China responds to criticism at WTO over trade policies

BEIJING (The Straits Times/Asia News Network): China has pushed back at criticism levelled during last week's World Trade Organisation (WTO) trade policy review, saying many of the points raised were beyond the ambit of the organisation's trade rules and were "unreasonable, unfair and unacceptable".

Over two sessions last week, fellow WTO members including Australia, Canada, Japan and the United States took the floor to air their grievances against China's trade practices. Among other things, they referred to preferential treatment for state-owned firms, coercive trade practices and not following through on commitments.

During a press briefing in Beijing on Thursday (Oct 28), Vice-Minister for Commerce Wang Shouwen said China's state-owned entities operate like any other company that has "independent operations in accordance with the provisions of the (Chinese) Constitution".

According to a report written independently by the WTO secretariat for the review, China's state trading firms have the exclusive right to import or export 12 products, including wheat, rice and crude and processed oil.

"State ownership remains very important in China's economy, even in non-strategic, commercially oriented sectors, with state-owned enterprises (SOEs) still having large market shares," the report said.

Wang added that the country has also opened up its market more to foreign investment, independent of WTO requirements, although there are still restrictions on where foreign entities can invest, a common practice in many other countries.

"We understand the desire of some countries that China should further relax investment access.

"However, criticising China in this way and saying that China has not fulfilled WTO regulations... is unreasonable, unfair, and unacceptable," he said in response to a question from The Straits Times.

"China is willing to deal with this issue through free trade agreements and bilateral investment agreements," he said, citing its recent application to join the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP).

China's membership is dependent on unanimous agreement by all 11 CPTPP members and it is noteworthy that tensions currently exist between Beijing and at least three of them - Australia, Canada and Japan.

Addressing the issues raised by its major trading partners at last week's trade policy review, Wang said China took their concerns seriously but did not accept criticism on issues that fell outside the scope of WTO commitments.

China also called for the removal of farm subsidies in some developed countries, saying that they were "unfair rules that disrupt international trade".

During last week's policy review, the US said China's industrial policies skewed the playing field against imported goods and services.

When China acceded to the WTO 20 years ago, there was expectation that the country would reform its internal systems and move towards more open, market-oriented policies, said David Bisbee, the charge d'affaires at the US mission in Geneva.

"Instead, China has used the imprimatur of WTO membership to become the WTO's largest trader, while doubling down on its state-led, non-market approach to trade, to the detriment of workers and businesses in the United States and other countries," he added.

Sixty-five WTO members took the floor during the review to give their comments on China's trade policy, including major trading partners Australia, Britain, Canada and the European Union. All four also called on the world's second-largest economy to further open its market.

The review usually occurs once every four years but bigger WTO members like China have to undergo them every two years.

Notably, China has faced more criticism this time around, as it is mired in trade disputes with several member states.

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 46
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Join our Telegram channel to get our Evening Alerts and breaking news highlights

China , WTO , trade , policies


Next In Aseanplus News

Asean News Headlines at 10pm on Monday (Nov 29)
747 new Covid-19 cases in Singapore on Monday (Nov 29); daily tally under 1,000 for first time since Sept 20
Thailand rejoice as its new Covid-19 cases hit five-month low; Bangkok eateries can serve booze until 11pm from Dec 1
Indonesia reports only 176 newly-confirmed Covid-19 cases and 11 more deaths on Monday (Nov 29)
Record number of cases in Hanoi on Monday (Nov 29) as Vietnam reports 13,770 new Covid-19 cases, 1,224,110 in total
Philippines logs a lowly 665 new Covid-19 cases on Monday (Nov 29); country records less than 1,000 daily cases for six straight days
Indonesia bans arrivals from eight African countries due to Omicron variant (update)
South-East Asia IPOs outperform to hit US$9.8bil as of mid-November, says Deloitte
Philippines launches mass vaccination drive on spectre of Omicron
Omicron variant: Thailand considers rescinding plans to use Rapid Antigen Tests

Others Also Read