk.

If the deal falls apart, Uber could depart Singapore and leave Grab as the dominant player regardless, experts said.

Uber is already winding down its regional operations and has asked customers and drivers to transition to Grab's platform. Five hundred Uber staffers will also move to Grab.

Market share data on the ride-hailing sector is patchy, but mobile data analytics firm App Annie ranks Grab ahead of Uber in all the big economies in South-East Asia in terms of monthly active users. The exception is Indonesia, where Tencent Holdings-backed Go-Jek was ahead.

"An antitrust issue is all about how can you minimise a monopoly which is hitting pricing power and is bad for consumers. But the reality here is that consumers have other options with the incumbent taxi operators in all markets," said a person familiar with the Grab deal who was not authorised to speak to the media.

Uber is selling its South-East Asia operations, including its food-delivery unit, to Grab after a five-year battle that cost the US company US$700mil (RM2.71bil). In return, Uber will get a 27.5% stake in Grab, which is valued at roughly US$6bil (RM23.24bil).

Grab's president Ming Maa told Reuters last week that passengers and drivers had plenty of other transportation options, from taxis to public transport.

And Go-Jek plans to enter Singapore soon in its first international expansion, the Straits Times reported this week.

Kala Anandarajah, who leads the competition and antitrust practice at Rajah & Tann Singapore, said that though barriers to entry in the ride-hailing sector were relatively low in Singapore and South-East Asia, new entrants had to start off big enough to compete effectively with a potential Grab-Uber entity.

Singapore's antitrust agency told Reuters it would consider Go-Jek and taxi companies such as ComfortDelgro Corp as part of the market as it determines competition during its investigation of the Grab-Uber deal.

The interim measures proposed by the Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore require Uber and Grab to maintain their pre-transaction independent pricing and not share any confidential data. This week Grab presented the agency with written proposals on the deal.

Uber to declined to comment. Grab had no immediate comment and referred to a previous statement in which it said the deal did not decrease competition and was beneficial to both riders and drivers.

"At this juncture, regulators don't have much recourse since the assets being transferred from Uber to Grab are of little consequence. So even if the asset transfer is blocked, Grab's goal, which is to push Uber out of Southeast Asia, has already been achieved," said Corrine Png, chief executive of research firm Crucial Perspective.

"However, Grab will be careful not to step on the regulators' toes," Png added. — Reuters

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Join our Telegram channel to get our Evening Alerts and breaking news highlights

Next In Tech News

Facebook oversight board seeks clarity on review system for high-profile users
Facebook to launch portable version of Portal video chat device
Former F1 driver Rosberg, Agnelli's Exor invest in adopt-a-tree site Treedom
EU plans to legislate for common phone charger despite Apple grumbles
AT&T plans multi-year effort to burnish its brand image
Facebook spent over $13 billion on safety, security since 2016
Biden sanctions cryptocurrency exchange over ransomware attacks
Banks say draft capital rules make cryptoassets too costly to trade
Google to buy more office space in NYC as big tech swoops down on real estate
Brazil's Gol hails deal to bring flying taxis to Sao Paulo

Stories You'll Enjoy