A morally right decision

  • Letters
  • Thursday, 24 Jan 2019

THE Malaysian government’s decision not to allow Israelis to enter the country to participate in the World Para Swimming Champion­ships in Sarawak in July-August 2019 is both politically correct and morally right.

Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s firm stand on this issue has been endorsed by PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim and Deputy Sports Minister Sim Hee Kyung. A coalition of 29 NGOs has also voiced support for the decision.

That Malaysia has no diplomatic relations with Israel provides the political rationale for our stand. What this means in concrete terms is that Israelis cannot visit Malaysia just as Malaysians cannot visit Israel. This is an important dimension of our foreign policy. As a national policy, it supersedes internal arrangements on the immigration rights of a state within the Malaysian Federation.

If our decision on Israeli swimmers is politically viable, it is because it is anchored on a powerful moral ethos. In international law, Israel is an occupier that has annexed and usurped not only Palestinian land but also Syrian and Lebanese territories. If Malaysia recognised Israel, we would be bestowing legitimacy upon Israeli occupation and oppression.

Israeli occupation has become more severe since 1948, as reflected in its seizure of the West Bank and Gaza in 1967; tightening grip over East Jerusalem; and the construction of a wall that divides the West Bank and marginalises the Palestinian population.

Even more tragic is the continuous massacre of Palestinians and other Arabs in the course of the last 70 years through wars and brutal assaults. If they are not killed or executed, the victims of Israeli aggression are subjected to imprisonment and torture or simply humiliated through body searches at numerous check-points.

Indeed, what Israel has established in the West Bank and even within the country itself is an “apartheid state” that denies Palestinians their basic human dignity. It is against this backdrop that one should view the Malaysian decision to bar Israelis from entering our country.

There are thousands of individuals and organisations all over the world that are opposed to Israel’s intransigent arrogance. By boycotting Israel, many of them are hoping to compel it to obey international law.

This is the aim of the global “Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS)” movement which has grown and expanded over the last 15 years or so. Through the boycott of Israeli sports activities, musical concerts, academic programmes and Israeli goods produced especially in the West Bank, the BDS movement aims to isolate Israel and, as a result, create among Israelis the awareness about the imperative importance of forcing their government to recognise the legitimate rights of the Palestinian people.

It is significant that the BDS movement is totally committed to peaceful protest.

Academic organisations such as the American Studies Association (ASA) have joined the movement, as have churches in the United States, like the Presbyterian Church and the Methodist Church that have divested their investments in Israel. The Dutch pension fund PGGM is another entity that has divested its shares in companies operating in Israel.

Big European companies such as Veolia, Orange and CRH have also exited the Israeli market. As a result, there was a 46% drop in foreign direct investment (FDI) into Israel in 2014 compared to 2013.

Even cities, such as Dublin in Ireland and Leicester in Britain, are part of the BDS movement. Among prominent individuals associated with BDS is the indefatigable Desmond Tutu who sees parallels between what is happening in Israel-Palestine today and apartheid South Africa in the past.

It is within the context of the BDS movement that we should view our own boycott of Israeli swimmers. We are strengthening the most promising movement alive today for the liberation of the Palestinian people.

It is a movement that has drawn people from diverse religious and cultural backgrounds to commit to a common cause – a cause which Nelson Mandela once described as the greatest moral issue of our time.

By saying “no” to the Israeli swimmers, as others have said “no” to other Israeli athletes in other fields, we are continuing to champion a struggle that we have been devoted to for a long time. Criticisms from various quarters, even economic and political moves against Malaysia as a nation, should not deter us. Let us remind ourselves that we are not alone in this noble quest for justice.



International Movement for a Just World

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Join our Telegram channel to get our Evening Alerts and breaking news highlights

Next In Letters

Carbon farming and palm oil
Business events sector crucial
Let’s not cry over spilled milk
Some consideration for senior citizens
Committing to net zero carbon emissions
Five principles for bribery prevention
Respect gender diversity and human rights
Positive consumer behaviour learnt during pandemic
Focus on working together
Caught in a difficult situation

Stories You'll Enjoy