Garbage in. Garbage out


A vast, 120-hectare moonscape of toxic, foul-smelling and suppurating waste; this huge dump (the largest uncovered landfill in Southeast Asia) serves the 32 million-strong Jakarta conurbation. Estimated to contain over 39 million tonnes of garbage, (7,000 tonnes are being added daily) it should reach its full capacity of 49 million tonnes by 2021–if not sooner.

Ibu Suki Sri, now 52-years old, started scavenging at the facility when it first opened thirty years ago. Back then, the rubbish was deposited in a series of craters left behind by quarrying activity. Three decades on, Bantar Gebang – at least from a distance – is more like a range of hills: ten small hills to be exact.

Ibu Sri no longer combs through the trash herself. She has become a collector, managing a team of scavengers who in turn hunt for plastic bottles, straws, medical plastic containers (low density polyethylene/HDPE plastic), shoes, aluminium, metal and tin. Once sorted, graded and cleaned, the trash has some economic value: a sack of plastic bottles can be sold for IDR5000 per kg, HDPE’s fetch IDR7000 per kg.

Still, Ibu Sri is unsentimental about the prospect of it having to close by 2021, noting that: “I don’t think Bantar Gebang will be closed anytime soon. But if it does, I’ll just move to another dumpsite. Wherever the trash goes, I’ll follow.”

There are Bantar Gebang‘s all over Southeast Asia, from Tondo in Metro Manila to Da Phuoc in Ho Chi Minh City, and they are testimony to a fundamental flaw of the economic growth and prosperity narrative that we have all accepted as the gospel truth.

Economic value: Once sorted, graded and cleaned, the trash can be sold for money – a sack of plastic bottles costs about IDR5000 per kg, HDPE’s fetch IDR7000 per kg.

In short: we have been sold a lie because the unfettered consumerism and consumption that underpins our lives is unsustainable.

Every tube of toothpaste, shampoo bottle, yoghurt cartoon, confectionary wrapper and flimsy pink plastic shopping bag ends up in somewhere like Bantar Gebang, Tondo or worse, is still floating somewhere in the open seas off our shores.

The desperate lie at the heart of our current economic model was made all the more glaring when, just over eighteen months ago, on 31 December 2017, Chinese authorities decided to ban the import of waste materials.

Dubbed the “National Sword” policy, they dealt a near-fatal body-blow to the USD200 billion strong global recycling industry: the consequences of which are still being felt across Southeast Asia, Europe and North America.

Ibu Suki, who has been living in Bantar Gebang since 1989, says if the dumpsite in Bantar Gebang is closed, she’ll just move to another dumpsite and follow the trash wherever it goes.

Basically, an entire “do-gooder” ecosystem of recycling bins, depots and incinerators has evolved to allow Western consumers to think that they can continue their profligate ways without harming the environment.

Well this is nonsense. In fact, it is rubbish.

The ecosystem was only workable as long as the Chinese were willing to import the detritus of Western consumerism: from hazardous waste to plastics and e-waste.

When the Chinese realised, albeit belatedly, the impact of the presence of millions of tonnes of waste on their own environment, they changed their minds and the entire edifice collapsed.

The biggest loser has been the Western idea – now revealed as little more than a fraud – that recycling of all this waste is even possible.

We now know that recycling isn’t cost-free. Nor is it an environmental good.

The Bantar Gebang landfill is predicted to reach its maximum capacity of 49 million tonnes of waste by 2021.

As Southeast Asia drowns in thousands of tonnes of hazardous waste – most of which comes from the smug and hypocritical nations of the global north, the recriminations on both sides have been bitter.

Earlier this month, Indonesia decided to ship back 49 containers of contaminated waste to the United States, Australia, France, Germany and Hong Kong.

Malaysia, in May, shipped back 3,000 tonnes of plastic to 14 origin countries. Meanwhile, the Philippines returned 69 containers to Canada, accompanied by the usual anti-Western bluster of President Rodrigo Duterte.

The fact is that Southeast Asian countries can barely manage their own garbage, much less handle the West’s.

Back in Jakarta, there are plans to create a US$250mil intermediate treatment facility (ITF) zone by 2022 that can store 2,200 tonnes of waste to replace Bantar Gerbang.

Plastic bottles from various brands end up in Bantar Gebang. Jakarta produces at least 7,000 tonnes of waste a day, and 1,900-2,400 tonnes of which is plastic waste.

But that will probably not be enough given that the city, as noted, produces 7,000 tonnes a day.

And even if more landfills could be created –it doesn’t solve the fundamental issue of what the people of Jakarta – indeed, of Southeast Asia and the world – are eventually going to do with all the garbage 21st Century living and consumerism produces.

Calls for both manufacturers and individuals to change their practices or habits can only go so far. They only sweep the problem under the carpet – or in Bantar Gerbang’s case – pile it even higher.

Technology – and global integration – have clearly failed us in these counts.

A 50-metre high mound of garbage just by the entrance of Bantar Gebang Integrated Waste Processing Area.

Exporting your trash as the Europeans and Americans have been doing (albeit surreptitiously) is hypocritical and self-defeating.

All societies need to face up to the impossibility of ever managing the mountain of trash that our Fast Moving Consumer Industries (FMCG) are generating.

What is required is a total overhaul of the sale and distribution of FMCG. Waste management will only be short-term and temporary if we don’t reeducate consumers, producers and retailers. Anything in between will fail.

Until then the Bantar Gebang’s of Southeast Asia will continue to mushroom and grow.

The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect those of the Sunday Star.


   

Across The Star Online