Extreme cost of road projects

Hikers starting off their hike up Bukit Saga. Many are objecting to the degazettement of the Sungai Puteh Forest Reserve in Ampang for the Sungai Besi-Ulu Klang Expressway (SUKE) project.

THE Selangor state government’s tenacity in degazetting and destroying forest reserves for tolled highway projects is an outrage to the principles of integrity, transparency and environmental responsibility it promised to uphold during the last general election.

The East Klang Valley Expressway (EKVE) would brutalise the Ulu Gombak and Ampang forests, fragmenting wildlife habitats and destroying vital watershed areas.

Now the proposed Sungai Besi–Ulu Klang Elevated Expressway (SUKE) would bisect and destroy more green lungs, including Bukit Saga (pic), a nature spot beloved by hikers and campers, while the proposed Damansara-Shah Alam Highway (DASH) would cut through the Bukit Cherakah and Sungai Buloh forest reserves.

The plans for these highway projects are seen to have been pushed through with alarming haste, without giving citizen action groups and residents sufficient notice or opportunity to provide their feedback on them. It has been reported that the SUKE and DASH projects were not even formally listed in the local planning documents as required by the Town and Country Planning Act 1976. As such, the said plans should have been rejected from the start.

The destruction of these vital forest reserves in an already overdeveloped state will result in more dry spells and poorer water and air quality for Selangor residents. Constructing roads through previously forested areas would increase wildlife mortality, provide access to loggers, poachers and hunters, and increase soil, water, air, noise and light pollution in ecologically-sensitive areas. Residents in areas near highways would not only suffer adverse health effects, but would also be deprived of recreational areas and the opportunity to connect with nature.

As the rest of the world is making its best efforts to mitigate the impact of climate change, the proponents of these highway projects appear to be quite happy to increase carbon emission and damage to the natural areas while paying lip service to the ideas of environmental protection and community engagement. No amount of tree-planting and environmental awareness campaigns can compensate for the loss of vital forest reserves, some of which are centuries old.

There is insufficient evidence that highway construction can divert traffic away from congested areas and improve traffic flow. Any road user in Malaysia can attest to the fact that traffic congestion can occur on highways as well as trunk roads and residential areas. If anything, highway projects encourage greater private vehicle ownership and put more vehicles on our roads.

Traffic volume will simply rise along with the number of roads if there are no feasible alternatives to driving.

The solution to traffic problems is not to increase the number of highways but to create solid, functional alternatives to driving and private vehicle ownership. A reliable and extensive public transport system (especially a bus service using existing road systems) and increased road safety will benefit human populations and reduce harm to the environment, cost less and take less time to implement than the construction of more highways.

Governments need to be responsive to the changing transportation needs of their citizens. Higher urban costs of living mean that fewer people will be able to afford private vehicles. A younger and more educated urban population will also mean greater concern for the environment and more interest in cycling, telecommuting, ride-sharing, working from home and flexible work hours.

Malaysia has the infrastructure and resources to create an efficient and practical public transport system, but we need to improve our service and maintenance culture. We need leaders with the political will to reduce environmental damage and stop wasting public funds on unnecessary highway projects.

If these highway projects are allowed to proceed despite the strong objections of citizens, we, the people, will have to bear the economic and environmental cost.



Green Living Special Interest Group

Malaysian Nature Society

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 46
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Join our Telegram channel to get our Evening Alerts and breaking news highlights

Next In Letters

Stop the politics of neglecting people’s welfare
Logbook must also be provided
On the road to recovery
Calling on all MPs to work together
Community route to herd immunity
MPs must not take people’s health and safety for granted
Drop charges against Heidy Quah for exposing horrible conditions at immigration detention centres
Rude awakening as politicians showed their true colours
Move the date to save our world
Protecting our supply chains

Stories You'll Enjoy