PETALING JAYA: A proposal for a dedicated ministry to oversee ageing issues is all well and good, but such a ministry won’t help matters if it becomes another layer of bureaucracy.
While a dedicated ministry could help coordinate efforts to support Malaysia’s ageing population, the focus should be on ensuring policies across ministries and agencies are properly carried out, particularly on retirement savings, long-term care, employment and age-friendly facilities, an expert said.
Universiti Putra Malaysia’s Malaysian Research Institute on Ageing research officer Chai Sen Tyng said Malaysia needs stronger political leadership and institutional accountability to address population ageing and cautioned that establishing a dedicated ministry could inadvertently create a silo.
“Population ageing affects almost every aspect of government, including finance, employment, education, health, housing, transport, social protection, local government and urban planning.
“It cannot be addressed effectively by placing responsibility just within one particular ministry.
“Many of the practical determinants of ageing will fall within state and local government jurisdictions as well,” he said.
He said the priority should be effective coordination and implementation rather than creating another layer of bureaucracy, noting that many countries addressed ageing through existing inter- ministerial structures and whole-of-government strategies.
Chai also called for ageing considerations to be incorporated into national policies and budgets through ageing impact assessments, age-responsive budgeting, measurable national indicators and clear ministerial performance targets.
Universiti Sains Malaysia’s Dr Nik Norliati Fitri Md Nor, who specialises in ageing populations and socio-spatial demography, said a dedicated ministry could help Malaysia plan for population ageing more systematically, but stressed that it must have the authority and resources to coordinate policies across multiple ministries.
She said the main weakness in the current system is not an absence of agencies responsible for older persons but the lack of coordination among them, resulting in fragmented services and different procedures for those seeking assistance.
“What is more important is that the proposed ministry genuinely has the power, financial resources and ability to coordinate policies that are currently under various ministries.
“Malaysia can no longer view population ageing as an issue of the future. The change is happening now, and our preparations must move in tandem with it,” she said.
She also said Malaysia has a shorter time to prepare for an ageing population compared with Japan, which has one of the world’s oldest populations.
According to a Financial Times article, Japan became aware of its imminent ageing problem and began developing social protection and elderly care systems as far back as the early 1960s.
Nik Norliati Fitri said Malaysia still needs to strengthen healthcare facilities, train more caregivers, and expand home-care services as demand for long-term care increases.
Senior lawyer K. Siladass said the proposal by Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department, Hannah Yeoh, is timely, given the longstanding issues affecting older persons.
He added, however, that Malaysia should prioritise the proposed Senior Citizens Bill and ensure that it is not delayed by discussions over establishing a new ministry.
The Bill is under Women, Family and Community Development Minister Nancy Shukri and is expected to be tabled in Parliament early next year.
“The suggested ministry might take time. It is advisable that the Bill Nancy Shukri is in the process of finalising be given preference – Hannah Yeoh’s suggestion should not delay the much-awaited Bill,” he said.
He said the proposed ministry and legislation should address the needs of older Malaysians who had contributed to the country throughout their lives and who should not be neglected or mistreated in their later years.
“They have given their best years to the country, and they should not be ignored, neglected, or bullied in the evenings of their lives,” he said.
