Onion farmers cry foul at politicians’ price recipe

Price fluctuations: Farmers load onions onto a truck after an auction at a market in Nashik, India. Production expenses for the crop have more than doubled since 2017. — AFP

Nashik (India): Almost every Indian meal requires an onion – one of the cooking essentials along with sugar and lentils that sweet-talking politicians use to curry favour with their voters by lowering costs.

But their policies to cut prices by slapping export bans on some goods including on onions and sugar, or by allowing duty-free imports of lentils, has made the key voting demographic of farmers furious.

They say the politicians’ decisions flood the markets, and that the savings shoppers make are at their expense.

“The governments talk a lot about us,” said onion farmer Kanha Vishnu Gulave. “But their actions only hurt us – to keep the easily agitated city people happy by keeping our produce cheap.”

Gulave, 28, comes from India’s onion-producing heartland of Nashik district in Maharashtra state, which produces some 40% of onions nationwide.

He felt cheated when prices crashed after a sudden export ban in December.

“We dread elections,” said Bharat Dighole, onion producers’ association president for Maharashtra. “The most unwise interventions come around polls.”

After the ban, prices dropped to sometimes less than a third, Dighole said.

That sparked dozens of small-scale protests in Maharashtra.

At the same time, production expenses have more than doubled since 2017, Dighole added.

But the slump in wholesale prices meant that was not passed on to the consumer – or voter, from the politicians’ viewpoint.

They paid the same for their onions as they had done for years.

“All polls are fought in the name of farmers, but the government policy clearly favours the consumers,” said Dighole.

India will vote on Saturday in the seventh and final phase of a general election, stretched over six weeks to ease the logistical burden of polls in the world’s most populous country.

Two-thirds of India’s 1.4 billion people draw their livelihood from agriculture, accounting for nearly a fifth of the country’s gross domestic product.

In India, onions can be a barometer of a government’s popularity.

Runaway prices have triggered mass protests and toppled governments in the past.

In 1998, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) of Narendra Modi – at the time a local politician – lost control of the capital Delhi in state elections.

The defeat was widely blamed on voter anger at high onion prices.

While Prime Minister Modi is expected to sweep a third term in the ongoing national elections, the BJP has been out of power in the capital’s state legislature ever since.

Days before voting began in the onion belt of Nashik, Modi’s government lifted the export ban.

But analysts called that a political ploy.

“The opening up of the onion market is nothing but rhetoric,” said economist Ashok Gulati, from the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations.

Gulati said restrictions remained – including a minimum export price and 40% duty – and made exports unviable, leaving farmers teary-eyed.

“Our best hope is to not sell for a loss,” 30-year-old farmer Akshay Tarle told AFP at an onion auction, where lines of trailers piled high with the vegetable waited.

“When I leave home in the morning I don’t even know if I’ll be able to sell my produce at the right price,” added another farmer, Vikas Babaji Tushare.

“My family ask me to buy things on my way back home, but there are days I don’t even have the money,” the 36-year-old added.

“I don’t even know what to tell my children.”

Gulati warned export bans and unchecked imports of other products such as lentils – a key staple and protein source for many – were distorting markets and hurting producers.

India’s import of pulses jumped to a six-year-high of around US$3.75bil in 2023-2024, according to commerce figures cited by Indian media.

“Duty-free import of pulses would dent the progress made in domestic production,” Gulati said.

But some hope for change.

“People at the top fear that if onion prices rise, governments will fall,” said Jagannath Bhimaji Kute, 58, vice-president of a wholesale onion market in Nashik.

“Whoever comes to power next will have to address our issues.”

Kute urged Indians to “think about the farmers”, questioning why people swallowed rising prices on fuel and cooking oil, but not food.

“Why must what we produce remain cheap, when everything else is getting more expensive?” he said. — AFP

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!


Next In Business News

Banking industry meets credit growth target in 1H
Alphabet in talks to buy cybersecurity startup
Saudi Arabia stress-tests its economy and stretches petro wealth
Interim Credit Suisse review blasts regulator
Not all Vietnam firms interested in franchise model
ECB may prime markets for September rate cut
Need for central climate funding body
Wall Street pushes back after protests escalate
Manufacturers up investments in services trade
Thai economy faces upheaval due to factory closures

Others Also Read