US bill requiring carriers to report ‘terror’ criticised

  • TECH
  • Wednesday, 05 Aug 2015

Onerous burden: A new US bill would require Internet companies like Facebook and Twitter to make judgement calls about what constituted "terrorist activity" on their networks and report them to the authorities. Photo: Reuters

WASHINGTON: A coalition including civil liberties and human rights activists urged US lawmakers to reject a bill that would require Internet companies to report signs of “terrorist activity” on their networks. 

More than 30 organisations endorsed an open letter urging the Senate to reject the measure included in an intelligence authorisation act which cleared a committee and had been on track for Senate passage without debate. 

“Turning Internet companies into informants for the government flies in the face of individuals’ fundamental right to privacy,” said Emma Llanso, at the Centre for Democracy & Technology, one of the groups leading the opposition. 

“People who know their online service providers are required to turn over a broad category of communications and ‘activity’ to the government will face a serious chilling effect on their willingness to access information and speak their minds online.” 

The groups said the Senate was set to consider passage by unanimous consent, or without debate, before Senator Ron Wyden objected, temporarily blocking the bill. 

They noted that the reporting provision was added during closed proceedings of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence and would require social media platforms, telecom providers, cloud services and websites to provide authorities with their users’ personal information and communications content if terrorist activity was suspected. 

“Unfortunately, this provision would create strong incentives for providers to overreport on the activity and communications of their users in order to avoid violating the law,” the letter said. 

“This provision risks bringing wholly innocent people under the scrutiny of the US government in a procedure that includes no limits on the use of the reported information and no safeguards against abuse.” 

Signatories of the letter include the American Civil Liberties Union, Human Rights Watch, Consumer Federation of America and the Software & Information Industry Association. 

Wyden, in blocking the bill, said it had “a flawed provision that would require companies like Twitter and Facebook to make judgments about when users’ speech constitutes ‘terrorist activity.’“ 

Markham Erickson of the law firm Steptoe and Johnson said in a blog post that the provision could “serve as a global template for other countries to impose reporting requirements for activities those jurisdictions deem unlawful.” – AFP

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Join our Telegram channel to get our Evening Alerts and breaking news highlights

Next In Tech News

Russia opens case against WhatsApp for violating personal data law
Amazon hit with record EU data privacy fine
Pinterest shares slump as growth warning rattles investors
Online retailer Boohoo to move to new auditing model for suppliers
Crypto exchange Binance to wind down futures and derivatives offerings in Europe
Flawed scientific papers fueling Covid-19 misinformation
UK's Deliveroo mulls ending Spain operations on high costs
Study: Most Malaysians on 3G networks actually have 4G-capable phones
Big Tech booms even as lockdown living wanes
Fire breaks out in Tesla Megapack unit in Australia during testing

Stories You'll Enjoy