Halkbank urges immunity from US prosecution in Iran sanctions case

  • World
  • Thursday, 29 Feb 2024

FILE PHOTO: A customer uses an automated teller machine at a branch of Halkbank in Istanbul August 15, 2014. REUTERS/Osman Orsal/File Photo

NEW YORK (Reuters) - Turkey's Halkbank drew skepticism from a U.S. appeals court panel on Wednesday, as the state-owned lender renewed its push to escape U.S. criminal charges that it helped Iran evade American sanctions.

Arguing before the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan, a lawyer for Halkbank said the bank was entitled to immunity under common law principles that date back more than two centuries, warranting the dismissal of the U.S. indictment.

But a Department of Justice lawyer told the three-judge panel it was up to the White House to decide when bringing charges was consistent with U.S. foreign policy.

Circuit Judge Joseph Bianco appeared to agree, telling Halkbank's lawyer John Williams that courts normally defer to the executive branch on foreign relations.

"How embarrassing is it that when something overtly affects the United States and is damaging our national security, that courts step in and tell the executive, 'Sorry, you can't act there,'" Bianco said.

U.S. prosecutors charged Halkbank in 2019 over its alleged use of money servicers and front companies in Iran, Turkey and the United Arab Emirates to evade sanctions.

Prosecutors said Halkbank helped Iran secretly transfer $20 billion of restricted funds, converted oil revenue into gold and then cash to benefit Iranian interests, and documented fake food shipments to justify transfers of oil proceeds.

Halkbank has pleaded not guilty to bank fraud, money laundering and conspiracy. Its case also complicated U.S.-Turkey relations, with Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan calling the U.S. charges an "unlawful, ugly" step.


In 2021, the 2nd Circuit said Halkbank could be prosecuted under the federal Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act because its alleged misconduct involved commercial activity that the 1976 law did not cover.

Last April, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed, saying Congress' desire to shield foreign countries and their instrumentalities from civil liability did not cover criminal cases.

But in a 7-2 decision, the justices said the 2nd Circuit should more fully consider whether common law immunity separately shielded Halkbank.

Williams, the Halkbank lawyer, said "numerous holdings of cases around the world" supported immunity, but Bianco suggested that only a 2004 case from France might be clearly on point.

"Isn't that the only case, the French case, in the history of the world?" he said. "This is new ground."

Michael Lockard, the Justice Department lawyer, said Halkbank's involvement in an "integrated comprehensive scheme" to evade sanctions should not be excused.

"For a foreign commercial bank, one that is majority owned by the state of Turkey, to launder billions and billions of dollars (to benefit Iran), to deceive banks, to lie to U.S. Treasury officials, that conduct is unprecedented," he said.

The appeals court did not say when it will rule.

The case is U.S. v. Halkbank, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 20-03499.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Bill Berkrot)

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In World

After COVID, WHO defines disease spread 'through air'
Trump hush money jury selection resumes as lawyers probe for bias
Indonesian volcano eruption forces evacuations, airport closure
Croatian ruling party wins polls, prepares for talks on forming government
India's election officials climb hills, ford rivers to reach voters
Dubai's flood aftermath, Malaysian travellers facing difficulties
3,000-member revenge porn group had underage victims, US officials say. Creator arrested
Flooded UAE counts cost of epic rainstorm, airport still facing disruptions
Parents find camera disguised as phone charger in girl’s room, US cops say. Man charged
Germany arrests two for alleged military sabotage plot on behalf of Russia

Others Also Read