China’s belief that every country should choose its own Internet “governance model” was reasserted at its leading cyber conference on Wednesday by the country’s propaganda chief, who said it would fight “all forms of hegemony” in cyberspace administration.
Huang Kunming argued that every country should be entitled to participate equally in international cyberspace management, in his keynote speech at the opening of the World Internet Conference in the misty river town of Wuzhen in eastern China.
The annual event – traditionally a high-profile platform for China’s narrative on internet governance – began in unusually low-key fashion against a backdrop of the prolonged trade war with the United States and increasing international wariness of the spreading “China model” of Internet control.
“We should adhere to the principle of respecting cyber sovereignty, respecting every individual country’s right to choose its own development path for cyberspace, model of cyber governance and internet public policy,” said Huang, in charge of media and public information in China – which still blocks Google, Facebook and Twitter.
Chinese President Xi Jinping, who had pushed the idea of cyberspace sovereignty at the same event in 2015, sent a letter to the conference, read out by Huang before his speech.
Xi wrote in the letter that the world should seek “mutual trust and collective governance” of the Internet based on the shared goals of developing “digital economy” and addressing cyberspace threats.
China’s vision of an Internet centred on sovereignty and control contrasts with the open, free Internet advocated widely elsewhere, although there are shared interests in specific issues such as security and e-commerce. Beijing and Washington held their first cybersecurity dialogue in October 2017.
This year’s edition of the Internet conference, which also showcases China’s use of the Internet to serve economic growth and life improvement, was the first not to be attended by any of the Communist Party’s supreme Politburo Standing Committee – an apparent downgrading of the event in the tea leaf reading of Chinese politics.
It is overshadowed by the ongoing inaugural China International Import Expo in Shanghai, one of Beijing’s top events of the year and attended by Xi and other top leaders including Vice-Premier Hu Chunhua.
Since 2014’s first internet conference, a member of the seven-member committee had always been present to give the keynote speech in a symbolic show of support for the event and its importance.
It was the Premier, Li Keqiang, in 2014, followed by Xi a year later. In 2016, the then ideology tsar Liu Yunshan was there, with Xi sending a video message. And last year, Liu’s successor as ideology guru, Wang Huning, read out a letter from Xi.
Huang addressed the topic of “creating a digital world for mutual trust and collective governance”.
In addition, while the three-day forum beginning on Wednesday is still the biggest annual gathering for a who's who of China's Google, Facebook, Microsoft and Amazon sent their vice-presidents or regional heads, and only Harry Shum from Microsoft was expected to give a speech at a conference session, according to the official schedule of the conference.
The lower ranking of attending Chinese officials may be designed to reflect the light presence of top foreign tech chiefs, said Severine Arsene, managing editor of the digital journal AsiaGlobal Online, published by the University of Hong Kong’s Asia Global Institute.
“Given the fact that fewer top executives from abroad are coming, putting a higher-ranking leader before them would be a loss of face,” she said, adding: “Meanwhile, the choice of the head of the propaganda department shows where the priority is.”
Ryan Hass, a China expert at the Brookings Institution, who attended the Internet conference last year, said the Chinese leadership might want to keep the international focus on the import expo in Shanghai, and not divide attention between it and Wuzhen.
But the relative drop in enthusiasm from major Western tech executives could also be due to their “commitment fatigue”, after receiving repeated Chinese pledges of progress on liberalisation that have not yet materialised.
“There could be growing wariness by chief executives of major multinational firms about the direction of China’s tech policies towards tightening and control,” said Hass, who directed China policy for the US National Security Council during the Barack Obama administration.
The conference comes with China having been ranked bottom for Internet freedom by Freedom House for the fourth year in a row.
The US-based web watchdog said in its latest report this month that China’s restrictive Internet policies were being actively exported around the world, and warned that China’s “digital authoritarianism” could threaten democracies in other countries. — South China Morning Post