PUTRAJAYA: An Arabic language teacher was hauled off to prison after the Court of Appeal sentenced him to 10 years' jail and two strokes of the rotan for sexually assaulting a female pupil in the school library seven years ago.
A three-judge panel chaired by Justice Mohamed Zaini Mazlan unanimously upheld the Muar High Court's conviction of Ahnaf Afiq Shairul Bazri, 35.
"The accused admitted that he had taken the victim to the study room and closed the door. His explanation was considered by the High Court but it was not enough to raise reasonable doubt.
"We find no reason to disturb that finding. After considering the totality of evidence, we are satisfied that the charge was proven beyond reasonable doubt," Justice Mohamed Zaini said here on Wednesday (Nov 18).
On the prosecution's cross-appeal to increase Ahnaf Afiq's prison time, the court agreed that the sentence was insufficient and did not consider the victim's age and Ahnaf Afiq's position of trust as her teacher.
"We agree this is a serious offence. The victim was merely eight and the accused, as her teacher, had abused his position of trust, we are unsatisfied with the sentence meted out by the High Court," he said.
Justice Zaini then set aside Ahnaf Afiq's original sentence of four years' imprisonment and two strokes, replacing it with eight years in jail.
The appellate court maintained the High Court's order for Ahnaf Afiq to serve an additional two-year term and two strokes of the cane under Section 16(1) of the Sexual Offences Against Children Act 2017.
The section provides for additional punishment if an offender commits a sexual crime while holding a position of trust over a child. The jail sentences are to run consecutively.
The appellate court also ordered Ahnaf Afiq to undergo counselling under Section 26 of the same Act and to be subjected to police surveillance for two years under Section 27 of the same Act, after the completion of his jail term.
Other judges on the panel were Justices Ahmad Shahrir Mohd Salleh and Dean Wayne Daly.
Ahnaf Afiq was charged with committing the offence against the then eight-year-old pupil in a school library in Muar between 10.20am and 11.20am on Oct 3, 2019.
He was accused under Section 14(a) of the Sexual Offences Against Children Act 2017, which carries a maximum 20-year prison term and caning upon conviction.
He was called to enter his defence by the Muar Sessions Court on March 25, 2024, after the prosecution established a prima facie case.
However, on March 19 last year, the same court acquitted and discharged him due to contradictions in the prosecution's witness testimonies.
The prosecution filed an appeal at the High Court.
On March 11 this year, the High Court overturned the acquittal and sentenced him to a total of four years' jail and two strokes of the cane, with additional sentence of two years in jail and two strokes under Section 16(1).
Ahnaf Afiq then filed an appeal to the Court of Appeal. He was out on RM10,000 bail pending his final appeal at the appellate court.
