PETALING JAYA: The Football Association of Malaysia (FAM) and seven naturalised players have seen their appeals decisively dismissed by the FIFA appeal committee in one of the most severe sanctions in recent memory for the use of forged documents to secure international eligibility.
The ruling, passed on Nov 3, concludes a staggering case that involved a “deliberate mechanism” orchestrated to circumvent eligibility rules for players who, in the committee’s words, had “no connection whatsoever with Malaysia.”
Here’s where it all went wrong for FAM and the seven players.
FORGED ANCESTRY AND FALSIFIED RECORDS
The heart of the scandal lay in the players’ attempts to meet FIFA’s stringent criteria for national team eligibility, which typically demands a player prove a genealogical link, such as a parent or grandparent born in the country.
To achieve this, the FAM submitted birth certificates for the players’ grandparents during eligibility enquiries with FIFA.
A thorough investigation, however, exposed a calculated act of forgery.
FIFA found that original civil records from their countries of origin - Spain, Argentina, Brazil, and Holland - clearly showed the grandparents were born in their respective home nations.
The doctored certificates, supervised by FAM officials, systematically falsified this crucial information, altering the birthplaces to various Malaysian localities, including Melaka, Penang, Johor, and Sarawak.
This deliberate and widespread tampering fabricated the essential genealogical connection required to play for the Malaysian national team.
The seven players were granted Malaysian nationality following a process overseen by the FAM.
During this procedure, the players signed application forms that falsely declared they had been resident in Malaysia for “no less than 10 years,” a claim the appeal committee noted was unequivocally untrue, as their naturalisation was not granted based on residency.
‘WILFUL BLINDNESS’ OF PRO PLAYERS
The appeal committee completely dismantled the players’ defence that they were merely “passive victims of an orchestrated scheme”.
While acknowledging the culpability of the FAM, the Committee ruled that the conduct of the professional athletes amounted to “wilful blindness and gross negligence.”
It stressed that, as professional footballers, they were expected to exercise “basic scrutiny” over the documents and declarations they were signing.
The committee highlighted a shocking lack of accountability, noting that the players admitted to having not read the documents, including the section stating 10 years of residency in Malaysia.
Furthermore, they failed to question how they could legitimately represent a country with which they had “no genuine connection”.
FAM’S CREDIBILITY ERODED
The Football Association of Malaysia’s officials were found to be in clear breach of Article 22 of the FIFA Disciplinary Code (FDC) for their involvement in the fraudulent submission.
The appeal committee were particularly scathing in their assessment of the national body’s integrity. While noting the FAM’s “admission of guilt” regarding the tampering, the committee heavily criticised the organisation’s internal controls and overall credibility.
It was also “unimpressed” by the FAM’s public announcement regarding the suspension of their secretary general Datuk Noor Azman Rahman.
The committee observed that public reports indicated the suspended official continued to appear at high-profile events, a move they viewed as a mere public relations exercise designed to shield the FAM from the true consequences of their actions, thereby undermining the credibility of the entire disciplinary measure.
The fraudulent efforts provided an “undue sporting gain,” enabling the players to participate in official matches, including the AFC Asian Cup 2027 third-round qualifiers, where two of the players scored decisive goals.
