Japan court upholds ban on same-sex marriage but voices rights concern


Plaintiffs hold placards outside the court after hearing the ruling on same-sex marriage, in Tokyo, Japan, November 30, 2022. Placards read "A step towards Marriage Equality". REUTERS/Kim Kyung-Hoon

TOKYO (Reuters) -A Tokyo court upheld a ban on same-sex marriage on Wednesday but said a lack of legal protection for same-sex families violated their human rights, a comment welcomed by plaintiffs as a step towards aligning Japan with other G7 nations.

Japan is the only G7 nation that does not allow same-sex marriage, and its constitution defines marriage as based on the mutual consent of both sexes.

Although Prime Minister Fumio Kishida's ruling party has revealed no plans yet to review the matter or propose changes, several senior members support same-sex marriage.

In Wednesday's ruling, the Tokyo district court said the ban was constitutional, but added that the absence of a legal system to protect same-sex families infringed their human rights.

"This is actually a fairly positive ruling," said Nobuhito Sawasaki, one of the lawyers involved in the case.

"While marriage remains between a man and a woman, and the ruling supported that, it also said that the current situation with no legal protections for same-sex families is not good, and suggested something must be done about it," he told Reuters.

Japan does not permit same-sex couples to marry or inherit each other's assets, such as a shared home, and denies them parental rights to each other's children, while even hospital visits can be difficult.

Though partnership certificates from municipalities cover about 60% of Japan's population, they do not give same-sex couples the same rights enjoyed by heterosexual couples.

The Tokyo ruling promises to be influential as the capital has an outsized influence on the rest of Japan.

It had been keenly awaited after hopes were raised by a 2021 ruling in the city of Sapporo that the ban was unconstitutional, although another decision in Osaka in June upheld the ban.

The eight plaintiffs in the case said the ban contravened their human rights and demanded damages of 1 million yen, although the court rejected that.

"This is hard to accept," said Gon Matsunaka, head of the activist group Marriage for All Japan.

Both heterosexual and same-sex couples should be able to benefit equally from the system of marriage, as everyone is equal under the law, he added.

"It (the ruling) clearly said that is not possible."

Yet the recognition that same-sex families lacked legal protections was "a big step", he said.

ENCOURAGING STEP

The plaintiffs, who unfurled a banner outside the courthouse reading, "A step forward for Marriage Equality" after the ruling, said they were encouraged.

"There were parts of this that were disappointing, but parts of it gave me hope," said one of them, Katsu, who gave only his first name.

The decision came a day after the U.S. Senate passed a same-sex marriage protection bill and Singapore lifted a ban on gay sex but limited the prospects for legalising same-sex marriage.

Two more cases are pending in Japan, and activists and lawyers hope an accumulation of judicial decisions supporting same-sex marriage will eventually push lawmakers to change the system, even if this is unlikely soon.

"I hope there will be legislative debate about this," said plaintiff Shizuka Oe. "We will keep making efforts."

The situation has limited the talent pool for global firms, as groups such as the American Chamber of Commerce in Japan have pointed out, calling for change.

"Thinking about the future of their lives, they don't see anything in Japan," said Masa Yanagisawa, head of prime services at bank Goldman Sachs and a member of the group Marriage for All Japan.

"So they move to more friendly jurisdictions, like the United States."

($1=138.1400 yen)

(Additional reporting by Rikako Maruyama and Kohei Miyazaki; Editing by Simon Cameron-Moore and Clarence Fernandez)

Article type: free
User access status:
Subscribe now to our Premium Plan for an ad-free and unlimited reading experience!
   

Next In World

Ukraine says it will not strike Russian territory with new missiles
Turkey says no concrete evidence of threat to foreigners after ISIS suspects detained -state media
Snow and winter storms cut power, disrupt traffic across the Balkans
Lantern Festival returns to Taipei after 23 years
Iran's supreme leader issues pardon for 'tens of thousands' of prisoners - IRNA
Lebanon hopes UNESCO danger listing could save crumbling modernist fairground
UK's shortest-serving PM Liz Truss blames economic 'orthodoxy' for downfall
South Korea searches for missing crew after fishing boat capsizes
Fierce fighting in north of Ukraine's Bakhmut, says Russian head of Wagner militia
Germany's Scholz: Putin has not threatened me or Germany - Bild

Others Also Read