PETALING JAYA: Malaysia needs coordinated legal reforms covering civil, Islamic and customary marriage laws to ensure that all children are protected from underage marriage, say women’s rights advocates.
Association of Women Lawyers vice-president Denise Lim said the absence of a uniform minimum marriage age of 18 across all communities remained a major legal gap.
She added that raising the minimum marriage age under one legal framework alone would not be sufficient, as different laws continued to govern civil, Islamic and native customary marriages.
For non-Muslims, girls aged between 16 and 18 may still marry with the approval of the Chief Minister, while Islamic family matters fall under state jurisdiction, with provisions for underage marriages subject to approval by the Syariah Courts.
Orang Asli customary marriages are also governed by a separate legal framework that does not prescribe a uniform minimum marriage age, she noted.
“The next phase of the National Strategic Plan to Address the Causes of Underage Marriage should prioritise stronger federal-state coordination and comprehensive data collection to identify the scale and circumstances of child marriages.
“This should include the ages of both parties, the number of applications approved and rejected, marriages solemnised and registered, as well as unregistered customary marriages and informal unions,” Lim said.
She added that studies should also assess whether a child’s views, welfare and best interests were meaningfully considered before an underage marriage was approved.
Lim said these views were also shared by the association’s executive committee and immediate past president Daniella Zulkifili.
Women’s Aid Organisation executive director Nazreen Nizam said parental agreement or promises of financial support are insufficient to establish that a marriage is in a minor’s best interests.
Authorities must assess whether the child is safe, could continue her education, is in an unequal relationship or possibly faces abuse, and has the freedom to refuse the marriage, she said.
Citing previous research, including a 2018 Unicef study, Nazreen said pregnancy, concerns over sex outside marriage and parental approval had been among the considerations in child marriage applications.
“Pregnancy does not make a child ready for marriage.
“It should prompt access to healthcare, emotional support, help to stay in school and an investigation where sexual abuse is suspected,” she said.
Nazreen cautioned against assuming all judges approached applications in the same way, calling for greater scrutiny of existing procedures and whether children could express their views freely.
Nazreen called for a minimum marriage age of 18 for both girls and boys, without exceptions, supported by coordinated amendments to civil, Islamic and native customary laws.
She also suggested that the law should prevent adults from arranging or facilitating child marriages, including overseas marriages intended to circumvent domestic restrictions.
Children facing the threat of marriage should have access to independent legal assistance, safe accommodation and urgent court orders to stop planned marriages or prevent them from being taken overseas, she said.
On Nov 11, Women, Family and Community Development Minister Datuk Seri Nancy Shukri told Parliament that only Selangor and Kedah had amended their laws to set the minimum marriage age for Muslims at 18.
On Nov 14, Kelantan Islamic Development, Dakwah, Information and Regional Relations Committee chairman Mohd Asri Mat Daud reiterated that a blanket prohibition is unsuitable for the state.
He said the position is consistent with Section 8 of the Islamic Family Law Enactment 2002, retained in the Islamic Family Law Enactment 2025.
The state had established standard operating procedures for underage marriage applications and a special committee involving relevant stakeholders to seek solutions based on Islamic principles and public interest, Mohd Asri added.
