PETALING JAYA: The government’s MediAsas medical insurance scheme risks becoming increasingly expensive for policyholders if rising private healthcare costs are not addressed, while questions remain over whether it can adequately protect those who need coverage most, say health experts.
Their concerns follow findings by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) that the pilot programme was unrepresentative and recorded no hospital admissions or insurance claims, raising questions about its readiness for nationwide implementation in January 2027.
MediAsas aims to expand access to affordable and sustainable medical and health insurance and takaful (MHIT) coverage amid rising private healthcare costs.
Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia associate professor and public health medicine specialist Dr Mohd Hafiz Jaafar said the pilot had yet to demonstrate how the scheme would work when policyholders needed hospital treatment.
While acknowledging its objectives, he urged the government to reconsider its approach rather than rush into nationwide implementation.
“We also need to ask whether the people involved in the pilot truly represent those who need financial protection the most,” he said.
The PAC also expressed concern over the delay in amending the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998 until the first quarter of 2028, warning that the prolonged wait could leave consumers vulnerable to fee manipulation and excessive markups on non-professional hospital charges.
Assoc Prof Mohd Hafiz said MediAsas’ affordability would hinge on controlling underlying private healthcare costs.
“We cannot expect insurance premiums to remain affordable if the underlying cost of hospital treatment continues to increase.
“I appreciate that the government has started looking into hospital price transparency and other cost-control measures,” he said.
“However, these efforts need to move together with healthcare financing reform.”
He said wider implementation of Diagnosis-Related Groups (DRG), or casemix-based payments, could help control expenditure by linking hospital payments to the type and complexity of cases rather than individual services.
However, Assoc Prof Mohd Hafiz cautioned that DRG alone would not resolve the problem without accurate clinical coding, appropriate payment rates and quality monitoring.
He also urged Malaysia to consider a National Health Insurance system to distribute healthcare risks and financial responsibilities more widely across the population.
Meanwhile, Galen Centre for Health and Social Policy chief executive Azrul Mohd Khalib said the absence of actual hospital admissions and claims during the pilot meant it had tested enrolment rather than the scheme’s ability to provide insurance protection.
He warned that operational problems, including delayed guarantee letters, rejected claims and unresolved disputes, could leave patients facing unexpected bills or delays in receiving treatment.
“Bank Negara must require rigorous end-to-end testing, including emergency admissions and claims disputes, before nationwide implementation,” he said.
“The January 2027 deadline must not take priority over patient protection.”
Referring to the concerns raised, Azrul said the pilot’s success should be measured by how many previously uninsured Malaysians gained meaningful protection, rather than simply the number of policies sold.
On affordability, he warned that MediAsas risked benefiting existing policyholders seeking cheaper coverage instead of reaching previously uninsured Malaysians.
Azrul added that even monthly premiums of RM60 could be beyond the reach of households with irregular incomes, particularly when deductibles, co-payments and exclusions were factored in.
“The RM200 first-year subsidy is insufficient, while using EPF savings risks undermining retirement security.
“Targeted, sustained subsidies are needed for lower-income and vulnerable groups. Affordable premiums do not necessarily mean affordable healthcare,” he said.
