Higher costs cloud CTOS Digital outlook despite service restoration


“We estimate CTOS may require several weeks to monitor transaction volumes and assess the pace of recovery towards pre-incident levels,” CIMB Securities said.

PETALING JAYA: Despite CTOS Digital Bhd announcing on Nov 2 that affected credit reporting services have resumed after measures were taken to ensure data security, there continues to be uncertainty over the company’s outlook.

Analysts pointed to concerns over the pace of earnings recovery, the return of customers to pre-incident levels and higher expenditure on cybersecurity measures that would impact margins.

The cybersecurity incident occurred on Sept 23.

CIMB Securities has maintained a “hold” call on the stock with a 43 sen a share target price (TP) based on 14 times price-to-earnings.

However, it remains cautious on the pace of earnings recovery for the financial year ending Dec 31, 2027 (FY27) amid higher cybersecurity operating expenses, customer retention costs, and the upcoming expiry of its pioneer tax status.

While positive on the resumption of affected services, the research house said the financial impact of potential service fee waivers and customer compensation remained unquantified.

“We estimate CTOS may require several weeks to monitor transaction volumes and assess the pace of recovery towards pre-incident levels,” it said.

It noted that while the resumption of services limits further earnings downside risks.

This is given the earlier estimate of an RM2.5mil revenue loss and a RM1.3mil reduction in profit after tax and minority interests (Patami) for each additional week of disruption, the normalisation of transaction volumes and resumption of customer onboarding remains key to earnings.

Kenanga Research has maintained a “market perform” call on the counter with a TP of 40 sen per share on a discounted cash flow (DCF) basis after raising FY26 core Patami by 10.6% imputing the earlier-than-assumed service restoration.

“Conversely, we trim our FY27 earnings by 2.9% to reflect higher operating expenditure (opex) to strengthen cybersecurity post-incident,” it said.

“The FY26 earnings upgrade is not materially accretive to our TP, as our DCF valuation is anchored on FY27 as a base year.

“Meanwhile, the slight cut to our FY27 earnings is offset by a lower share base following CTOS’ recent share buybacks,” it added.

It remained cautious about higher-than-expected margin compression and earnings erosion from customer compensation and retention initiatives, recurring opex to strengthen cybersecurity infrastructure, customer attrition and a slow recovery in volumes.

“While our forecasts incorporate some of these costs, the actual impact could be higher, depending on negotiations over service-level agreement breaches and contractual remedies.

“This includes customer discounts, rebates, fee waivers, credit notes and contract extensions,” it said.

It added the potential impact of deferred price increases for selected products has not been factored in as the company prioritises customer retention.

While no customers have terminated their contracts or indicated that they would do so, this cannot be ruled out, as customer confidence may have been dented by the incident.

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In Business News

An energy planning dilemma
Search for safe haven gets harder
Yen’s unpredictable game
Bracing for more bond volatility
Time for RCI on corporate mafia
Building wealth for the long haul
Tech currencies are well-off
A Soviet icon’s 5-star reinvention
India back in favour?
No SUV, no problem��

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read