Four reasons Pax Silica may violate Philippine laws: Comment


MANILA: BCDA President Joshua M. Bingcang has claimed that PAX Silica will operate under Philippine laws. That claim cannot stand because PAX Silica, as it is being pushed, already proceeds in violation of the laws that are supposed to govern it.

It is not a project that follows the law and then builds. It is a project that builds first, promises compliance later and asks the Filipino people to accept the consequences as inevitable. The four grounds below show why the claim of legality is false.

First, there is no feasibility study on which an Environmental Impact Assessment, or EIA, and an Environmental Compliance Certificate, or ECC, can be based.

Under Presidential Decree No. 1586, or the Philippine Environmental Impact Statement System, an environmentally critical project cannot proceed without a full EIA. An ECC cannot be issued without a scientific basis for predicting, evaluating and mitigating the project’s impacts on water, air, land and communities.

Yet, as of August 2026, the Department of Environment and Natural Resources itself had reported that no EIA for PAX Silica had been applied for or processed.

How can BCDA claim that the project will operate under Philippine laws when the foundational document required by law — the feasibility study showing how much water, power and land the project will need, how much waste it will produce, where its water and power will come from, and what will happen to surrounding farms and communities — does not exist?

The figures now being debated — 3 gigawatts of power, 39 billion litres of water per year, 20,390 to 20,780 hectares for solar farms and reservoirs, and a heat island effect of 4.5 to 6 degrees Celsius that will make rice farming nonviable within 12 to 15 kilometers — are not from BCDA.

They are from independent scientists who were forced to do the work that BCDA and its proponents should have done before promoting the project.

A project without a feasibility study, an EIA and an ECC is not operating under the law. It is operating outside it.

Second, BCDA claims the land is theirs. What about the Indigenous Peoples Ancestral Domain Claim Zone, or IPADCZ, of the Aetas?

The 1,620-hectare site at New Clark City in Capas, Tarlac, is not empty land. It is within the ancestral domain claim and traditional territory of the Aeta Indigenous Peoples, who have lived, farmed, hunted and buried their dead in those mountains and forests long before BCDA existed, long before Clark existed and long before PAX Silica was conceived.

Under Article XII, Section 5 of the 1987 Constitution, the state shall protect the rights of Indigenous cultural communities to their ancestral lands.

Under Republic Act No. 8371, or the Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act of 1997, no project can proceed in ancestral domains without the free, prior and informed consent, or FPIC, of the Indigenous Peoples concerned, obtained in accordance with their customary laws and after full disclosure of the project’s impacts.

BCDA cannot simply declare that the land is its own because it holds a title or proclamation. Ancestral domain is a pre-existing right recognized, not granted, by the state.

To ignore the IPADCZ of the Aetas, proceed without FPIC and treat the Aetas as squatters on their own land would directly violate IPRA and the Constitution.

A project that displaces Indigenous Peoples without their consent does not operate under Philippine laws. It violates them.

Third, what about pollution and the Filipino people’s right to a balanced and healthful ecology?

Article II, Section 16 of the 1987 Constitution provides that the state shall protect and advance the people’s right to a balanced and healthful ecology in accord with the rhythm and harmony of nature.

In Oposa v. Factoran, the Supreme Court held that this right belongs to present and future generations and can be enforced by every citizen.

PAX Silica threatens that right at every level. Its artificial intelligence data centers will consume 130 million liters of water per day for cooling and semiconductor manufacturing, which requires ultrapure water, and will produce wastewater containing chemicals, heavy metals, complex organic compounds and pathogens.

Its power demand of 3 to 5 gigawatts will require massive fossil fuel or solar expansion and will release waste heat that will raise field temperatures to 45 to 47 degrees Celsius, causing rice spikelet sterility above 35 to 36 degrees Celsius and making farming nonviable in the core zone.

Its mining expansion will cause deforestation, river siltation and watershed contamination.

The Filipino people have a constitutional right not to be poisoned, not to have their water taken, not to have their farms rendered unproductive by heat and not to have their children inherit degraded land.

To claim that PAX Silica will operate under Philippine laws while it threatens the ecological right guaranteed by the Constitution is a contradiction. The law does not allow the state to give away the people’s right to a healthful ecology for the profit of foreign AI and semiconductor companies.

Fourth, under Executive Order No. 122, 9 million hectares are deemed open to mining. That is equivalent to about one-third of the Philippines being opened for such use.

The Philippines has a total land area of about 30 million hectares. Nine million hectares is 30 percent, or nearly one-third, of the entire country.

Executive Order No. 122, signed Aug 18, 2026, opens that vast area to critical mineral mining exploration, reservation and one-stop-shop fast-tracking, representing a 1,000 percent increase over the present 813,575 hectares of approved mining projects.

Article XII, Section 2 of the Constitution provides that the exploration, development and utilization of natural resources shall be under the full control and supervision of the state and that the state shall protect the nation’s natural wealth for the benefit of the Filipino people.

It does not authorise the president, by executive order alone, to open one-third of the country to foreign mining companies for AI, semiconductor and military production without Congress, Senate concurrence for a treaty, an EIA or FPIC.

That is not the exercise of state control. It is the surrender of state control.

When nine million hectares are opened, permits are fast-tracked, FPIC is weakened and minerals are linked to the war-production value chain of PAX Silica, the Philippines is no longer the owner of its patrimony. It becomes a supplier of raw materials, cheap labor, water and energy for other countries, while Filipinos are left with mined-out mountains, polluted rivers and displaced communities.

For these four reasons, the claim that PAX Silica will operate under Philippine laws is wrong.

A project without a feasibility study violates PD 1586. A project that ignores the IPADCZ of the Aetas violates IPRA and the Constitution. A project that pollutes water, heats farmland and destroys watersheds violates the people’s right to a balanced and healthful ecology.

And a project that opens 9 million hectares — nearly one-third of the Philippines — to foreign mining under Executive Order No. 122 violates the constitutional principle that natural resources are under the full control and supervision of the state for the benefit of Filipinos.

PAX Silica does not operate under Philippine laws. It operates above them, around them and against them.

Until the feasibility study is shown, the EIA is completed, the ECC is issued, the FPIC of the Aetas is obtained, and the Senate and the people have given informed consent, the project must not proceed. - Philippine Daily Inquirer/ANN

Dr Teodoro C. Mendoza, PhD is a former professor of crop science and sustainable agriculture at the University of the Philippines Los Banos.

 

 

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In Aseanplus News

Gen Z activists revive three-finger protest movement to oust Thai PM
Siblings killed in Tawau house fire
Japan PM Takaichi walks tightrope with Russia, China on Asia trip
Australia police charge Sydney man with terror offence
No 'big brother' in PN-BN talks, says Dr Sam
Three taken to hospital, 30 evacuated after Singapore kitchen fire at HDB flat
Five caught using smart devices to cheat in South Korea’s college entrance exam
Once unthinkable, Trump-Xi-Putin summit makes Russia and Beijing the biggest winners
Civil servant nabbed at KLIA for bringing undocumented foreigner into the country
MACC and China's NCS look to strengthen cooperation against corruption

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read