Debate erupts over op


  • AseanPlus News
  • Thursday, 10 Jul 2003

The twins - File picture - EPApic

SINGAPORE: Prayers were held yesterday for conjoined Iranian twins who died after a marathon separation operation as a debate erupted over whether the pioneering surgery should have even been attempted. 

The 29-year-old sisters, Ladan and Laleh Bijani, had made it clear they were willing to risk death in high-risk surgery for a chance to pursue separate dreams and live out their lives in different cities. 

“They gambled and have lost,” was the verdict of Singapore's Straits Times newspaper, which nevertheless noted the unprecedented procedure was “history in the making”. 

Iranians in the city state were in a sombre mood as they gathered to hold prayers for the two women at a private home. 

“I think the doctors have an obligation to fulfil the wishes of their patients,” said Ali Homayouni, 25, an Iranian law student who had visited the twins in the hospital. 

“It was their duty to make sure they do the best job they could given the circumstances,” he said. 

The twins' skulls joined before operation - File picture - EPApic

But medical experts were more critical, concerned about the haste and motives behind the surgery. 

“There are troubling aspects about this case,” Dr Ian Kerridge, Associate Professor in bioethics at Sydney University's Centre for Values, Ethics and the Law in Medicine said. “...and one of them was the statement by one of the surgeons that they found it was more difficult than they had expected. To me that sets off a little bit of an alarm bell.” 

Kerridge suggested doctors could have let the girls wait for a year, talk to people who have not had the surgery or to people who felt it was wrong. 

Twins joined at the head occur once in every two million live births. A separation operation had never been tried on adults. 

Dr Keith Goh, who led the team of 28 specialists and 100 assistants in the 52-hour long operation, defended the decision. 

“I think that for those of us who were here over these last three days, for those of us who flew in from all over the world ... the time and commitment is a convincing indication of their belief that the decision is correct,” Goh told a news conference. 

The twins walking - File picture - EPApic

Ben Carson, director of paediatric neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore who flew in for the operation said the operation was worth it “even recognising that the odds were not good. I think it was a worthy humanitarian effort.” 

But a neurosurgeon in Germany who declined to separate the twins when they were 14 said on Tuesday he was stunned the operation had even been attempted. 

Madjid Samii, president of the International Neuroscience Institute in Hanover, said he had reluctantly turned down the twins' request after a month of examinations in 1988 showed the shared vein, which drained blood from their brains to their hearts, meant chances of survival were almost nil. 

Australian medical ethicist Nic Tonti-Filippini said consent of the patients was not enough reason to go ahead with surgery. 

“The profession actually has to be satisfied that it's a safe enough procedure,” he said.  

But among ordinary people, the view was more sanguine. 

“It is the destiny of the twins,” said Javad Najafi, 39, an Iranian living in Singapore. 

An Iranian diplomat said the twins' bodies were to be returned to Iran on a flight leaving Singapore today.  

The Straits Times in its editorial saw a silver lining in the cloud of tragedy. 

“It is not the done thing to talk about boosterism when patients have died. But wrung of its emotion in what was literally a clinical job, Singapore will gain in international renown for its medical advances when the verdicts of professional peers are in.” – Reuters 

For another perspective from The Straits Times, a partner of Asia News Network, click here.

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
   

Did you find this article insightful?

Yes
No

Across the site