KUALA LUMPUR: The Dewan Rakyat witnessed an unusual procedural dispute on Monday (Nov 16) when Deputy Speaker Datuk Seri Ramli Mohd Nor left the Speaker’s chair to take his place at the MP’s bench and debate the Supply Bill (Budget 2027), leaving the chair momentarily vacant.
While reading out the list of debaters for the Works Ministry’s committee-stage debate, Ramli announced that he would also be participating in his capacity as the MP for Cameron Highlands. He then stepped down from the dais and walked over to his MP seat.
The move immediately drew an objection from Datuk Seri Ronald Kiandee (PN-Beluran), who questioned who was presiding over the House while the chair stood empty. Calling the move unprecedented, Ronald argued that a temporary Speaker should have been appointed before Ramli stepped down to debate.
Ramli defended his action, saying he had checked the rules and found no prohibition against it, adding that he intended to return to the chair immediately after delivering his speech.
"YB, I am also the Speaker, and I have chosen to speak from my seat. I have checked, and that does not go against any rules. I will return to my seat and preside as Deputy Speaker after debating," Ramli told the House.
Following brief exchanges between the two, Deputy Speaker Alice Lau entered the chamber to temporarily take over the chair, prompting Ramli to return to the dais.
Datuk Ngeh Khoo Ham (PH-Beruas) then stood up to voice strong disappointment over the incident, arguing that the Standing Orders clearly require a presiding officer to occupy the chair at all times to ensure proceedings run in accordance with the rules.
"I express my disappointment and objection, and I hope Parliament will not become a laughing stock in Malaysia and to the world," Ngeh said, calling for the episode to be expunged from the Hansard and reminding Ramli to adhere strictly to parliamentary regulations.
In response, Ramli cited Standing Order 99—which empowers the Speaker to interpret the Standing Orders and issue rulings on procedural matters—and told Ngeh he was free to file a substantive motion if he disagreed with the ruling.
Reiterating that he had not abdicated his responsibilities, Ramli resumed presiding over the sitting. Meanwhile, government backbenchers' chief Datuk Seri Dr Zaliha Mustafa (PH-Sekijang) noted that because the situation was unprecedented, clear procedural guidance should be established moving forward.
