Insight - Informal workers in South-East Asia: Resourceless, yet resourceful

Working as street vendors, construction and agriculture workers, waste pickers, home-based and domestic workers, drivers and increasingly, “gig economy” workers, their contribution to national economies is crucial.

INFORMAL workers dominate the region’s labour market in both urban and rural areas. More than half of the workforce in most South-East Asian countries earn their living in the informal sector, with the proportion surpassing 80% in Cambodia and Myanmar.

The exceptions are Singapore, Brunei and Malaysia, where formal workers dominate.

Working as street vendors, construction and agriculture workers, waste pickers, home-based and domestic workers, drivers and increasingly, “gig economy” workers, their contribution to national economies is crucial. Yet, governments in the region barely recognise their value, as highlighted by the scant attention they were given in their country’s Covid-19 response.

A review of the literature conducted for the Khon Thai 4.0 Project found that South-East Asian governments followed a short-term approach directed at addressing only the most immediate socioeconomic impacts of the pandemic.

Stimulus packages

Their response has entailed stimulus packages to sustain the economy and, to a lesser extent, social protection measures to somewhat shield those most affected.

To hasten implementation, these measures have utilised and leveraged preexisting systems, usually dominated by social insurance schemes such as pensions, social security funds, unemployment benefits and health insurance that favour salaried employees in the formal sector.

Meanwhile, social assistance schemes for the poor, such as welfare assistance, cash or in-kind transfers, and health and disability assistance, have proven insufficient as a stopgap in view of the prolonged pandemic, especially in those countries that have scarce resources or are dependent on donor support for relief efforts.

Informal workers without secure contracts are “invisible” in government systems, lacking legal recognition and being ineligible to register for official schemes. Moreover, they tend to fall through the cracks, as they are not covered by social insurance schemes but are also not considered “poor enough” to qualify for social assistance.

Teething problems

The delayed government response, often in the form of cash transfer social assistance, has been fraught with unreliable registration data, bureaucratic rules, miscommunication and in some cases, corruption.

Complaints have been widespread among eligible beneficiaries unable to receive their entitlement, while those who did have been disappointed at the inadequate assistance.

Unable to work because of containment measures or diminished opportunities, informal workers across the region, many of them women, lost their livelihoods without receiving any income compensation or social security support.

As for those who were able to work reduced hours when containment rules allowed, their incomes were no longer sufficient to buy food and healthcare needs for their families. Even if they were recognised as “essential workers”, such as delivery workers in the thriving gig economy, there has been a vacuum in support.

Left to fend themselves, informal workers remain at high risk of infection and falling into increased debt and poverty. In Cambodia, a United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) survey in late 2020 found that pessimism and anguish were rife among informal workers, with similar sentiments echoed in neighbouring countries.

Despite the overwhelming Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) rhetoric of “leaving no one behind”, the pandemic is showing that social protection systems in South-East Asia are not tailored to the needs of informal workers and other vulnerable groups.

With the realisation that Covid-19 will last longer than expected, it is imperative to better protect such a large proportion of the workforce. Although governments continue to dismiss their plight while worrying about disrupted macroeconomic fundamentals and shrinking state budgets, informal workers are not remaining idle.

Joining hands

Around the region, informal workers are organising and taking action to support each other during the crisis, all the while working to ensure a more just and protected future. Their efforts in mutual assistance and sense of volunteerism have helped other informal workers to cope with Covid-19 infection and deaths, as well as to access vaccines.

To make their plight visible, gig workers in the creative industries in Singapore, Malaysia and other countries have launched the “I Lost My Gig” campaign to publicly gather data on job and income loss and provide resources for financial support.

Informal workers’ cooperatives in Tangerang, Banten, assisted their members to overcome the bureaucratic barriers in applying for government assistance, lobbied relevant ministries to distribute masks and personal protective equipment, and obtained loan and debt relief for members who had lost their incomes.

In Thailand, networks of informal workers’ groups joined forces to raise funds to support their members, produced a video to help informal workers navigate the process to access government aid and lobbied the Ministry of Labour for more generous measures. Idea, a group of tuk-tuk, taxi and motorcycle taxi drivers, street vendors, and small restaurant workers in Cambodia established in 2005 to promote and protect the rights of informal workers, is exposing the hardships its members have experienced as a direct result of the pandemic and demanding access to the same benefits granted to salaried workers. Common agenda

To ensure that they do not remain unprotected, informal workers’ organisations are using their Covid-19 experience to advocate for legal and institutional reforms.

They argue that governments need to finally recognise the existence, size, relevance and permanence of informal workers and reform the existing regulatory systems to fully integrate informal workers and their needs. The narrow aim to move informal workers into regular, formal employment does not reflect the dynamics of the region’s labour market.

Homenet South-East Asia, a regional network of informal workers’ organisations, is reviewing national social protection benefits for informal workers and comparing these benefits to that for salaried employees and the poor.

Based on the resulting data, a common agenda is being formulated for advocating across the region that includes universal health care and social security, and inclusion in skills development and other government schemes. — The Jakarta Post/ANN

Rosalia Sciortino is associate professor at the Institute for Population and Social Research at Mahidol University in Thailand. The views expressed here are the writer’s own.

With this and other initiatives, informal workers are translating their activism born out of distress into a resourceful quest for a new social contract that assures protection and decent employment for all. — The Jakarta Post/ANN

Rosalia Sciortino is associate professor at the Institute for Population and Social Research (IPSR) at Mahidol University in Thailand and Director of SEA Junction. The views expressed here are the writer’s own.

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Subscribe now to our Premium Plan for an ad-free and unlimited reading experience!


Next In Business News

Perodua's sales up by 5% in 3Q
Rich mainland Chinese snap up luxury homes in Singapore despite tax hikes
PETRONAS declares force majeure on gas supply to Malaysia LNG -Mitsubishi
Weaker refining, gas trading to hit Shell's Q3 results
Asian shares climb, oil extends gains after OPEC+ deal
MYEG partners Mimos in developing national public blockchain
Bursa continues to push higher on Budget hopes, oil price rally
Cosmos debuts strongly on ACE Market at 50 sen, foresees strong demand for products
EPF partners Ally Logistic Poperty to build Bukit Raja logistics hub
Ringgit opens flat as greenback firms up on improved US jobs data

Others Also Read