Read it as a whole, says law expert


  • Nation
  • Saturday, 10 Dec 2016

PETALING JAYA: The use of the word “parent” in the Federal Constitution makes it appear as if the consent of just a mother or father is required to convert a minor to Islam.

Does that mean the amendment by Perlis to allow just one parent to unilaterally convert their child to Islam really is in line with the supreme law of Malaysia?

Definitely not, argues constitutional law expert Prof Datuk Dr Shad Saleem Faruqi.

Shad, who is Emeritus Professor of Law at UiTM, said Article 12(4) of the Constitution states that the religion of a person under the age of 18 for the purposes of education will be determined by his parent or guardian.

“It doesn’t say ‘parents’ or ‘guardians’ but anyone who knows the law will know that in legal drafting we normally use the singular,” he explained.

Citing an example, Shad said Article 5 says that “no person” shall be deprived of his life or liberty.

“It doesn’t say, ‘all persons’ but that does not mean anyone is excluded.

“We normally use singular and masculine when drafting laws, so we have to look at what we call interpretation clauses.”

Shad noted that Clause 2(95) of the Eleventh Schedule in the Constitution states very clearly that, “words in the singular include the plural and words in the plural include the singular”.

“When Article 12(4) and Schedule 11 are read together, the conclusion drawn by many people that parent means one and guardian is singular is not correct.” (see table below)

Shad said the Constitution has to be read as a whole, and in this issue, there is also the question of equality between a mother and father, which is mentioned in Article 8.

He said it was not right to say that one parent has more say over the other in matters of the religion of the child.

“It is only sensible, reading Article 12(4), Schedule 11 and Article 8, that both parents should have equal rights.

“Given what the Constitution says, some state enactments are clashing with the Constitution. Not just Perlis, but a number of other states,” said Shad.

He said that in cases where there was a conflict between a federal law and a state law, Article 75 of the Constitution says the federal law prevails.

“This is subject to the issue of whether the federal law was within jurisdiction and the state law was within jurisdiction, in other words were they passing a law on a matter within their competence?”

On Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said’s statement that the proposed amendment to the Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce) Act 1976 (LRA) may require a constitutional amendment to Article 12(4) to substitute the word “parent” with “parents”, Shad said that would require two-thirds support.

He said at least 148 Members of Parliament (two-thirds of the 222 MPs) must vote in favour of the constitutional amendment for it.

“Surely on an issue like this, if the Government wishes to support they should be able to muster two-thirds.”

On whether a newly-converted Muslim parent can take his or her child from a civil marriage to Perlis or other states with similar provisions in order to unilaterally convert their child to Islam, Shad believes they could.

Citing polygamy as an example, he said a Muslim man who would need permission from his wife to marry another woman under his own state’s law need only to “hop over” to another state, where such permission is not required.

“All laws will have loopholes because life is always larger than the law.

“This is where legislative amendments will have to keep up with all these problems that keep coming up now and then,” he said.



Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3

Religion , Shad Saleem Faruqi

   

Did you find this article insightful?

Yes
No

Next In Nation

Covid-19: Malaysians keen on mass vaccination to stem pandemic spread
Wisma Putra: Hisham to make three-day official visit to Brunei
Bus ferrying Covid-19 patients involved in accident in Serdang, six lightly injured
Covid-19: Introduce three-tier system for SOP violators instead of RM10k fines for all, says Lee Lam Thye
MCA launches memorial website on founding president Tun Sir Tan Cheng Lock
Be reasonable when imposing compounds on SOP violators, says Bersatu youth wing
Johor hopes to kick off Covid-19 immunisation programme on March 1, says state Health Committee chairman
Firemen continue to battle blaze at Ampang Jajar waste disposal site
Cargo train slips off track, blocking two railway tracks at Batu Tiga KTM station
Two men nabbed following viral traffic incident remanded four days

Stories You'll Enjoy


Vouchers