PUTRAJAYA (Bernama): Carpet Raya Sdn Bhd director J. R. Deepak Jaikishan and two others on Monday (Sept 20) failed to reinstate their suit against former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak, his wife Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor, and Baling MP Datuk Seri Abdul Azeez Abdul Rahim over taxes incurred for allegedly acting as proxies for the couple.
This was after the Court of Appeal dismissed their appeal to quash the High Court's decision in allowing an application by Najib, Rosmah and Abdul Azeez to strike out the suit.
Justice Datuk Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah, who led a three-man bench in a unanimous decision, said the suit brought by Deepak, Carpet Raya and Deepak’s younger brother J. Rajesh, who is also the director of the company, was obviously unsustainable and bound to fail if it was to proceed for trial.
"We find that the High Court judicial commissioner is correct in finding that the suit was a plain and obvious case for striking out. Hence, we find no merit in the appeal and the appeal is hereby dismissed with costs RM10,000 for Najib and Rosmah and RM10,000 for Abdul Azeez,” Justice Mohamad Zabidin said.
The other two judges were Datuk Azizah Nawawi and Datuk S. Nantha Balan.
The panel made the ruling after hearing submissions from counsel Daniel Annamalai, representing the appellants, David Mathews, who appeared for Najib and Rosmah, and Datuk Prem Ramchandran for Abdul Azeez.
On July 16 last year, the Kuala Lumpur High Court allowed an application by Najib, Rosmah and Abdul Azeez to strike out the suit after finding that the statement of claim did not disclose a reasonable cause of action as the essential elements to sustain the claims for conspiracy to injure, misfeasance in public office and breach of duty of care.
The trio had filed the application on Sept 24, 2019, on grounds that the suit was vexatious and the plaintiffs had no cause to sue them.
In the suit filed on Nov 15, 2018, Deepak claimed that between 2004 and 2010, he and the company had acted as an agent and proxy to Najib and Rosmah in land transactions and business deals as instructed by the couple.
He also claimed that Abdul Azeez had acted as an agent for Najib and Rosmah to carry out the transactions and acted as the intermediary between the couple and Carpet Raya.
Deepak claimed that as a result of the transactions, he received a letter from the Inland Revenue Board (LHDN), dated March 2, 2018, to settle the arrears in taxes owed by Carpet Raya and his income tax, totalling more than RM6mil, excluding penalty charges and interests.
Deepak claimed that he received the letter from LHDN after his relations with the couple soured in 2012 following his refusal to follow their instructions in a civil case involving private investigator P. Balasubramaniam, claiming that Abdul Azeez had knowledge of the matter.
They contended that Najib and Rosmah also ordered legal action to be taken by LHDN against Carpet Raya and a winding-up petition was filed against the company on March 22, 2017, by LHDN and the petition was published in newspapers.
They claimed that as a result of the petition, the business and reputation of all the plaintiffs were affected and Deepak was also banned from leaving the country, while their business facilities were withdrawn by Maybank and the company's contract with Ikea was cancelled.
They are seeking a court declaration that Najib and Rosmah are responsible for paying the tax arrears owed by the company and seeking damages of RM500,000 which was paid to Maybank, RM47mil for the company's inability to fulfil its contract and sales, RM74mil for cancellation of the company's contract with Ikea, RM200mil for alleged defamation and RM37mil in losses caused by Najib’s alleged misconduct.
They are also seeking RM100mil in aggravated and exemplary damages.- Bernama