Scientists have long posited the earliest water animals to transition to land had amphibious tadpole features, going through a metamorphosis akin to that of today’s frogs.
But new research out recently in the journal Science challenges that conventional assumption.
It presents analysis of rare fossils which scientists say fill knowledge gaps on the development of the creatures that gave rise to the first land-dwelling vertebrates.
The research centres on specimens excavated from the Mazon Creek fossil beds in northern Illinois, southwest of Chicago.
The world-renowned site features iron carbonate concretions that formed some 309 million years ago, fossilising within them ancient creatures that had once thrived in the area’s lush swamps, shallow seas and river deltas.
It’s known for its exceptionally well-preserved specimens including soft tissue.
The new study analyses dozens of fossils to examine the evolution between fish and tetrapods, or four-legged animals.
At the centre was a specimen determined to likely be the baby of a crocodile-esque creature known as an embolomere, which lived mostly in the water but did develop little legs.
In its juvenile stage, popular thought would have anticipated it to show tadpole-like features like external gills, explained Jason Pardo, a research associate at Chicago’s Field Museum and the study’s co-lead author.
But it didn’t, he said.
The body of the baby – the specimen of which the researchers said are about the size of a short, narrow macaroni noodle – instead showed evidence of direct development, meaning it was more or less put together the way they would be into adulthood.
That’s not what we would expect to see in amphibians, whose metamorphosis from tadpoles into adults includes much more dramatic rearranging and development of organs and limbs.
“We now actually have some direct fossil record evidence,” Pardo said, “that this metamorphosis, this amphibian-like life cycle that we’ve for 150 years assumed was part of our history, turns out that it wasn’t part of that at all.”
Glorious fossils
John Long, an Australian paleontologist who has also done extensive research in this field, called the study “quite outstanding.”
“Not much was known about their early life stages,” he said of the animals that gave rise to the first tetrapods.
“This detailed work on a bunch of simply glorious fossils nails it that they went straight into a juvenile phase so didn’t need to go through the tadpole stage.”
Jason Anderson of the University of Calgary said the “impressive” paper highlights “the power of fossils to address questions we thought impossible given they take place in short periods of time, and in tissues not normally preserved over hundreds of millions of years”.
Both he and Pardo also noted that the study underscores that amphibians are impressive evolutionary creatures in their own right.
“Our amphibians, instead of being relicts of earlier stages in the evolutionary history of tetrapods, are themselves highly evolved creatures,” Anderson said.
Love letter to citizen scientists
The fossil serving as the focal point of the study had been in the collections at the Field Museum for a long time when the then-director showed it to paper co-author Arjan Mann, who became enthralled.
While both were doctoral students in Canada, Mann and Pardo puzzled over it for years.
Eventual analysis with scanning electron microscopy at the Canadian Museum of Nature allowed researchers to confirm it as a probable embolomere.
Throughout their research the duo analysed that fossil’s juvenile features along with another, smaller embolomere and other species of fossil baby tetrapod relatives.
Mann – the Field Museum’s Assistant Curator of Early Tetrapods – noted that their research was made possible by the remarkable discoveries at the Mazon Creek site and the amateur scientists who for decades have combed it, a hobby that over the years turned up the specimens analysed in the paper.
“This paper, in a way, is kind of a love letter to them, that shows the power of what we can do with working together with this community to synthesise really high-impactful new research,” Mann said. – AFP
