Control Resonant lives within the aftermath of tragedy. It takes place seven years after the events of the previous game, when a mysterious alien entity wrought havoc in the halls of the Federal Bureau of Control, a fictional organisation dedicated to the study of unexplained phenomena.
Resonant’s main character, Dylan Faden, is the man responsible for that event, as he is constantly reminded by the FBC soldiers and scientists he comes across. He spent most of his childhood confined in the bureau, studied because of his supernatural abilities. Through found notes and audio recordings, Resonant tells a grim story of an orphaned boy – also separated from his sister – who was poked, prodded and brutalised in the name of scientific advancement before exploding.
Dylan gets to leave that tragedy partly behind in Resonant. He has escaped, along with the alien contagion, onto the streets of midtown Manhattan in New York City, unrecognisably bifurcated by another entity. No longer trapped in his cell, Dylan can finally speak for himself.
When Dylan speaks out loud, whether in cut scenes or over the radio with his sarcastic handler, he comes off as profoundly awkward. His eyes dart around, he emphasises the wrong words, his delivery is halting. Any pretenses at suave video game heroics fail whenever Dylan must stammer out responses to lost researchers and disgruntled guards, or when he lets silences extend for awkward lengths of time. He spent his life trapped inside, so it’s no wonder he is utterly unprepared to socialise with others.
Dylan’s actions speak much more boldly. When leaping between skyscrapers or using his powers to dispatch strangely mutated monsters, there is no hesitation – only thrilled shouts and gleeful, throaty grunts of exertion as he slashes away with his glowing scythe or pancakes foes with his giant hammer. Tangible in Dylan’s explosive energy is a sheer joy at being able to navigate so freely.
This is the game’s tension and its central split. (It’s fitting that the space where Dylan levels up is called the “gap”.) Textually speaking, our character is a reluctant hero, guilt-ridden and ashamed of his past. There are occasional missions where Dylan is able to contact his sister, Jesse, who has disappeared since the events of the first game. One memorable encounter relives their troubled childhood through an evocative combination of interactive wall projections and platforming.
The tone of these quieter moments may feel weighty, but when Dylan is crushing skulls and leaping along vertiginous avenues, things lighten up considerably. He’s free now, and he’s going to enjoy that freedom.
Resonant leans into his joy. Navigating these spaces, whose bizarre spatial arrangements could exist only in a video game, is a legitimate pleasure. Resonant’s Manhattan is a stunning and mind-bending distortion of 3D space. City blocks stop suddenly in endless chasms, and rooftops brush up against the water towers of inverted buildings hanging from the sky. Holes in the ground descend into hollow caverns made up of high-rise cross-sections.
There is a light and experimental approach to the interactivity in Resonant. The boss fights feel less like reflex challenges than visual spectacles that play with space and performance. One is a dancer who spends most of the fight ignoring you and going through her routines for an invisible audience. At the bottom of a steaming factory, a tortured giant moans, struck through with giant pipes. Elsewhere you fight a fungal growth in an impossibly large chasm, running and leaping from walls to floors to ceilings until you can’t tell which way is up.
Resonant’s world feels dreamlike and impossible as it wraps itself around you, as you fling yourself from surface to surface, into battles and encounters with wild abandon and grinning delight.
The first game spent far too much time explaining exactly how its world was uncanny and weird. It had reams of diary entries, research notes and videos, all meant to instruct players to feel awestruck by the mysterious unknowability of the FBC. Playing the game meant plodding through midcentury office chambers, blasting away at angry red scarecrows with guns and whatever office furniture was handy. The awe never arrived; it never rose above the level of the text.
In Resonant, the world does the talking. I feel awe as I stand on the side of an office building, looking out at a city block spiraling kaleidoscopically away into an impossibly twisted horizon.
But the game’s narrative layer, again infused in science-fiction tropes, feels small and far away as I hurtle into that urban chasm. The context is kept at a distance. Monsters and humans alike fizz out and disappear when they die, like remnants of a dream fading into ether. Tables, chairs and radios are flung up in the air as Dylan rushes past.
The game’s narrative hits a similarly light and inconsequential tone. Bureaucrats argue about company protocol. Nerdy scientists geek out over objectively terrifying things. Characters are thin and functional, never feeling quite like they deserve the gravitas lent by their voice actors. Occasionally, Resonant sits you in a corner and talks at you about serious things. Certain missions bring Dylan indoors to learn more about his past and to face his demons. In these moments the game is most like its predecessor. Audiences are told how to feel: Dylan is sad, Dylan is tortured, just like it says in Research Note No. 4.
Games are agentic experiences that work better when feelings are embodied in your actions. Dylan’s interiority ought to exist beyond cut scenes and flashbacks with stiff, unnatural performances. More compelling is learning about Dylan while launching through the air at snarling enemies with the heavy yet weightless feeling of the transforming supernatural weaponry in his hands.
Dylan’s plotline asks whether he can overcome his past, and whether he can control his violent rage. But when we command Dylan, that question doesn’t matter. His actions are frictionless and his weapons can never harm his allies. Whenever he gets close enough to someone to hurt them, the game’s interactivity disappears. Pivotal moments exploring Dylan’s character happen within the sterile safety of the cut scene.
Resonant works best when it lets us experience freedom through Dylan’s eyes. But when control is given to the player, it is only ever for the purpose of violence: Dylan is released to destroy the FBC’s enemies. He may have left his cell, but it remains unclear whether he has truly escaped. – ©2026 The New York Times Company
(Control Resonant was reviewed on the PlayStation 5. It will also be available on the PC and Xbox Series X|S.)
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
