PETALING JAYA: The application process for underage marriages should be strengthened to prevent parents from exploiting loopholes, says the Malaysian Muslim Lawyers Association.
Its president Muhamad Hisham Marzuki said syariah court judges should use discretion when assessing individual cases, taking into account factors such as geographical location, family background and family history.
“Even if the pattern of cases appears to be the same, there may be different factors that need to be considered,” he said.
Muhamad Hisham said Islamic family matters fall under the jurisdiction of state authorities, with the Sultan serving as the head of Islam in each state.
Any changes to existing approaches, he noted, would need to take into account Islamic principles, including maqasid syariah (the higher objectives of Islamic law), within the context of the time in which they were applied.
On preventing underage marriages, he said the application process should be strengthened to identify possible loopholes, including instances where parents might provide false information about their income or family circumstances to support an application.
Islamic Renaissance Front founder and director Datuk Dr Ahmad Farouk Musa supported making psychological, medical and financial assessments compulsory before the syariah courts considered such applications.
Dr Ahmad, an associate professor in the Department of Surgery at RCSI & UCD Malaysia Campus, added that the absence of a streamlined process could leave decisions to individual discretion.
He added that poverty and a lack of education are among the underlying factors contributing to underage marriages and could perpetuate a cycle of disadvantage.
Efforts to address the issue should go beyond legal procedures and include improving the socio-economic circumstances of vulnerable communities, particularly in rural areas, he said.
“By alleviating poverty, we can provide better access to education,” he said, adding that this should include age-appropriate sex education to help prevent teenage and unintended pregnancies.
On Nov 11, Women, Family and Community Development Minister Datuk Seri Nancy Shukri told Parliament that only Selangor and Kedah had amended their laws to set the minimum marriage age for Muslims at 18.
She said 1,361 underage marriages were recorded in 2024, compared with 923 in 2023 and 1,467 in 2019.
She said the ministry is engaging state governments towards nationwide standardisation.
Nancy added that studies on the effectiveness of the National Strategic Plan to Address the Causes of Underage Marriage (2020-2025) and efforts to standardise the minimum legal marriage age nationwide are expected to be completed early next year.
