The real business of diplomacy in Manila


THE first morning of the 49th Asean Summit in Manila brought a welcome gesture from Indonesia’s President Prabowo Subianto. In his remarks to fellow leaders, he apologised to Malaysia and Singapore for the haze, albeit caveated with a no-fault declaration.

I was seated immediately behind Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, who listened intently.

Prabowo spoke of Indonesia’s considerable efforts to contain the fires – to no avail – and the punitive measures taken against the culprits. His apology was more poignant for being made with the countries concerned at the same table. I am not sure whether he knows that the smoke reached all the way to the Philippines, too.

Asean is often judged by the problems it has yet to solve. The Code of Conduct for the South China Sea remains unfinished, and Myanmar is still at war.

Some expectations of Asean are unreasonable. Its members differ widely in history, political system and interests, and the association was built to manage those differences, not wish them away. That its members still meet and deal with the major powers together is itself an achievement.

A summit’s most useful work often happens away from the microphones and prepared statements.

Hence, for Malaysia, apart from the optics, the question is what the PM makes of the opportunities Asean provides.

There are the customary formal bilateral meetings in addition to the more casual pull-aside meets, and the even shorter exchanges on the fly as well as the business roundtables. It is in this arena of practical diplomacy that we separate the boys from the men.

The Summit sessions had their uses, too. On the haze, Malaysia proposed a Sustainable Haze Fund to give regional efforts steadier financing, together with closer scientific cooperation, so that governments work from common evidence.

Leaders also called for ratification of the agreement establishing an Asean coordinating centre for haze control. Malaysia will chair the relevant ministerial steering committee in 2027. The next dry season will be a more exacting judge of these efforts than any summit communiqué.

Energy came up throughout the discussions. The conflict around the Strait of Hormuz has exposed South-East Asia’s dependence on a narrow waterway far from its shores. At the leaders’ retreat, Anwar argued for revitalising the Asean Petroleum Security Agreement so that the region can respond better to disruptions, and urged members to buy energy from one another before looking further afield.

Food security presents a similar problem. Across South-East Asia, food production depends heavily on imported fertiliser, seeds and animal feed. Disruptions to these supplies could threaten future harvests and push up food prices.

There were opportunities beyond Asean, too. Canada’s Prime Minister Mark Carney was in Manila as Asean and Canada announced the substantial conclusion of negotiations on a free trade agreement. In a classic exchange on the fly, Carney urged Anwar to make more of the opportunities Canada now offers while dropping an invite to visit.

Myanmar was harder. Members differ on how best to influence events there. Anwar has argued for sustained engagement with Naypyitaw, including through his own recent contacts, on the grounds that Asean can achieve little without channels of communication. Other members worry that engagement could confer legitimacy without improving conditions on the ground.

In Manila, the leaders agreed to keep Myanmar’s representation at Asean summits and foreign ministers’ meetings non-political while leaving open the gradual restoration of full political representation if there is sustained and concrete progress under the Five-Point Consensus. They also encouraged individual members to engage all relevant stakeholders, in consultation with the Asean Chair.

This was a reasonable way of keeping engagement possible while holding to conditions. Whether it works depends heavily on events inside Myanmar, which Asean can influence only in part.

Asean's limitations are part of the reason it remains necessary. Without the association, each member would have to manage its disputes and dealings with the major powers largely alone. It is an arrangement born less of idealism than of a sensible appreciation of strategic geography.

That’s centrality in motion. That matters especially in relations with China and the United States. Both

are essential to South-East Asia’s economic future, though their interests do not always coincide with ours. Malaysia trades heavily with each and must also protect its security and freedom to decide for itself.

At the Asean-China Summit, Malaysia delivered two statements: the first on behalf of Asean, whose relations with Beijing it coordinates, and the second in its own name. The national statement welcomed the upgraded Asean-China Free Trade Agreement while insisting on balanced trade.

Growth in commerce, Malaysia argued, must not come at the expense of smaller enterprises. Collaboration in advancing digital transformation and innovation should be enhanced “particularly in forging the upward trajectory of artificial intelligence”, and in efforts to strengthen AI governance frameworks and regulatory guardrails.

The intervention also addressed the South China Sea, where Malaysia co-chairs the Code of Conduct negotiations with China, and called for renewed political will to conclude an agreement. Closer economic cooperation with Beijing and the defence of Malaysia’s maritime rights can be pursued together, provided difficulties in one area are not allowed to block progress in the other.

An independent foreign policy needs consistency, too. At the Asean-UN Summit, in stressing the imperative for multilateralism, Malaysia argued that a rules-based international order cannot endure under selective morality, and reiterated the call for Security Council reform, including abolition of the veto.

Its position on Palestine has been equally consistent. Principles are of little use if they change according to the company one keeps.

The summit made plain how much diplomacy now concerns matters that once seemed domestic. Electricity supply, food prices and the security of supply chains are increasingly shaped by decisions taken abroad. Malaysia cannot insulate itself from them, but it can work with others to reduce its vulnerabilities and widen its choices.

I have attended enough of these meetings to be wary of claiming too much for Asean. But I am just as tired of doubting Thomases who are hell-bent on denigrating Asean centrality as sheer nonsense.

Asean cannot settle every dispute or protect its members from every external shock. But it gives countries that often disagree a reason to keep working together and firmer ground for dealing with the wider world.

That is why I would judge Manila less by its declarations than by what follows. The financing discussions have to become projects, and opportunities identified with foreign partners must be pursued. What I saw was a Malaysian delegation attentive to these interests and conscious of the limits of diplomacy.

The real test will come afterwards, in the opportunities the PM has opened up for Malaysia and the benefits they bring to Malaysians.

DATUK PROF DR MOHD FAIZ ABDULLAH

Executive chairman

Institute of Strategic and International Studies, Malaysia

 

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In Letters

A hitherto account of managing stray dogs and why their numbers continue to grow
Time to consider adopting a ‘Living with floods’ mindset
Preparing workplaces for extreme weather conditions
Make Sustainable Haze Fund work on the ground
Asean Must Move Beyond Ceremonies to Meaningful Cooperation
What a small seller wants from Malaysia’s new e-commerce law
Gaza: A ceasefire is not peace
The Poch Project: Can Mauricio save United from themselves?
A home in every sense, except for stamp duty relief
Incomes are rising, but are Malaysians better off?

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read