Tribunal wrong to clear ex-lawmaker Margaret Ng of misconduct, court told


A disciplinary tribunal erred in its decision to clear barrister and former Hong Kong opposition lawmaker Margaret Ng Ngoi-yee of professional misconduct over her conviction for taking part in an unlawful assembly in 2019, a court was told on Monday.

The Hong Kong Bar Association, the professional body for the city’s barristers, sought a court ruling to revoke the decision, arguing that the panel had overlooked “the likelihood of Ng’s action bringing the legal profession into disrepute”.

Benjamin Yu Yuk-hoi SC told the High Court on Monday that the association’s council had applied for judicial review to seek a clarification of its code of conduct after the Barristers Disciplinary Tribunal found the complaint against Ng unsubstantiated.

Ng was convicted in April 2021 of taking part in an unauthorised assembly that began as a lawful gathering at Victoria Park on August 18, 2019.

The Hong Kong Bar Association is the professional body for the city’s barristers. Photo: Edmond So

A three-member panel heard the complaint and ruled that her criminality in the case was not so “morally culpable, disgraceful or dishonourable” as to warrant professional sanction.

The panel comprised chairwoman Charlotte Draycott SC, barrister Jolie Chao Tsz-kwan and veteran social worker Sze Lai-shan.

Yu, representing the council, said the panel had erred in law by failing to apply the appropriate legal principle to assess whether Ng’s involvement had constituted misconduct.

“If the tribunal had applied the law correctly ... it would have found the conduct had brought the bar into disrepute,” Yu said.

He said a more stringent legal test should have been applied to assess whether Ng’s conduct would bring the bar into disrepute in the eyes of objective bystanders.

Instead, the panel looked at whether Ng’s actions had caused actual damage.

Citing the verdict and sentencing reasons in Ng’s case, Yu said “it was barely arguable that” the barrister’s actions were not “very serious”.

He said Ng, “a prominent barrister in the public limelight”, had been found by the court to have led the public to defy a police ban, held up a banner and told people it was fine to break the law if they exercised civil disobedience.

But, based on the tribunal’s deliberations, it had taken Ng’s political motive into account.

Yu argued that Ng’s political beliefs were “irrelevant” in a disciplinary hearing, since the bar’s code required barristers to uphold the rule of law.

The tribunal was not legally represented in the proceedings, having earlier notified the court that it would not attend the hearing or make any submissions regarding the lawsuit.

Tim Parker SC, for Ng, said the panel had not lost sight of the law, as it recognised there was a propensity for a barrister’s conduct to expose the bar to criticism among a section of the public.

Parker said that despite Yu’s repeated assertions that Ng’s actions had damaged the standing of the legal profession, he failed to identify any actual or potential impact on the bar’s reputation.

He also stressed that Ng’s participation in the assembly fell outside her legal practice, contending that Yu had attached an “illogical” relevance to her prominence as a barrister by profession and as a public figure from her political activities.

The council sought a declaration from the presiding judge, Madam Justice Queeny Au Yeung Kwai-yue, to revoke the tribunal’s decision and remit the matter to a fresh panel.

Noting that Ng had retired from legal practice at the end of 2025, Yu said the challenge was not merely academic, as the court’s ruling would help set a precedent.

Au Yeung reserved judgment, to be handed down within six months. -- SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In Aseanplus News

Can Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin give Donald Trump the Iran exit he needs?
Japan PM Takaichi begins trip to the Philippines and China for Asean, APEC talks
Written in bone: China bets on ancient scripts for modern soft power
UN chief warns against appeasement, even as Asean mulls renewed engagement with Myanmar
Ringgit ends mostly higher against major currencies, slips against greenback
Dewan Rakyat erupts over Ahmad Maslan’s ‘kencing’ pantun
Anthony Kwong falsely claimed father killed Abby Choi so damage was ‘minimal’, court hears
Title holders Buriram Utd of Thailand to unveil new coach Raul Caneda in Asean Club Championship Shopee Cup
China, Russia and US try to nail down AI nuclear agenda in time for Apec talks
Bursa Malaysia snaps five-day losing streak on bargain-hunting

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read