Are texting and Facebook really worse for kids than TV?
LET’S face it: Teenagers spend hours texting, socialising on Facebook and playing videogames. And it’s driving their parents nuts.
Sure, there are real dangers associated with all this screen time — everything from cyberbullying to couch-potato obesity. Not to mention driving while texting, shortened attention spans and Internet porn.
But many of today’s parents spent hours as kids sitting in front of screens too — only they were TV screens.
Which raises an interesting question: Is Facebook really worse for teenagers’ brains than the mindless reruns of Gilligan’s Island and The Brady Bunch that their parents consumed growing up?
Douglas Gentile, a child psychologist and associate professor at Iowa State University in Ames, Iowa, who studies the effects of media on children, says texting, Facebook and videogames are not inherently bad.
Nor are they inherently better or worse than watching TV, although they do pose different risks, such as cyberbullying. But research has shown that the more time kids spend in front of screens — whether it’s TV or instant-messaging — the worse their school performance.
“That doesn’t mean it’s true for every kid, but it makes sense, that for every hour a kid is playing videogames, it’s an hour that they’re not doing homework or reading or exploring or creating,” he said.
Gentile calls this the “displacement hypothesis. If screen time is displacing doing their homework, that’s bad. But if their homework is done, well, so what?”
Gentile, who admits that his own teenager crossed the “9,000 texts in one month barrier” last summer, acknowledged that parents are struggling to adjust to a world in which kids would rather look at words on a cellphone screen than have a conversation.
“The older generation, it’s not their culture,” he said. “There is a resistance to it.”
Watching TV as a family, as mindless as that experience can be, is now regarded with nostalgia by parents.
If your kid is sitting in the living room watching American Idol, you can plop on the sofa with them, and “it’s a shared experience,” Gentile said.
But if they’re texting or video-chatting with a friend from school, “it’s a private experience. It’s like they’re whispering secrets. And we find it rude.”
Patti Rowlson, a mother of two in Everson, Washington, says this “has been a topic of discussion in our house for years now.” She and her husband started out limiting TV time when their kids were little, but “then technology crept in. Cellphones, laptop computers, iPods with WiFi.
We, as parents, were no longer in control of screen time because we could not even tell when they were using it.”
Recounting a struggle that will sound familiar to many parents, Rowlson said that at first, she and her husband imposed limits on tech use.
“There were battles and even groundings,” along with the confiscation of iPods, she said. “We were constantly policing and the kids were constantly getting in trouble. We were trying to fight for the old ways, and it was causing a lot of stress and tension in the family. It was ridiculous.
“So we loosened up. And it’s made everybody happier. We were fighting something that you can’t hold back. It’s how they communicate with their peers.”
What’s been the result? Two good kids, she said. “In the end I’m not sure if having boundaries early on helped them or made no difference at all.”
Ron Neal, who lives in West Los Angeles, has a teenage daughter who is “tech-driven and passionate about it .... I don’t know how it’s going to play out, but I don’t have this fear and dread about it.”
Neal, who admits to watching a lot of Gilligan’s Island growing up, added: “We had our minds numbed by TV, and maybe they’re looking at useless things on the Internet or YouTube, but I also think they’re developing a lot of skills through this technology that we could never comprehend.
“For my daughter, when she is home, she does have everything going — the TV, the computer, communicating with friends, and doing the homework at the same time.”
He admits, though, that there are some frightening aspects to the dependence today’s teenagers have on technology.
“They are so emotionally connected to being tied in with their friends 24 hours a day, if they get a text, they feel obligated to respond in seconds,” he said.
He recalled a group of girls showing up for a birthday party at a restaurant, and “everyone of them had their head down, texting.”
The explosion in teen screen time is well-documented. A recent Associated Press-mtvU poll found that one-third of college students use computers, cellphones or gaming consoles for six or more hours daily.
A Kaiser Family Foundation study published in January found that total media use among 8- to 18-year-olds, including TV, music, computers, videogames, print and movies has increased from six hours, 21 minutes daily in 2004 to seven hours, 38 minutes in 2009.
“Try waking a teenager in the morning and the odds are good that you’ll find a cellphone tucked under their pillow,” the Kaiser report said.
The Kaiser study also found that the more time kids spend with media, the lower their grades and levels of personal contentment are.
Gentile said the impact of screen time on school work can be mitigated by what he calls “protective factors.”
Those might include good teachers and a high-performing school, love of reading, coming from a family where education is valued, and exposure to experiences that are culturally and intellectually enriching.
“If you had all these protective factors,” said Gentile, “then that one little risk factor (screen time), who cares?”
He added that surprisingly, the amount of time kids spend watching TV has not declined precipitously with the popularity of computers and gaming, but “they don’t pay nearly the attention (to TV) that they used to.”
The TV might be on, but “they’re also instant-messaging, they’re on Facebook, they’re texting.”
One thing parents should worry about, Gentile said, is the way electronic devices encourage multitasking.
“Multitasking is not really good for anyone,” he said. “Your reflexes speed up, you’re quicker to look over your shoulder and notice little noises or lights. This is not what they need when they get to the classroom and you’re supposed to ignore the kid next to you.
“Scanning to see when the next message comes, this may not be good for kids. The more distractions you have, the worse your performance is.”
Getting kids to turn off their phones, iPods, and computers in order to concentrate on homework and reading, he said, “I think that’s a fight worth having.”
Bottom line: Never mind that your kid is spending two hours on Facebook each night. As long as they do their homework without texting in between math problems, it’s probably no better or worse than the hours you spent watching Star Trek. — AP
Did you find this article insightful?