Caning shows growing religious intolerance

  • Letters
  • Monday, 17 Mar 2003

SISTERS IN ISLAM of Kuala Lumpur (via e-mail) writes:  

WE refer to your report, “Fellow students present at flogging, says victim,” (The Star, March 14). 

The authorities and responsible citizens must take immediate steps to stop vigilante punitive action taken by overzealous individuals in the name of religion.  

The hudud punishment inflicted on Mohd Asrul Ahmad reflects a distorted obsession with sex, morality and punishment among Muslims who feel they have the right to take the law into their own hands in the name of religion.  

Equally distressing is the behaviour of those who witnessed the brutality, and yet did nothing to help the two students, but instead applauded and counted the lashes. 


The incident brings into question the role of the school authorities in ensuring the safety and security of their students. It is perplexing that these outsiders managed to have contact and access to the students on school premises.  


For too long, Malaysians have been silent and silenced in the face of the growing conservatism and intolerance in the country. 

Over the years, we have received many reports of a whole range of vigilante action taken in the name of religion. 

This has spanned from women stopped by security guards from entering public buildings because of the way they dressed, to state-sponsored vigilante groups targeting couples for khalwat offences.  


It has reached a point where Islam has come to be equated with spying into the private lives of citizens and humiliating and harsh punishment, rather than with mercy and compassion. 


The obsession with sex, morality and segregation between the sexes has resulted in a mindset that men and women, boys and girls, are incapable of having platonic friendships and that any kind of interaction between them could only lead to maksiat.  

That Mohd Asrul was flogged 25 lashes for the “crime” of chatting in public should serve as a wake-up call to the Malaysian public of the dangerous path we tread when we remain silent on issues pertaining to religion. 

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Subscribe now to our Premium Plan for an ad-free and unlimited reading experience!

Next In Letters

Raising awareness of heart problems
What ails govt service?
Roads to Fraser’s Hill in need of regular maintenance
Exotic animals are not pets
Put flood victims in other places
Faster treatment from specialist at older hospital
Another way for scammers to get the money
Recruitment fees for maids just don’t tally
We cannot continue living with the existential threat of nuclear weapons
Better care for all

Others Also Read