Eswatini court rules first Trump deportees in jail have right to lawyer


FILE PHOTO: Protesters hold placards as lead applicant and lawyer Mzwandile Masuku addresses them outside the court, after today's hearing was postponed, in Mbabane, Eswatini, August 22, 2025. Activists are challenging a secretive agreement with former U.S. President Donald Trump's administration to accept third-country deportees, which they argue is unconstitutional. REUTERS/Zakhele Mabuza/File Photo

JOHANNESBURG, April 10 (Reuters) - ⁠A court in Eswatini has ruled that the first five migrants ⁠the Trump administration sent to the African kingdom have a ‌right to a lawyer, after they were denied legal representation on their transfer from the U.S. to a Swazi jail in July.

The court rejected a government argument that the detainees had ​not specifically requested the human rights lawyer Sibusiso ⁠Nhlabatsi represent them. Nhlabatsi has ⁠been trying to fight the migrants' case without access to them.

"There can be ⁠no ‌real harm in granting the Respondent access to the detainees," the three judges ruled in a decision reviewed by Reuters.

"If they do ⁠not wish to see the Respondent (they can) tell this ​to the Respondent ‌to his face," they said.

The detainees are among at least 19 ⁠third-country migrants - from ​various countries in Africa, Asia and the Americas - that Trump's administration deported to Eswatini as part of its crackdown on immigration. Other countries have also hosted migrants ⁠deported from the U.S.

The judgment only applies to ​the first five arrivals, as the challenge was first launched on their behalf, although it could set a precedent for the others. Eswatini, an absolute monarchy ⁠ruled by King Mswati III, has released only two of the detainees so far, a Jamaican man last year and a Cambodian last month.

Lawyers in Eswatini and the U.S. have challenged the legality of the $5.1 million deal between ​the two countries, which has resulted in deportees ⁠being incarcerated in the southern African nation despite having already served sentences for crimes ​committed on U.S. soil.

The high court last ‌month threw out a case filed by ​a local human rights lawyer that challenged the deal itself, though the lawyer has appealed.

(Reporting by Tim Cocks; Editing by Kate Mayberry)

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Others Also Read