PETALING JAYA: The Federal Constitution does not expressly bind the Yang di-Pertuan Agong to the Pardons Board’s advice, unlike state Rulers and Governors, say two senior lawyers.
Senior lawyer Kitson Foong said the Constitution specifically requires state Rulers and Governors to act on their Pardons Boards’ advice but does not use similar wording in relation to the King.
“Article 42(1) gives the power to pardon to the King. Not to the Pardons Board. The Board advises. The King decides. The minister answers for it.
“For the Rulers and Governors, Article 42(4)(b) says the power ‘shall be exercised on the advice of a Pardons Board’. For the King, those words are missing,” he said.
He added that Article 42 did not specify any voting requirements for the Board to formulate its advice.
Foong acknowledged the opposing view that Article 40(1A) requires the King to accept advice, a position upheld by the Federal Court in Najib’s addendum case last year.
However, he argued that the addendum never went before the Pardons Board.
“So what the courts held is that the King cannot decide outside the Board. Not that the King must decide as the Board says.
“The courts have touched on it. They have not decided it,” he said.
Lawyer Mohamed Haniff Khatri Abdulla said the King was not required to obtain the agreement of all five board members, or even a majority, before exercising his powers.
He said the King only hears their views but is not bound by them, adding that even if all five disagreed, the King’s wisdom cannot be disputed.
He added that the King had sought the board members’ views despite not being obliged to do so.
Meanwhile, minutes of the Sept 18 Pardons Board meeting, which were circulated on social media on Wednesday, showed that Attorney General Tan Sri Mohd Dusuki Mokhtar and Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh had objected to allowing Najib to serve the remainder of his SRC International case prison sentence under house arrest.
The King, who granted Najib’s house arrest until Aug 23, 2028, had decided who would sign the pardon order.
According to the minutes, Yeoh cited Section 14 of the Delegation of Powers Act 1956 in proposing that another officer, such as the Chief Secretary to the Government, sign the order.
Foong said Section 14 provided a legal basis for her proposal, as the Chief Secretary is also the Secretary to the Cabinet. However, he said the King was right to direct Yeoh to sign the order.
“A minister signs for the King because the King doesn’t answer in Parliament. A minister does. A civil servant, however senior, doesn’t,” he said.
He added that Yeoh’s signature “carries His Majesty’s command, not her own view”.
Haniff said the minutes appeared to have been released to highlight Yeoh’s disagreement with the pardon.
“The power of pardon is the absolute prerogative of the King. Whether the government agrees or not, whether it objects or not, is irrelevant,” he said.
