Indonesia government appeals Jakarta air pollution verdict


Smog covers the Jakarta skyline. - Jakarta Post/ANN

JAKARTA, Oct 10 (Jakarta Post/ANN): The government has filed an appeal against a recent Central Jakarta District Court ruling that found President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo and other top government officials guilty of negligence for failing to tackle Jakarta’s chronic air pollution.

Ilyas Asaad, an expert staffer for the Environment and Forestry Ministry, said the President, the environment ministry, the Home Ministry and the Health Ministry had filed the appeal with the Jakarta High Court on Sept. 29.

“An appeal is just an ordinary mechanism [to be used] if we have something that we object to [in a ruling],” Ilyas told The Jakarta Post.

He said the government’s decision to appeal the ruling was driven by the failure of the judges to take into account a new regulation pertaining to air quality, namely Government Regulation (PP) No. 22/2021.

The PP, a derivative regulation of the Job Creation Law, updates provisions in PP No. 41/1999 on air pollution control.

The new regulation, issued on Feb. 2, requires governors, mayors and regents to commission studies analyzing the causes of air pollution in the regions they lead, among other provisions.

The data from the studies is to be handed over to the central government to allow it to formulate a nationwide air pollution control policy.

State Secretariat expert staffer Faldo Maldini noted on Wednesday that the government remained committed to improving air quality, regardless of the ruling and the results of the ensuing appeal.

In contrast to the central government’s response, hours after the verdict was read on Sept. 16, Jakarta Governor Anies Baswedan said the city administration would not appeal the ruling.

The Central Jakarta District Court ruled in partial favor of 32 residents of Greater Jakarta grouped under the Capital City Coalition, which in 2019 sued the President, the environment minister, the health minister and the home minister, as well as the governors of Jakarta, Banten and West Java, for failing to improve air quality in the capital city.

In the ruling, the court said the officials had broken the law. It ordered them to tighten the city’s air quality regulations and to ensure that the Jakarta administration’s efforts to tackle air pollution were supervised.

The judges, however, declined to rule that the actions of the officials had constituted a violation of human rights as the petitioners had demanded.

The plaintiffs said in a statement last week that they had decided to accept the verdict, even though some of their demands had not been fully met. Ayu Eza Tiara, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, said the coalition was disappointed that the central government had decided to appeal the ruling.

“We were hoping that the government would actually do what the verdict told them to do,” Ayu told the Post.

She added that although appealing to a higher court was a common legal procedure, doing so would likely lengthen the time that Jakarta’s citizens would have to deal with unhealthy air as the appeal could affect the Jakarta administration’s policies to improve air quality.

“We hope that the central government withdraws its appeal or at least immediately starts to clean up the air without waiting for the final verdict,” Ayu said.

The Health Ministry and the Home Ministry were not immediately available for comment. Jakarta’s severe air pollution stems mostly from vehicle emissions, factories and coal-fired power plants.

In a recent report by the C40 Cities network, Jakarta was in the top three of 61 cities observed worldwide for premature deaths related to air pollution from coal-fired power plants.

In 2019, more than 1,500 deaths in the city were attributed to the burning of coal. That figure is expected to double to more than 3,000 fatalities by 2030, by which time a number of new coal-fired power plants are expected to be operational. - Jakarta Post/ANN

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 46
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Join our Telegram channel to get our Evening Alerts and breaking news highlights
   

Next In Aseanplus News

New Covid-19 variant fears see global travel restrictions increasing as Philippines and Singapore takes steps against variant
12 more Chinese companies are placed on US export blacklist
Vietnam's commitment at COP26 marks a turning point in climate change policy, says expert
Earthquake of 6.1 magnitude hits Myanmar-India border area; Covid-19 cases decreasing in Myanmar
ASEM vows unity, co-op and jab multilateralism, says Cambodian PM
Brunei keeping an eye on new Covid-19 variant developments
China and Laos education forum aims for higher-education cooperation
Vietnam considers Japan a long term, important and reliable strategic partner, says PM
Kirin to contest Myanmar junta firm bid to end brewery deal
Covid-19 Watch: 5,097 new cases bring total to 2,619,577

Others Also Read


Vouchers