Envy, the root of much pain

  • Letters
  • Tuesday, 30 Apr 2019

I WILL look at the notion of “Malay envy” from three perspectives:

> The envy people of other communities feel towards Malays;

> The envy Malays feel towards the other communities;

> Malay envy within their own community.

Of the three categories I have identified, the third has a longer socio-cultural existence. I will discuss the notions in reverse order from three to one.

In the pre-Merdeka era and going further back into the pattern of Malay village life, rural or kampung Malays were bound by a close-knit family and community existence. They were bonded by strong kinship relations where groups of families lived side by side in clusters of kampung communities where every part of their daily life was intertwined -- from economic activities to socio-cultural practices to neighbourly interactions to kinship and family relations.

Because of this intimacy, everyone knew everyone else, so much so there arose not only good cross-connectivity -- as in silaturrahim or goodwill -- but also bad cross-vibrations -- as in rivalry stemming from the feeling of cemburu or envy. There arose the habit of jaga tepi kain orang or nosing around other people’s affairs. The minding of one’s own business characteristic of individualistic urban living was not a socio-cultural phenomenon in a community that closely guarded the interests of its members.

Kampung life was replete with the cemburu mentality of individuals, families and neighbours in visible competition to display their material acquisitions by, for instance, changing house curtains and cushions every Hari Raya or wearing prominent pieces of gold jewellery. This bersinggit-singgit or competitive habit, extended to other areas of social life such as weddings and exchanging gifts, or hantaran. The more trays of gifts, the greater the family pride. Great pride in the educational, career and business achievements of family members could also turn to boasting about them.

Close-knit communities exist everywhere in history, and even today groups of people living together in a small physical space would be more inward than outward looking, getting sustenance from one another’s contributions while closely assessing them. Outstanding contributions inspire imitation in others and oftentimes, envy.

Today, rural urban migration which started in the 1960s has turned many Malays into sophisticated urbanites living in comfort and luxury -- but the envy mentality has remained a part of the Malay psyche. Modern Malay communities still carry with them the customs and habits of old as they nose around one another’s family and kampung backgrounds.

Having to coexist with the early immigrant communities, viz Arabs, Indians and Chinese who, from the start, had an economic edge over them has given rise to different attitudes in the indigenous Malays towards these communities.Generally, there was acceptance and even admiration for success especially of the Chinese in business and industry, but soon there grew an uneasiness that the Malay slice of the country’s economic cake was too small.

In the town areas, Malays who went to school with their non-Malay peers shared an amicable social relationship, but still, there was a tinge of envy that the families of their Chinese friends were successful business people. Many Indians were successful teachers, lawyers and doctors who spoke excellent English, and the Malays envied their professional achievements.

Envy of the success of others has a way of turning itself around into positive action, as it did with the community of town Malays in Penang categorised by the British as Jawi Pekan from the late 19th century and later as Jawi Peranakan (from my book, Images Of The Jawi Peranakan Of Penang, 2004). Ethnically, they were of Indian Muslim and Malay ancestry and their early success in business can clearly be seen as a test case for Malay resilience to debunk the myth of the lazy Malays.

When the Malays are in a fair competition and on a level playing field with the other communities, and where they are accepted as equal partners, everyone prospers as they did in old George Town. Even today, Malays from Penang display a more confident attitude and hold respected positions in the public and private sectors.

One cannot deny that the vast majority of Malays were late arrivals in all sectors of the economy except agriculture. Schooled in the smaller towns and kampung, the children of fishermen, farmers, rubber tappers, craftsmen, clerks and schoolteachers went through English, Malay and religious education, managing to be better educated than their parents.

Many broke atap ceilings and moved out of their rumah kampung to live in concrete flats, terrace houses and bungalows. They were becoming authentic urban Malays alongside the Chinese and Indians.

Still, they were envied because their successes were thought to be artificially heaped with props in the affirmative action programmes carefully crafted by the post-independence government. In the 1970s, the New Economic Policy and its implementation became the focus of green-eyed communities who saw it as biased and unfair. The Malays had become the favoured community and the other communities felt themselves sidelined in the development of the country.

Unhealthy inter-ethnic envy persists till today, giving rise to all kinds of negative developments that do not augur well for a country which prides itself on being a harmonious, multiethnic society.

What we urgently need from the Pakatan Harapan government is a freshly crafted affirmative action policy with new definitions, categorisations, roadmaps and action plans where every community is given honourable mention and direction. With this, Malay envy in all senses will be a thing of the past.



Association of Voices of Peace, Conscience and Reason

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Subscribe now to our Premium Plan for an ad-free and unlimited reading experience!

Next In Letters

IDEAS: Crucial to ensure public confidence, trust in new Cabinet line-up
Executive power over the Judiciary must be removed
Still a lot to do to advance science and innovation
Inequalities hamper efforts to end AIDS
Targeted subsidy is the way to go
Malay Rulers’ call to end racist, religious incitement timely and wise
Debunking the myths of dementia
No support for cashless aid payment
Of salaries and appointments to GLCs
Global rethink on subsidies

Others Also Read