BANGKOK: Thailand’s opposition is preparing to scrutinise the government’s trade negotiations with the United States after President Donald Trump announced major tariff concessions that were not detailed in a joint statement signed by the two countries’ leaders.
Prime Minister and Interior Minister Anutin Charnvirakul and Trump signed the joint statement on an Agreement on Reciprocal Trade (ART) in Manila, the Philippines, on Nov 17.
The statement confirmed that Thailand and the US had reached substantial agreement in their negotiations. However, it did not constitute the final trade agreement, which must undergo further legal and domestic approval procedures before taking effect.
The signing has prompted questions from the opposition People’s Party, particularly over the tariff concessions Thailand may be required to make and the extent of parliamentary oversight.
Anutin has defended the agreement, insisting that Thailand would not have signed the statement if its interests were being compromised.
He argued that Thailand already had free trade agreements and similar commercial arrangements with several countries, and that the proposed agreement would create further opportunities for Thai agricultural exports.
Anutin described the US as Thailand’s largest trading partner and a market with considerable purchasing power, referring to its population of nearly 400 million.
Trump, meanwhile, presented the proposed agreement as mutually beneficial, outlining several commitments he expected Thailand to undertake.
According to the US president, Thailand would eliminate tariffs on American exports and remove significant non-tariff trade barriers affecting vehicles, medical equipment, pharmaceuticals, ethanol and poultry.
Trump also announced plans for Thailand to purchase an estimated US$2.6 billion in additional agricultural products from the US.
These concessions were outlined in Trump's remarks at the signing ceremony, rather than specified in the joint statement itself.
Sirikanya Tansakul, a People’s Party list MP and deputy leader, questioned the transparency of the signing, arguing that the government had not disclosed sufficient information about the proposed trade arrangements.
She noted that agreements involving other countries had generally provided clearer information about the tariff rates involved.
In Thailand’s case, however, she argued that the public had yet to see the relevant details, raising questions about the precise nature of the agreement reached with Washington.
Sirikanya described the signing as puzzling and criticised the government for failing to clarify the tariff commitments announced by Trump.
She pointed out that Deputy Prime Minister and Commerce Minister Suphajee Suthumpun had indicated that the agreement was not yet fully finalised and that tariff reductions would not take immediate effect.
Nevertheless, Trump had publicly outlined substantial concessions, including the elimination of tariffs on US exports to Thailand.
Sirikanya questioned why Anutin had not challenged the US president’s remarks or clarified whether his account accurately reflected Thailand’s commitments.
She also criticised the government's position on confidentiality, questioning why Thai officials maintained that negotiation details could not be disclosed while Trump was able to discuss specific terms publicly.
Despite the political controversy, the joint statement does not mean that the final ART agreement has entered into force.
Thailand and the US must first complete the remaining legal drafting and domestic procedures.
Under the process outlined by the Thai government, both sides will refine the agreement's legal wording before Thailand submits the draft to the Cabinet for consideration and approval of its formal signing.
The government will then conduct public consultations and use the findings when submitting the agreement to Parliament for approval.
The ART agreement can take effect only after both countries have completed their respective procedures.
Thailand's 2017 Constitution, under Section 178, requires parliamentary approval for certain international treaties, including those that could significantly affect the country's economic or social security, trade or investment.
The provision also covers treaties involving territorial changes, the exercise of sovereign rights, legislation required for implementation, free trade arrangements and the use of natural resources.
However, the requirement does not apply automatically to every international agreement. It depends on whether the agreement falls within the categories specified in the Constitution.
For treaties requiring approval, Parliament must complete its consideration within 60 days of receiving the matter. If it fails to reach a decision within that period, approval is deemed to have been granted.
Section 178 also allows the Cabinet to refer questions about whether a treaty requires parliamentary approval to the Constitutional Court, which must deliver its ruling within 30 days.
Unlike the procedure available under Thailand's 2007 Constitution, the current provision does not give MPs and senators a direct route to petition the Constitutional Court on this particular question.
The parliamentary approval process has drawn comparisons with a Constitutional Court ruling concerning a joint communiqué signed by Thailand and Cambodia in 2008.
The statement concerned Cambodia's efforts to secure World Heritage status for the Preah Vihear temple.
In rulings No. 6–7/2551, delivered on July 8, 2008, the Constitutional Court determined that the joint communiqué constituted an international agreement under Section 190 of the 2007 Constitution.
The court unanimously recognised the document as an international agreement and subsequently ruled by eight votes to one that it required parliamentary approval before signing.
The judges considered that the communiqué could affect Thailand's territorial interests and national security.
That case arose under the 2007 Constitution, which provided a different mechanism for MPs and senators to request a constitutional ruling.
The current controversy therefore centres on whether the eventual ART agreement meets the requirements of Section 178 and whether the government's approval process provides sufficient parliamentary scrutiny.
Sirikanya has expressed concern that parliamentary consideration could become little more than a formality if the government has already made substantial commitments during negotiations.
She questioned how effectively opposition MPs could challenge the agreement once its terms had been settled between the two governments.
Although the government maintains that the final agreement will require further approval, Sirikanya believes the lack of publicly available details makes it difficult to assess the implications for Thailand.
The opposition is now expected to gather information on the ART negotiations and examine the government's handling of the agreement.
The issue could become a focus of political scrutiny ahead of a possible no-confidence debate against Anutin's government in early December 2026, before the parliamentary session ends.
For the government, the immediate challenge is to clarify the concessions under negotiation and demonstrate that the eventual agreement protects Thailand's interests while complying with the constitutional approval process. - The Nation/ANN
