Human minds are 'unprepared' for self-driving cars, expert warns


Self-driving cars suggest a more relaxed trip for passengers. And yet they threaten to turn us into something far more challenging: supervisory controllers, one expert is warning. — Photo: Marijan Murat/dpa

LONDON: Self-driving vehicles and people are dangerously out of sync, according to an engineer, who warns in a new book that the technology imposes "a strange new role" that human thought processes "weren't designed for."

According to Ronald McLeod, author of "Transitioning to Autonomy – The Psychology of Human Supervisory Control", autonomous cars "place unprecedented psychological demands on drivers – demands we are currently drastically unprepared for."

Far from being the hands-free, hands-off and safety-guaranteed panacea they are sometimes portrayed as, so-called self-driving cars require people to maintain focus in case they need to take over "at a moment’s notice" if the technology fails or proves unable to handle a complex and potentially dangerous road scenario.

"When autonomous features engage, drivers do not simply become passengers – they become something far more challenging: supervisory controllers. Instead of actively steering and accelerating, they must monitor the system’s ongoing performance and stand ready to intervene," the author explained.

But that is a major concern, according to McLeod, honorary professor at Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, who described people as "incapable of consciously paying continuous attention for more than relatively short periods."

"The cognitive load is actually higher than manual driving in many ways," McLeod warned, as whoever sits at the self-driving wheel has to maintain "a mental model of what the car is currently doing and is capable of doing and its limits, assess whether the car is aware of hazards the driver can see."

At the same time, the erstwhile driver needs to be alert enough to "make split-second decisions about when to intervene" despite having had "minimal direct engagement with the physical driving task," McLeod said.

The type of hands-off but constantly alert supervisory role required of whoever sits behind the wheel of an autonomous car entails a "fundamental shift in thinking that most of us would not recognise," according to publisher Taylor & Francis. – dpa

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In Tech News

Lucid unveils steering wheel-free robotaxi concept, taking aim at Tesla's Cybercab
US appeals court throws out injunction against California law on children's online safety
Microsoft's Rajesh Jha, head of experiences and devices unit, to retire
Ukraine opens battlefield data access to allies' AI models
SoftBank-backed PayPay shares set to open 38% above IPO price
Exclusive-Italian prosecutors seek trial for Amazon, four execs over alleged $1.4 billion tax evasion
Pentagon CTO says 'no chance' of renewed Anthropic negotiations
Bumble shares surge as investors swipe right on AI-powered reboot
US insurers and hospitals turn to new AI for age-old battle over charges vs payments
Google names London office 'Platform 37' in a nod to railway neighbour, AI 'Go' match

Others Also Read